Defeated or not? Mr Storke fights back

Jason Storke continues to insist that he has in some way triumphed in the debate over his liberal beliefs on crime and punishment. Very well then. I shall continue to point out that he has, on any reasonable terms, been defeated.

I doubt if we can settle this matter here to his satisfaction, because his idea of the rules of debate is fundamentally different from mine (see below).

But for the benefit of those third parties who have followed this discussion, my account of the debate so far is...