date
newest »


I don't want a lot of background right at the beginning. I prefer it to be worked into the story. Perhaps I'm not a committed enough reader, but that's the way I read!


I hate info-dumps as much as most people. There's nothing I enjoy better than a skillful writer weaving all sorts of facts into the narrative. I also agree that every book needs something interesting to catch a reader's attention. I just think that interesting beginnings do not necessarily have to involve jumping headlong into an action scene right on the first page. Other readers, and writers, are free to disagree.

Maria wrote: "I don't think it has anything to do with instant gratification--for me, if there isn't SOMETHING of interest right away--characterization, a small mystery, a large mystery or action--I'm not going ..."
Maria,
Oh, I'm sorry, I didn't mean to imply that the story should not start with something of interest, quite the contrary, but I think there is a difference between intrigue and action.
Gabriel pointed out that headlong jumps into the action or the conflict are not necessarily the best ways to hook your reader.
What did I mean by the term "committed reader"? A committed reader simply being someone who has decided based on either their knowledge of the subject, their interest in the genre or their appreciation of the author, to read the work. ( Sorry for not being clear about that.
Instant gratification ! We live in a world where so much that we do and want are at our fingertips...and technology, rushing to meet the demand of the consumer, is ever endeavoring to make things easier and faster for us.
As a result of that, I believe that as a "society", we have inadvertently applied this need for "fast and instant" to our entertainment as well.
Authors rise to the demand of their readers, and it is clear from the trends that we are seeing today, that it is becoming a more common practice to "dive" immediately into the action in an attempt to "hook" our reader from the first word because let's face it, that's what readers are looking for now.
It is my thought that Amazon has seriously influenced this emerging style with the "Look Inside" option. It's a great marketing tool and it does help sell books. Readers have the opportunity to read the first chapter for free, helping them to decide whether or not to buy the book, however this applies pressure to the author, who may not prefer this style of introduction into the novel he/she has invested so much time, sweat and tears.

Bravo ! I agree totally, a good book is a "companion" for the length of time one spends reading it, but strong characters are friends for a lifetime :-)

Agreed Gabriel, very good points, which is what drew me to your post to begin with.

I do agree that Amazon, with sampling on the kindle and the "look inside" feature, has influenced readers. I sample almost all the books I download. I'm not sure it helps because sometimes the books DO start off with something very intriguing and then...get slower and less interesting from there! But I do count on those samples to get an idea of what the book is about, what the characters are like and whether the writing style interests me.
I can definitely say that it's rare for an action scene to HURT my impression, but if it is too dark a scene and not about the main character, it can. For example if a book opens with a murder scene (and we know later it will be about the main solving it) that can sometimes be too dark for me. I don't GENERALLY care to see inside the mind of the killer...but if that same scene is told through the eyes of the main, well, then I get to know a bit about the main and whether that character interests me.
If there isn't action, I want a quick sense that I'm going to like the characters or the writing style.
Because of the Look Inside and sampling, I really do think that authors have to have some very strong writing upfront. Backstory or wandering prose where the characters aren't making any headway to get to the plot don't help me. Too many descriptions of things/places...that doesn't give me a great feel for enough when I'm sampling.
I guess for me the story can't just start--it has to get going. That may not be action, but, for example, one of the books I sampled the other day, served only to introduce characters and some backstory. By the time I finished the sample I was wondering--so what is the mystery going to be? I couldn't even remember the blurb so I had just spent 15 minutes reading about a character going from A to B, meeting her brother, and also meeting some guy who wanted to date her and...nothing else happened. It was all nice and laid out and honestly...nothing happened. And I had no sense of what great mystery might lurk later.
Or some samples only take me as far as what the blurb has already told me--they haven't developed past that so it's like a longer, drawn out version of a nice, concise blurb!
Everyone is different. So it's good there are different types of stories.

I do agree that Amazon, with sampling on the kindle and the "look inside" feature, has influenced readers. I sample ..."
As an avid reader myself, I too rely upon the Look Inside and the samples. We're living in a wonderful age where there are more books available to us now than ever before in our history. What that means to we "book worms" is that we have more choices and options. For authors, it means unlimited opportunity to publish.
As an aspiring author myself, I have found that readers want way more information about a book prior to purchase, so I "try" to include as much info as I can in my blurbs without giving away spoilers in hopes that the combination of the two, blurbs and look inside feature, will give my readers a good idea of what type of story they are getting into.
Something that I am experimenting with, and I'm crossing my fingers on this is starting my stories, writing the first Chapter in almost the same fashion as a short story. I feature my main character and include a lot of foreshadowing about the coming action or conflict...It's my hope that this technique will give my readers what they are looking for when they "Look Inside".
(My editor and publisher are wrestling with me on this one, LOL )
I agree with you, too much backstory or prose can put a reader off. Let's face it, we're busy people, and I for one consider my reading time precious...so I can understand why the reader wants to know "more" before they commit to either purchase or read a novel.
It's really up to Authors today, to find more creative ways to hook their readers before the book ever leaves the shelf. I for one endeavor to find creative ways of doing so without jumping into the action or conflict.
Everyone is different as you say, and preferences vary.

I do agree that Amazon, with sampling on the kindle and the "look inside" feature, has influenced reade..."
I think your idea might work. I wrote Snitched, Snatched as a short story. I had many requests for a full novel and then wrote Dragons of Wendal as the follow on. I think the story was strong enough to grab people's interest in the "what happens next" or "I like this character and want to read more about her."
I don't do that all the time, obviously, but the idea of a beginning that actually moves the story or has enough going on...well, I think it's important. I notice it in my own reading. I want SOMETHING to happen in that first 30 pages and it has to be something other than background, setting and introducing characters. But that's me. I'm sure others like a more leisurely read or have time to "get to know" the characters through their daily lives/actions.
There are also different genres and they have conventions too. Thrillers don't have as much time to waste. Cozy mysteries can get away with more character driven events, especially after the characters are known and the reader is reading in part to "share time with characters they love." Urban Fantasy tends to mimic thrillers. Fantasy...can go either way. It's perhaps most common for fantasy to have a lot of background info, even at first. But I've definitely read fantasy that start with intrigue or battles/action/escapes.

I do agree that Amazon, with sampling on the kindle and the "look inside" feature, has..."
Yes, yes ! You're absolutely right, the genre has everything to do with the best way to bring your reader in.
I am currently contracted to write a series that has been classified as science fiction although I like to consider it "environmental fiction" with a little dystopia flavor added in. The action comes in the form of extreme weather. I was successfully able to implement some of this action in the first chapter in the first book, and it was pretty much written in short story format.
An appropriate opening for the second book in the series has presented quite another challenge as it HAS to be different, unique from the first book....my conundrum comes from my desire to make the second book capable of standing alone.
As a reader, I must confess that I love several genres, and base my choice for my next read on my mood or mindset at the moment, and you are absolutely correct, some genres are best started at a dead run while others are forgiven and even expected to have a leisurely beginning.
Hmmm, sounds like you are a fantasy writer ? I'm a huge fan of this genre although I have not enough imagination to write it well ! I admire authors who can create other worlds :-)

I do agree that Amazon, with sampling on the kindle and the "look inside..."
I write humorous mysteries and urban fantasy for the most part. Dragons of Wendal is pretty much fantasy, but I'd classify it as cozy fantasy rather than "epic" fantasy.
Second and third books do have unique challenges, that is for sure. You have to remember all the rules and details of the first...and how much backstory/reminding do you do...
Good luck. I predict you'll do just fine!

I enjoy a cozy fantasy from time to time, I will definitely check out your work, your reviews are stellar !
I must say that writing the first book and now the second has taught me volumes and at the very least, I hope this project grooms me to become the writer I dream of being someday :-)
Good luck to you as well !
Carolyn

I enjoy a cozy fantasy from time to time, I will definitely check out your work, your reviews are stellar !
I must say that writing the first book and now the second has taught ..."
Thanks. That bar as a writer keeps moving. I don't think I'll ever be *quite* as good as I WANT to be!
That just simply isn't true when dealing with a committed reader. A committed reader will appreciate stage setting and character development and the promise they make for a great story.
The problem is that we have grown into a society that expects instant gratification and we have extended that demand to literature. It is sad, but I'm afraid it is the way of it.
The big question that an author needs to ask themselves is who are they trying to reach. If a writer is interested souly in the number of copies that will sell, maybe he or she should concentrate on opening their story with a hook. If an author is interested in writing a story that will live in the mind of the reader years after they turn the last page, they should spend some "quality" time in the very beginning.
I for one prefer immortality !