Your Computer Doesn't Know Anything

Jerry Coyne at Why Evolution Is True responded to my recent post defending libertarian free will, in which I pointed out that certain aspects of the mind -- intelligence and will -- are inherently immaterial. Because intelligence and will are immaterial, they cannot be yoked to matter deterministically, and are thus free in a libertarian sense. Coyne of course disagrees and raises some (uncommonly) thoughtful questions about the immateriality of intellect and will. I'll reply to Coyne soon,...