Inigo’s comment > Likes and Comments
Like
Woww I think this is hugely harsh! I think she cared very much but was put under a lot of pressure in terms of deadlines. It does feel rushed and was a little disappointing but at least she tied up everything and didn't leave us wondering what happened. I agree it could have been better but it's definitely not the worst by a long shot! You should consider buying her future novels, as it seems unfair to judge the entirety of a writer's work on the last 150 pages of one book :)
what was wrong with it i liked the way it ended and i don't think it was rushed and i'm sure she did care about the books that now have movies and are making her more and more of a millionarie
I didn't judge her on the last 150 pages, I judged her on all three books in their entirety...and they suck. The first was tolerable (barely), but the second was 'enh' and the third was miserable. It baffles me how so many sheeple can like this drivel. It's the best example of a 'non-character' hero I've ever seen. If I were a girl I would be supremely pissed that the leading character --the girl who is supposed to be a role model to all other girls-- is such a complete wuss. From half way through book two all she does is cry, whine and turn into quivering jelly whenever a boy is around. It's the literary equivalent of being told in real life to "just stand there and look pretty while us men do everything" because that's exactly what happens.
Inigo wrote: "I didn't judge her on the last 150 pages, I judged her on all three books in their entirety...and they suck. The first was tolerable (barely), but the second was 'enh' and the third was miserable. ..."
there is something wrong with you those books were very good books i know everyone has an opinon but that is too harsh and just sayn if it wasn't good it wouldn't be a movie!
Just because a lot of dimwits en mass think some crap is good, doesn't really make it so. If you really thought that was a good story, I'm happy for you. However, I suspect that you're also very easily entertained. Perhaps next they'll make some 'Dick and Jane' movies for you to enjoy too.
Inigo wrote: "Just because a lot of dimwits en mass think some crap is good, doesn't really make it so. If you really thought that was a good story, I'm happy for you. However, I suspect that you're also very ea..."
thank have a fun boring life while i try and enjoy mine btw i am not easily entertained i just have something you don't....... an imagination. try and get one
What in the world does imagination have to do with anything? It's not like I didn't get what the writer was conveying (that means 'what they were trying to explain'...so you don't have to look it up). I just think it wasn't done well. That is my opinion. You don't have to like it, but there is nothing that you can do to change it.
ok i'm just saying the ending wasn't as bad as you make it out to be sure it wasn't the best in the world but it was a good ending at least it had one it's not that bad of an ending!
back to top
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Layla
(new)
Nov 02, 2013 02:58AM
Woww I think this is hugely harsh! I think she cared very much but was put under a lot of pressure in terms of deadlines. It does feel rushed and was a little disappointing but at least she tied up everything and didn't leave us wondering what happened. I agree it could have been better but it's definitely not the worst by a long shot! You should consider buying her future novels, as it seems unfair to judge the entirety of a writer's work on the last 150 pages of one book :)
reply
|
flag
what was wrong with it i liked the way it ended and i don't think it was rushed and i'm sure she did care about the books that now have movies and are making her more and more of a millionarie
I didn't judge her on the last 150 pages, I judged her on all three books in their entirety...and they suck. The first was tolerable (barely), but the second was 'enh' and the third was miserable. It baffles me how so many sheeple can like this drivel. It's the best example of a 'non-character' hero I've ever seen. If I were a girl I would be supremely pissed that the leading character --the girl who is supposed to be a role model to all other girls-- is such a complete wuss. From half way through book two all she does is cry, whine and turn into quivering jelly whenever a boy is around. It's the literary equivalent of being told in real life to "just stand there and look pretty while us men do everything" because that's exactly what happens.
Inigo wrote: "I didn't judge her on the last 150 pages, I judged her on all three books in their entirety...and they suck. The first was tolerable (barely), but the second was 'enh' and the third was miserable. ..."there is something wrong with you those books were very good books i know everyone has an opinon but that is too harsh and just sayn if it wasn't good it wouldn't be a movie!
Just because a lot of dimwits en mass think some crap is good, doesn't really make it so. If you really thought that was a good story, I'm happy for you. However, I suspect that you're also very easily entertained. Perhaps next they'll make some 'Dick and Jane' movies for you to enjoy too.
Inigo wrote: "Just because a lot of dimwits en mass think some crap is good, doesn't really make it so. If you really thought that was a good story, I'm happy for you. However, I suspect that you're also very ea..."thank have a fun boring life while i try and enjoy mine btw i am not easily entertained i just have something you don't....... an imagination. try and get one
What in the world does imagination have to do with anything? It's not like I didn't get what the writer was conveying (that means 'what they were trying to explain'...so you don't have to look it up). I just think it wasn't done well. That is my opinion. You don't have to like it, but there is nothing that you can do to change it.
ok i'm just saying the ending wasn't as bad as you make it out to be sure it wasn't the best in the world but it was a good ending at least it had one it's not that bad of an ending!
