Ruth Graham in her article
Against YA chides adults who read YA for their lack of sophistication and intellectual rigor. After I read her article the first thing that popped into my head was Ruth Graham shaking her fist at me while yelling "Get off my lawn!" And being a YA author I was offended by her blunt and disparaging remarks of a genre I had chosen to write me first novel in. However I'm a mature adult, father, and author so I attempted to craft a few labyrinthine responses that articulated my feelings. Unfortunately the only thing I could write that had any panache was 'Your momma!' Frustrated I re-read the article and realized that my initial synopsis was wrong. Ruth wasn't besmirching all adults for reading YA but rather for not evolving their taste to more substantive literature. She was basically saying that YA should be a gateway drug that opens up doors to the hard core stuff like John Steinbeck and I actually feel her on this. Anyone who enjoys to read must experience the beautiful prose of Toni Morrison or the passion of Richard Wright. Which immediately made me feel better because I rationalized Ruth wasn't referring to me. She was referring to the intellectual fortitude of all you other day dreamers. I like Ruth after having gorged on YA in my youth require something more substantive to appease my literary appetite. You see me and my new hommie Ruth are made of sterner stuff. Feeling enlightened and armed with the knowledge that I kinda sort of agreed with a person taken seriously in literary circles, aim to share my new found wisdom to the ignorant masses as soon as I finish writing my 2nd YA novel. But I still can't get the image of Ruth shaking her fist at me out of my head.
Published on June 18, 2014 10:37
Admittedly, I have not read the article, so I won't say whether I agree or disagree with Ms. Graham; however, since I've read your blog post, I will say that I totally agree with you.
YA literature is amazing, but it's just the beginning and should open young kids to a whole world of words awaiting them, from Mark Twain to Zora Neale Hurston to Salman Rushdie to Gabriel Garcia Marquez and the list could go on and on.
I don't like the recent stigmatization of the YA genre - it puts everyone's defenses up over something quite ridiculous. As a nation who barely cares to open a book, we should be thankful folks are opening YA novels in droves. Moreover, how snooty to look down one's nose at the literary mark someone has left on this world simply because that mark might cater to a younger audience.
Everyone just needs to keep calm and grab a book.
And you are right - there is a ton more out there to read, loads of brilliant authors just waiting for kids to grab their books and get lost in their pages. I'm super hopeful that all this great YA lit will fuel a desire to discover Kerouac, Bukowski, Morrison, Irving, Butler, and more.
Fingers crossed...