The Painful Truth About Facebook (with resulting radio interview)

Due to the heavy response to the following blog, I was asked to speak on the radio! My confession, I've learned, is a timely one and has resonated with many readers. Here is the resulting radio interview. Enjoy!

http://www.breakradioshow.com/archive...

And here is the original blog that started it all:

Believe me when I say I wish I could be all light, full of positive thoughts and love all the time. I strive for that. I really do. But let’s get human for a moment and accept I’ve got my work cut out for me as far as that ambition. So with that preamble, I’m going to be honest about something. And as I get ugly-real, I wonder if anyone else feels the same way I do. Are you ready for some brutal honesty? Here it is . . .

Facebook makes me feel bad about myself.

I know, I know—I shouldn’t take social media so personally or give it so much power. But if you engage with Facebook at any level I ask, how can you not?

Now, of course, I admit my insecurities are exasperated by being an indie author. The very nature of my day-to-day business is to market and promote my books since there is no publishing house doing it for me. However, this need results in a cluttered overflow of us indies fighting for readers, likes, and comments in social media. You can see how I’m setting myself up for disappointment. I’ve already put my heart on display through my writing, and now I’m seeking validation for my work through an unreliable interface such as Facebook. Rationally, I understand people don’t have the time to coddle us, but it still hurts my feelings and causes me to question my every move. It’s like being in high school all over again, battling through a popularity contest that no one can truly win.

Self-publishing, in that regard, has been enlightening. I’ve been floored by the generosity of perfect strangers going far and beyond to champion my books. But on the downside, I’ve been truly pained and confused by the lack of enthusiasm from some of the people I thought were my closest friends. I realize people are busy with their own lives, jobs, and family, but really, I’m talking about common courtesy here. The sort of attention one might give to any of their other friends on Facebook, or to their barista at Starbucks for a job well done. I don’t understand it. Perhaps they don’t grasp what it all means to me? Or maybe it’s their way of relaying they don’t give a damn about my hopes and dreams. Or, maybe, it could simply be they just don’t like books (gasp!).

But the torment doesn’t stop there, I’m afraid. Facebook makes me doubt friendships and even my own self worth. It happens when I peruse my newsfeed. It doesn’t escape me when other friends get a flood of likes for a changed profile picture or receive a staggering list of comments on a witty post (or even a boring post, for that matter). Although I don’t set out to compare, I can’t help but ask myself why I don’t garner equal attention. Why a friend commented on someone else’s post and not on mine. Isn’t that ridiculous? I know my family loves me. I know God loves me, so why have I fallen into this pathetic need of approval from other people? A form of approval that didn’t even exist a few years ago!

So, there it is. My honest, raw feelings about Facebook. For the most part it has not improved my life, but has added a new stress I was blissfully unaware of previously. It’s weakened friendships in my mind, whether warranted or not, and leaves me feeling empty.

Can anyone else relate to this or am I alone in these feelings? I would really like to know. Am I being too sensitive? Do I need Facebook therapy? Comment below. Or not.

Janine Caldwell
1 like ·   •  10 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on April 25, 2014 11:33 Tags: blogging, facebook, friendships, self-publishing, social-media
Comments Showing 1-10 of 10 (10 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Chris (new)

Chris Moreno I like your blog entry. It's interesting because I see Facebook enabling friendships and social interaction for me. I hated high school and was not the most social person I could be. Thanks to social media for making life more interesting to those that were in the shadows while everyone else was shining. Jealousies and envy are part if any social interaction real life or online. It's just exacerbated by Facebook.
As to your indie status, I can relate. I don't know why my friends don't come to our shows. I really want them to have a good time but everyone has a life to lead and decisions to make about their time. And you're right - some people don't read books including me! I have several friends whose books sit on my shelf in pristine condition. I'm honest and say I'll never read them but I'll tell other readers the books are great!


message 2: by Janine (last edited Apr 25, 2014 04:04PM) (new)

Janine Caldwell Chris wrote: "I like your blog entry. It's interesting because I see Facebook enabling friendships and social interaction for me. I hated high school and was not the most social person I could be. Thanks to soci..."

Thanks, Chris. I really appreciate that there are people who even read this post. Sometimes, you just don't know if you're ever touching anyone. I truly wanted to learn if people felt the way I do about social media. It feels pretty damn good and reassuring that I'm not alone. And I can understand how it can benefit people in the right setting.


message 3: by Lisa (new)

Lisa Owen-lynch Wonderful post. I am an "artist" and am constantly seeking validation. The evil component of Facebook, is that I think I'm marketing my art (I'm not, these people already know me)and get my feelings hurt when all of my friends aren't jumping on the bandwagon and spend their art dollars elsewhere, like target, HOWEVER. I recently tried to go through my friends list and thank everyone who has actually "transacted" with me through art by tagging them in a post, and it was up to 176 people and Facebook threw it out. I am incredibly thankful and will try again. But you are right on here. bravo!


message 4: by Janine (new)

Janine Caldwell Lisa wrote: "Wonderful post. I am an "artist" and am constantly seeking validation. The evil component of Facebook, is that I think I'm marketing my art (I'm not, these people already know me)and get my feel..."

Thanks for the comment, Lisa. FB sure has brought on an onslaught of new problems in our society and left us artists not exactly sure how and when to use it properly. So it's understandable that it's confusing and hurtful to us especially.


message 5: by Jodi (new)

Jodi Hale I have, for the very reasons you mention, stepped away from what was once my" daily Facebook musings" over morning coffee. It is also why I refuse to allow my 12-year old to have ANY kind of social media profile. He will get the backlash of not-so-constructive criticism soon enough in school.

I think it is easy for people to "like" and "comment" on superficial matters because they don't have to invest a lot of thought or time in the issue and don't have to take a moment - really PAUSE - to consider what is being shared.

It is the often self-absorbed nature we find ourselves in when we engage in the social media game: "I'm gonna take this post of yours and raise you 25 MORE likes!" ;-)

Step away for awhile. Keep writing your blog. The things that matter will get read by the people who need to hear them and who care about what what is being said.


message 6: by Katy (new)

Katy This is a interesting blog: I think the internet is the marketing tool of the future and having own and started several business marketing is 50% of any start up venture. But I learned years ago by doing network marketing , back then it was called mulit level. That your best and your worst cleints were your family and friends. It's hard to see all the wonderful things people are doing on facebook are they just blabbing about how great their life is ? But is Facebook just the new family photo ablum ? Take the way you wanted it. I don't think it was started to be use as a marketing tool. I think like u-tube it become one. I think for artist and business it's a great tool. Learn to separate the two . Build a page for your businesses and use the tools they give you to finding your market. I just learned how to do that with my new venture and for $5.00 a day, no contact spend what you can afford. I was able to to get 41 likes and my post went out to 141 people in 2 days. People I never met or knew. As for me I don't do much reading , but I know you and the passion you have. I love to support new artist. Stay strong you have a great talent and don't give up!


message 7: by Janine (new)

Janine Caldwell Katy wrote: "This is a interesting blog: I think the internet is the marketing tool of the future and having own and started several business marketing is 50% of any start up venture. But I learned years ago ..."

Hi Katy! Thanks for your input. Yes, I will keep on working at it--using my author Facebook page and using their promote option. I have done that in the past. I like what you said about your family and friends being your best and worst clients. That is so true! Hope you're doing well and thanks for taking the time to comment.


message 8: by Janine (last edited May 02, 2014 09:14AM) (new)

Janine Caldwell Jodi wrote: "I have, for the very reasons you mention, stepped away from what was once my" daily Facebook musings" over morning coffee. It is also why I refuse to allow my 12-year old to have ANY kind of social..."

Thanks, Jodi. Awesome advice. Yes, I do find it all to be a game of who is the most popular among authors, pimping their books. I've actually stopped following most of the authors I used to follow because it just wasn't healthy for me to hear about their real or fake success. Too many mind games going on when all I want to do is bury my head in my computer and write a new book. Got to get going on that! : ) Thanks for commenting, I appreciate it!


message 9: by Joann (new)

Joann Truax I appreciate your courage to be honest. I have had many of the same feelings about my work posts and so I did a little investigating.

I am not a FB expert, but I did discover that just because you are my friend on FB (even my best friends), you don't always see my posts. FB has an algorithm that determines which of your friends walls your post lands on and it's never on all of them. So my presumably ignored post may have never been seen by those who care about me most. And without those likes or comments, the post will virtually disappear, because the more likes and comments you have the more "interesting" the algorithm thinks the post is and therefore will post you on more and more walls. I realize your blog post goes deeper than that; however, the greatest validation for those using FB for work is when we sell our products or services because of the exposure. I am working on creating a stronger brand presence on FB by asking a group of "real" friends to seek out my posts daily and like, comment or share for me. Sometimes their life is busy I even have to remind them : ). But that's ok, because my "real" friends want me to succeed and don't mind the gentle nudge.

When used on a personal level social media communication can leave us both inspired and depressed. Somewhere in the words that are posted the truth might exist, but mostly it is a forum to puff our chest and say "look at me, I am here." We can't take that too seriously!

Used properly, FB is an amazing way to promote our businesses. Consider me one of your "real" friends. I will seek your work posts daily and like, comment and share. I want you to succeed!


message 10: by Janine (new)

Janine Caldwell Joann wrote: "I appreciate your courage to be honest. I have had many of the same feelings about my work posts and so I did a little investigating.

I am not a FB expert, but I did discover that just because ..."


Ah, Joann, thank you for your comments. Yes, I had an inkling of what you explained with the algorithm, which makes posting on FB that much more frustrating. Same thing happens on Amazon and why I encourage any and all readers to leave reviews because it makes the books more visible to other people. It's just all such a game I didn't realize I would have to be playing as an indie author. I suppose it's the same for traditionally published authors but they start off the gun with much more exposure that helps them from the get go. Thanks for being one of my "real" friends. : )


back to top