Moms' Reviews and Sudoku Puzzles

    I don’t have a great relationship with my family. After many years of doing everything I could for them and getting nothing in return, except shit on, I decided to stop helping. We still talked, but I started getting a lot less calls from them when they realized I wasn’t bailing them out (literally or figuratively) anymore. This went on for a while, until a few years ago, when I went through a horrible personal tragedy. I spent a few months drinking as much as I could and thinking about killing myself every second that I was awake. A few of the people in clan McClellan did the bare minimum to be supportive of me during that dark time in my life. Most did less.
    I’ve heard a lot of people speak negatively about book reviews from friends and family. I don’t really see the problem. Did you write a book? Did your mother leave you a review on Amazon? Good for you! I don’t have any reviews from my mother. When I told her that I had self-published a book about zombies, she acted like I had told her I made an amateur pornographic movie. When I told her my second zombie novel was going to be published by Severed Press, she acted like I had told her I’d just made a professional pornographic movie. She hasn’t read either of my books. No one in my family has. None of them have given me any reviews, either. Of course, if I ever make any real money as a writer, it will be because of their tireless efforts to support me and their constant encouragement and hey, where’s my cut? I do have a couple of friends’ reviews on my first book, but nothing from my family.
    There’s a lot of talk about negative reviews and bullying and that sort of thing these days. People are pretty passionate about the subject. There are a lot of folks who go to great lengths to defend the rights of reviewers to leave negative reviews, whether the reviewer finished the book, or even read the first page. I’ve noticed, though, that a lot of those same people are the ones who will trash your reviews from friends and family. Personally, I’m a big fan of freedom of speech. Everyone should be allowed to give their opinion, no matter how well or ill informed they are on the subject. Saying that someone has to read an entire book from start to finish in order to be able to give their opinion is like saying that someone needs to be completely knowledgeable of every issue before they are allowed to vote. Ideally, yes, that would be how it would work, but that’s not the way it is in a free society. If you disagree, let me ask you this: Are you a conservative? Do you have an opinion on a book that you haven’t read? Maybe one by Michael Moore or Noam Chomsky? How about the liberals reading this? Same question, but say the book is by Ted Nugent or Bill O’Reilly. I’ll bet there’s a book out there that you haven’t read but you have an opinion on. That’s okay, though, because you’re entitled to your opinion. Conversely, just as someone who didn’t finish a book is entitled to their opinion on it, so is the author’s mother, or sister, or BFF, or anyone else that the author knows.
    I don’t have a great support system like a lot of authors getting started do. I barely have ties with my family, and only have enough real friends in the non-virtual world to count on one hand and have fingers left over. I do have some friends on Facebook and Goodreads, but having internet friends is kind of a new concept to me. If you have a really supportive bunch of family and friends that want to read your book and leave their honest opinion of it on a website, there’s nothing wrong with that. Is their opinion somewhat skewed because they know you? Of course it is! That’s okay, though. It’s still their opinion and they are still entitled to it. News networks are allowed to give their skewed opinions, why can’t an author’s mom?
    Let me tell you about a little obsession of mine. I love to do puzzles. All kinds of puzzles, but Sudoku puzzles in particular. If I start one, I HAVE to finish it, or something really bad will happen. I don’t know what this horrible occurrence will be, or why I think it will take place, I just know that if someone calls when I’m in the middle of one, I have to call them back later. Even the hardest Sudoku puzzles have a few gimmes. You don’t have to take them, but solving the puzzle without them is going to be exponentially harder than it should be. Life is hard enough already. Take the gimmes. Selling books is hard. There’s nothing wrong with taking a few gimme reviews, as long as they’re honest reviews. If your mom isn’t ashamed of what you do, and wants to leave a review for your book, she absolutely should, and you shouldn’t feel the least bit embarrassed about it. While she’s at it, maybe you could get her to review One Undead Step , too!
4 likes ·   •  8 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on June 08, 2014 08:06
Comments Showing 1-8 of 8 (8 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Tonia (new)

Tonia Threlkeld Well put, Ian.


message 2: by Ian (last edited Jun 09, 2014 05:42PM) (new)

Ian McClellan Thank you, Tonia! You're one of my favoritest internet friends!


message 3: by Stephen (new)

Stephen Kozeniewski Hey, man, I don't talk about this a lot (at all, really, since it's taboo in our culture) but I have a similar nonlationship with my mother. Actually, "mother" is kind of a strong term. Ova donor, maybe?

Anyway, I didn't know about all this, but I do know what a good friend you've been to me, even if it is just an internet friend. And it does mean a lot. And, yes, I'll get my ass in gear and write that review. :P


message 4: by Ian (new)

Ian McClellan Stephen wrote: "Hey, man, I don't talk about this a lot (at all, really, since it's taboo in our culture) but I have a similar nonlationship with my mother. Actually, "mother" is kind of a strong term. Ova donor..."

Thanks brother, and don't sweat it. I know you've been as crazy busy as I have lately.


message 5: by Shellody (new)

Shellody I agree, well put. And sometimes, family or friends or not, they will give an honest review, so don't assume all reviews from friends are gimmes.

People need to step back a bit and think about how many friends and family would have to review a book before it skews the results...I mean, a five star rating with 5 reviewers isn't going to persuade me to read a book like a 5 star review from 1,000 reviewers. Furthermore, read the freaking description and see if it's a book you might like. If the subject matter is appealing, read a chapter or two--you can tell if the writing is to your standards in that amount of time.

In other news, I'm also a fan of puzzles, and not of Facebook games, but Facebook has a game called Riddle Stones that's sort of a cross between mine sweeper and Sudoku. I do not recommend trying it.


message 6: by Ian (new)

Ian McClellan Shellody wrote: "I agree, well put. And sometimes, family or friends or not, they will give an honest review, so don't assume all reviews from friends are gimmes.

People need to step back a bit and think about ho..."


Lol! Yeah, people put way too much into reviews, in my opinion. Read the description and the excerpt. That should tell you what you need to know.

I will stay away from Riddle Stones. I tend to get way too involved in that sort of thing. Had to give up the gaming years ago.


message 7: by Chris (new)

Chris Philbrook Well said sir.


message 8: by Ian (new)

Ian McClellan Chris wrote: "Well said sir."

Thanks, Chris! You're the best!


back to top