Questions About The Alchemyst (The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel, #1)

by Michael Scott (Goodreads Author)

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about The Alchemyst, please sign up.

Answered Questions (26)

Is this Nicolas Flamel the same guy in HP?

Matt Yes and no. To start with, you have to know that Nicholas Flamel was a real person. Flamel was a book seller in 15th century France and it is legend t…moreYes and no. To start with, you have to know that Nicholas Flamel was a real person. Flamel was a book seller in 15th century France and it is legend that he actually discovered the codex, a legendary book that contained the most coveted secrets of alchemy, one of them being how to create the philosephers stone, which is sometimes called the sorcerers stone and does NOT produce the elixir of life: it actually turns any object it touches into gold. the recipe to the elixir of life was also rumored to be in the codex. I should also mention Perenelle was actually Flamels wife in real life too. But I digress. The Flamels in both the Immortal Secrets of Nicholas Flamel series and Harry Potter and the sorcerers stone (originally the philosopher's stone) are not the same person, which would connect the series. However, both Flamels are based off the same person who actually existed. FUN FACT: Michael Scott, author of the book of which we speak, actually wrote a book analyzing the sorcerers stone. He then expanded on the concept of Nicholas Flamel actually living forever and wrote his own series.(less)

flag

Was looking at this book and read some not so interesting reviews. But then again there have been bad reviews and to me the product is amazing. For those who have read it, did you enjoy it or is not worth the time?

Amy This was a fast paced, exciting book. I read it because it was a required read for my son and we like to talk about the books we read. While targeted …moreThis was a fast paced, exciting book. I read it because it was a required read for my son and we like to talk about the books we read. While targeted to young adults, I found it extremely entertaining and went on to read the rest of the series's, which just kept getting better with each book. My son and I had a lot to talk about! (less)

flag

I have a 2nd grader with a very high reading level (she is consistently reading books in the 5th-7th grade level) and she has asked to read this series, having just finished the first couple Harry Potter books. Any concerns, given that as parents we were fine with her reading Harry Potter and she did very well on those quizzes? Anything in this series that pushes beyond the messages in those books?

Julia It's absolutely fine. It's really just a fun read, much like Harry Potter.…moreIt's absolutely fine. It's really just a fun read, much like Harry Potter.(less)

flag

Can 12 year olds read this? Its for my brother and I dont really want him to be introduced to sex and dark stuff.. Thanks!

Sparklesome Yes, there is nothing of that sort. I'm in 8th grade, and this was one of the books our teachers picked for us to read and so it is appropriate. The b…moreYes, there is nothing of that sort. I'm in 8th grade, and this was one of the books our teachers picked for us to read and so it is appropriate. The book is just magic and things like that and for the dark stuff (it's not like depression or things like that) its dark as in like magic and villains and stuff, its a pretty safe book. (less)

flag

Can these be read as standalone?

ev._.lyn reads No, they generally end open-ended with many signs that there will be a next book. If your fine with starting a book series and not reading the rest of…moreNo, they generally end open-ended with many signs that there will be a next book. If your fine with starting a book series and not reading the rest of the books and you don't mind a inconclusive ending that points to many more things in the next book then it should be fine. The book doesn't end on the biggest cliff-hanger so it isn't that bad! 😀(less)

flag

Load 5 more questions