Questions About Existentialism is a Humanism

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Existentialism is a Humanism, please sign up.

Answered Questions (5)

I've read version that contained 28 pages. Was it full version, or I've read only some excerpt?

Paolo In my edition, the first 20 pages were an introduction and the last 23 pages contain a discussion between Sartre and some of the questioners that chal…moreIn my edition, the first 20 pages were an introduction and the last 23 pages contain a discussion between Sartre and some of the questioners that challenged some points in Sartre's exposition. The actual content of Existentialism & Humanism (Sartre's lecture) spanned some 45 pages in relatively large print. So it could be that you have read an excerpt, or maybe the print in your edition was small enough to reduce 45 pages to 28.(less)

flag

what page is the quote "existence preceeds essence?

Jeff The first use of that phrase is on p.20 of the edition that i'm reading:
"What [Christian and atheist existentialists] have in common is simply their b…moreThe first use of that phrase is on p.20 of the edition that i'm reading:
"What [Christian and atheist existentialists] have in common is simply their belief that existence precedes essence; or, if you prefer, that subjectivity must be our point of departure."

(Yale University Press, copyright 2007; translation by Carol Macomber)(less)

flag

I am stuck on this part "Consequently, when I recognise, as entirely authentic, that man is a being whose existence precedes his essence, and that he is a free being who cannot, in any circumstances, but will his freedom, at the same time I realize that I cannot not will the freedom of others." Why can't man not will the freedom of others?

Hippie Shawn Man cannot will the freedom of others because not all others believe that they can will what they want. A man can only try so hard to explain and pass…moreMan cannot will the freedom of others because not all others believe that they can will what they want. A man can only try so hard to explain and pass on the word, but if people want to live in bad faith and not want to have to be responsible for their actions, then people will not embrace their freedom. People who believe that life does have a preordained meaning and believe that we already have an essence will not have to worry about these types of issues and concerns; they just ride the wave. After all, as beings that exist, we each have our own subjective reality and the way of experiencing things, so naturally, not everyone will fallow the same path or be deemed as a truth from another viewpoint.

If you continue reading further, Sartre basically explains what he means. It is right after what you quoted:

"Thus, in the name of that will to freedom which is implied in freedom itself, I can form judgments upon those who seek to hide from themselves the wholly voluntary nature of their existence and its complete freedom. Those who hide from this total freedom, in a guise of solemnity or with deterministic excuses, I shall call cowards. Others, who try to show that their existence is necessary, when it is merely an accident of the appearance of the human race on earth – I shall call scum. But neither cowards nor scum can be identified except upon the plane of strict authenticity."

Be true to yourself without caving in from other pressures and "norms". (less)

flag

May I ask how to understand the Sartre's quote “Promote a rogue and he’ll sue you for damage, knock him down and he’ll do you homage”? If it means that a rogue, or a thug, preys on the weak but submits to those fighting back towards him, then this is not a good reference to support what Sartre stated next that these are sayings asking people to be obedient and submit to power. Appreciate your enlightenment.

Hippie Shawn Usually mayonnaise needs to be left in the fridge after being opened.

flag

What's the difference with this book and nausea. Which should I read?

Low amount of books read Nausea: Long story
This book: No story, short philosophy essay that explains Existentialism…moreNausea: Long story
This book: No story, short philosophy essay that explains Existentialism(less)

flag

Unanswered Questions

About Goodreads Q&A

Ask and answer questions about books!

You can pose questions to the Goodreads community with Reader Q&A, or ask your favorite author a question with Ask the Author.

See Featured Authors Answering Questions

Learn more