The Thousand Autumns of Jacob de Zoet, by David Mitchell

It’s always interesting how one person can love a book, rave that it’s the best book ever, and the next person find it ho-hum. One of my book clubs selected Mitchell’s book at the urging of one member, backed up by glowing reviews. One professional reviewer called it a page-turner; for me, not so much.

Jacob de Zoet, an earnest and honest young man, comes to Japan in 1799—a five-year undertaking—to earn enough money to be acceptable to his fiancé’s father back home in The Netherlands. Jacob a...