Fight the Power?: Something about Samantha’s speech bothers me, big time

Yesterday,
on a cold, rainy Sunday morning, I sat and re-read this part of Ambassador
Power's Friday speech
advocating U.S.
intervention in Syria. I couldn't put my finger on it, but
this passage, which is the end of her talk, really irked me:
The
American people elect leaders to exercise judgment, and there have been times
in our history when presidents have taken hard decisions to use force that were
not initially popular, because they believed our interests demanded it. From
1992, when the Bosnian genocide started, till 1995, when President Clinton
launched the air strikes that stopped the war, public opinion consistently
opposed military action there. Even after we succeeded in ending the war and
negotiating a peace settlement, the House of Representatives, reflecting public
opinion, voted against deploying American troops to a NATO peacekeeping
mission.
... If we cannot
summon the courage to act when the evidence is clear, and when the action being
contemplated is limited, then our ability to lead in the world is compromised.
The alternative is to give a green light to outrages that will threaten our
security and haunt our conscience, outrages that will eventually compel us to
use force anyway down the line, at far greater risk and cost to our own
citizens. If the last century teaches us anything, it is this.
Earlier
in the speech, she says Americans are "ambivalent" about the situation. I don't
think they are. Yes, they think Syria is a problem, but they don't think it is
their problem.
So
I went off to cook up a vat of vegetable curry. Finally I realized what was
bothering me: Power's stance is profoundly undemocratic.
The American system is founded on the belief that the
people do indeed know what is best for them. So I
conclude that Power's argument is itself yet another reason not to intervene in
Syria -- if we have to erode our system to do it, it certainly is not worth it.
Thomas E. Ricks's Blog
- Thomas E. Ricks's profile
- 436 followers
