Top 100 Mysteries & Thrillers on Goodreads

Posted by Cybil on April 30, 2017

Mystery & Thriller Week is sponsored by The Fact of a Body, a Goodreads Best Book of May.


Culprits, spies, bad guys, and women with vendettas: There's something so very satisfying about spending your time with the criminal element. And by that, we mean following the clues and solving the capers when you sit down with a great mystery or thriller. Always in search of a great book, Goodreads recently set out to uncover your 100 most-loved thrillers and mysteries.

There are, of course, rules to this game. Namely, every one of these books has at least a 4.0 rating from the Goodreads community. That means it's a bit of a popularity contest, for example Gone Girl is represented with a 4.02 rating, but another girl—Girl on a Train—just misses the list at 3.88. Then there are the usual suspects you won't find on this list: The Maltese Falcon (3.92), Angels & Demons (3.85), and Strangers on a Train (3.84) among others. It may seem brutal, but the readers have spoken.

Of course, many of your favorite writers have stayed with a character for a while, so in the cases of serialized mysteries and thrillers, we picked the books that, again, are over 4.0 and have the largest number of ratings.

It's time to unveil the top 100 Mysteries & Thrillers on Goodreads, arranged in alphabetical order. How many have you read? Tell us in the comments.

1st to Die

A Fatal Grace

A Great Deliverance

A Red Herring Without Mustard

A Scandal in Bohemia

A Study in Scarlet

A Time to Kill

Absolute Power

Along Came a Spider

American Tabloid

And Then There Were None

Big Little Lies

Black Betty

Blindsighted

Burial Rites

Child 44

Clear and Present Danger

Confessions

Crocodile on the Sandbank

Dead to the World


Dissolution

Double Indemnity

End of Watch

Eye of the Needle

Fatal Voyage

Fer-de-Lance

Finders Keepers

Fingersmith

Gaudy Night

Gone Girl

Gorky Park

Heaven's Prisoners

I Am Pilgrim

I Let You Go

Journey Under the Midnight Sun

Killing Floor

L.A. Confidential

Love You More

M is for Malice

Mean Streak


Murder at the Vicarage

Murder on the Orient Express

Mystic River

Naked in Death

No Country for Old Men

One for the Money

Patriot Games

Postmortem

Presumed Innocent

Rebecca

Red Dragon

Red Harvest

Relic

Rules of Prey

Shroud for a Nightingale

Shutter Island

Storm Front

Tell No One

The Alienist

The Beekeeper's Apprentice


The Big Sleep

The Black Echo

The Blessing Way

The Bone Collector

The Bourne Supremacy

The Boys from Brazil

The Camel Club

The Day of the Jackal

The Devotion of Suspect X

The Forgotten Garden

The Full Cupboard of Life

The General's Daughter

The Girl Who Played with Fire

The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo

The Godfather

The Hound of the Baskervilles

The Hunt for Red October

The Innocent

The Likeness

The Lincoln Lawyer


The Long Goodbye

The Murder of Roger Ackroyd

The Name of the Rose

The Odessa File

The Poet

The Secret History

The Secret Keeper

The Shadow of the Wind

The Silence of the Lambs

The Silkworm

The Snowman

The Spy Who Came In from the Cold

The Surgeon

The Westing Game

This Present Darkness

Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy

Triptych

Two for the Dough

Watchers

When the Bough Breaks


Tell us how many you've read in the comments! And be sure to check out more of our Mystery & Thriller Week coverage here.

Fact of the Body

Comments Showing 251-300 of 473 (473 new)


message 251: by Courtney (new)

Courtney 17/100 and quite a few were also on my TBR list. Some of these were my favorites! A few I wouldn't really classify as either mystery or thriller (Burial Rites).


message 252: by Lisa (new)

Lisa 28


message 253: by Donna (new)

Donna Krebs I've read 9 and seen 4 as movies. Oh, I am reading one now, also.


message 254: by Bonnie Lynn (new)

Bonnie Lynn Only 48. Thanks for this list. I'll have to start reading faster.


message 255: by Lew (new)

Lew 22 of 100


message 256: by Garden (new)

Garden Girl I've read 18 of these great books. Read many of these authors, but not the particular books listed i.e. I've read many James Lee Burke, but not the one listed; Louise Penny; and am surprised there are no Donna Leon or Ruth Rendel books included.


message 257: by Jodi (new)

Jodi Read: 15 but many more are ony TBR. I see several to add to my TBR.


message 258: by Sai Shashanka (new)

Sai Shashanka 11 + 5 movies.


message 259: by Andrew (new)

Andrew I've read only 5 of these, but happen to be currently reading another on the list-- Stephen King's Finders Keepers. So I will have read 6 of them soon.


message 260: by Erika (new)

Erika I've read 4 of the mentioned 100. But! I did read all 13 of the Sookie Stackhouse series :)


message 261: by Kate (new)

Kate Marie wrote: "It seems to me you've mixed up detective stories and thrillers, which are two different genres (although they often overlap)...."
I totally agree. A lot of these books I have, and never will, read because they are 'thrillers' which I don't care for. Generally their plots are thin as paper whereas the mystery writers tend to have much more complex plots. Also I found there is a lot of violence in the thrillers which really puts me off books If you can't write a book without gouts of blood or sexual abuse I don't think much of you or your writing.


message 262: by Carole (new)

Carole Evans 40! And watch tv adaptation of a couple more!


message 263: by Doris (new)

Doris 15 . Amazed there are no Graham Hurley and Peter May books on this list. Peter May's Island Trilogy are some of the best books I've read :)


message 264: by Christine (new)

Christine Parker What a great idea this was! Am loving reading the responses.
How about a retro reads week? That would bring some great stuff back to the surface.


message 265: by Christine (new)

Christine Parker Or books translated from their original language


message 266: by Dirk (new)

Dirk 13 books. It would be 15 if I could remember if I had read Agatha Christies works. But thats nearly 30 years ago. It's sad that no books of Ian Rankin are under the top 100. In my opinion he is one of the best thiller authors of the las decade.


message 267: by Del (new)

Del Deborah wrote: "Five of 100"

Five for me too


message 268: by Leigh (new)

Leigh 30/100, with a few more on the 'To Read' pile.


message 269: by Martin (new)

Martin I've read 12 from the list. Really looking forwards to diving into some of the others listed.


message 270: by Kim (new)

Kim 18, but most of them when I was younger. It is a genre I don't read much in any more.


message 271: by Sean (new)

Sean O 17 out of 100. I have read a couple of sequels to other books mentioned as well.
Great list.


message 272: by Ian (new)

Ian Hunter 31, more than I had expected.


message 273: by Leslie (new)

Leslie 8/100


message 274: by ScrappyMags (new)

ScrappyMags I think it was about 30. Not too bad. Some of these I disagree with (I'm sure many do). Uh that Janet Evanovich novel is chick lit IMO with a mystery thrown in. I HATED that book.


message 275: by ScrappyMags (new)

ScrappyMags Robin wrote: "Cheryl A wrote: "37/100. Remember, it's based on GR popularity. Great classic titles and authors are sorely missing and whoever thought Agatha Christi and Janet Evanovich would be on the same list?..."
Yes!!! I wish the cozy mystery and chick lit mysteries were omitted but I like my mysteries down and dirty lol!!


message 276: by Cheryl (new)

Cheryl 22/100. Surprised so few, better get reading.


Paris        (kerbytejas) 9/100 several more on my TBR list


message 278: by Arielle (new)

Arielle 9/100

7 are on my want to read list. I'm sure I'll be adding more though!


message 279: by Janice (new)

Janice I've read 12.

Camilla Lackberg is a favorite of mine, surprised she's not in the top 100, her books are great.


message 280: by Sue (new)

Sue Wright 12 and many others not on the list but equally as good.


message 281: by Neila (new)

Neila 38 read, and many more on my Want to Read list.


message 282: by Judi (new)

Judi Ferrari 7


message 283: by Chiara (new)

Chiara 8 out of 100. Most of the other are on my "want to read" list!


message 284: by Nuria (new)

Nuria G It's 24 for me.


message 285: by Donna (new)

Donna 54; love he Elizabeth George series ; notably missing are Jussi Adler-Olson and his Dept. Q series which are wonderful and Martha Grimes and her series with Melrose Plante and so many others, including James Abel and Steven James


message 286: by Azmira (new)

Azmira 5/100. still have a long way to go..


message 287: by Cupof (new)

Cupof Tea Robin wrote: "I'm a big mystery fan, but not really a thriller fan. I was surprised to find that I had only read 27 of these. I've read some in the same series as the book listed - like Ludlum's Bourne Identity ..."

Yes, I'm also a big fan of Ellen Raskin and Laurie R King :)


message 288: by Thomas (new)

Thomas Janick 31


message 289: by Mike (new)

Mike I really enjoy Qiu Xialong's Inspector Chen series as well as the Inspector O series by James Church.


message 290: by Nancy (new)

Nancy  Price 40


message 291: by Yani (new)

Yani Daniele 4 of 100, and my currently reading is Watchers - Dean Koontz


message 292: by Renn (new)

Renn It makes me so content to see all the Holmes stories on the list.


message 293: by [deleted user] (new)

I've read 18. I'm surprised it's not more actually. At least 60 were on my 'to read' list though!


message 294: by Piet Hein (new)

Piet Hein I have read 24/100, and 6 more were already on my to read list.


message 295: by Linden (new)

Linden 17/100 Some I have read more than once.


message 296: by Kim (new)

Kim I've read 26 and got 11 on TBR.


message 297: by Beth (new)

Beth Wynne 40.


message 298: by Cindy Courtney (new)

Cindy Courtney Read 14. Another 7 are on my "want to read" list. And saw others as movies or TV shows. I don't really care for character series in which most of the titles wind up as mass market paperbacks at the drug store...


message 299: by D (new)

D 16/100... Disappointed to see one of my favorites, Stuart Woods' "Palindrome," did not make the list!


message 300: by Linda (new)

Linda I've read 61/100 if I counted correctly...I love the genre!


back to top