A Reviews Editor's Guide to Writing Reviews... Fast!

I've been writing reviews for more than 20 years... movie reviews... theatre reviews... and, of course, book reviews.

For the past eight years, I've also been the reviews editor for several business, investment and self-help magazines.

The blank screen can be overwhelming. So much so that you don't put into words your thoughts about the books you've read.

In my role, I haven't had that luxury. To write reviews fast, I've developed a system. The secret is that reviews have their own structure. Follow the same structure. You'll write readable reviews that cover all the bases.

You won't feel overwhelmed thinking about writing them. You'll know where the finish line is before you start.

Here's the format I follow for 200-word reviews (later I'll show you how to adapt it to longer reviews):

HOOK

OVERVIEW
General
Specific
Specific
Specific

EVALUATION
Claim
Proof
Proof
Proof

RECOMMENDATION

Hook: no matter what you write, your opening has to latch hooks into your reader's eyeballs and reel them into the rest of your piece of writing.

Overview: You want to give readers an idea of what the book's about. Tell part of the story if it's fiction. Describe the sections or chapters if it's non-fiction.

Your first sentence gives the big picture view. Then in the following three sentences you give your reader details that fill out that first sentence.

Evaluation: This is where you give your judgment of how well the author achieved their intent.

Your first sentence makes a claim about the book. "The author's idea's work." Then in the next three sentences, you offer evidence to support your claim. "One way I know her ideas work is that I applied them in my own life... and got results."

Recommendation: Almost every book published through a mainstream publisher will have a home with the right reader. In this final section, you let your reader know who would be a good fit for the book.

So how do you write longer reviews? Simply repeat the structure in the Overview and the Evaluation sections. For 750 word reviews, such as the ones I write for M/C Reviews - 'words', I make two extra general statements about the book and two extra claims. Then I give the details to establish my point.

Reviews are simple and fun to write. They give you a chance to articulate why you're passionate about a book you loved. Or think through the reasons for a book you loathed.

Have fun writing reviews.

Do you have any lingering questions? Ask them in the comments and help this article become a more useful resource.
2 likes ·   •  3 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on December 07, 2014 02:00 Tags: daniel-g-taylor, how-to, reviews, writing-craft
Comments Showing 1-3 of 3 (3 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Clifton (new)

Clifton Hill Well said. I love to write reviews, but get hung up on them all the time. Not because I don't have a structure, but because I want to pick apart every aspect of what was good and bad.

Informational, but holding me back from sharing the love of good books.


message 2: by Daniel (new)

Daniel Taylor Clifton wrote: "Well said. I love to write reviews, but get hung up on them all the time. Not because I don't have a structure, but because I want to pick apart every aspect of what was good and bad.

Informationa..."


Totally get where you're coming from, Clifton. Writing reviews for print -- both book reviews and theatre reviews -- means I need to accept that good enough and done is better than perfect and unfinished. Happy reviewing!


message 3: by Clifton (new)

Clifton Hill This is true. Break the Perfect-Seeker Bone, it does us no good.


back to top

Notes From Daniel's Writer's Studio

Daniel G. Taylor
Random ramblings from a full-time writer, carer and lover.
Follow Daniel G. Taylor's blog with rss.