A Southern Accent Does Not Mean You're Stupid

Ladies and gentlemen, newsflash from this here rare bird who is just as comfortable living in the South as the North: Having a Southern accent does not mean you're stupid. I don't know why it's necessary for Southerners, and friends of Southerners, to have to explain this all the time, but it's very painful. I lived in South Carolina during my formative years, age six to 12, during the 1960s. I went to college and began my career as a newspaper reporter in Florida, covering alligator festivals and the like, and learning that Florida is almost as "rebby" as South Carolina. A pivotal moment for me, however, was earlier, when I was 12 and my family moved back north from South Carolina. I lost my accent (learned to hide it) by lunchtime on the first day of school. Ridicule doesn't even come close to describing the way Northern students (and teachers) treated me. Ironically, I started out in the North, having been born in Pittsfield, Mass.! To this day, it rankles me when I hear Northerners put down Southerners. And it goes on all the time. Last August, a Northern colleague dismissed my new novel without reading it, saying that she doesn't read "that Southern crap." Wow! That is beyond rude. I didn't realize how much my colleague's comment hurt until I noticed ever since that on Facebook and elsewhere, this same woman is a champion of tolerance who relentlessly declares her love for all of humankind (except, evidently, Southerners). My Northern relatives and friends can't understand why there's no progress or compromise on issues such as gun control, but is it any wonder? My fellow Northerners, listen to the way many of you talk to and about our Southern neighbors. If you belittle people, they're going to put their backs to the wall.
6 likes ·   •  9 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on July 02, 2013 10:11 Tags: accents, florida, northerners, south-carolina, the-north-south-divide
Comments Showing 1-9 of 9 (9 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Beth (new)

Beth Duke Amy, I moved from Alabama to Turbotville, Pennsylvania (I did not make that up) at the tender age of eleven--with an accent thicker and slower than sorghum syrup in an hourglass. Even when tested and placed in the "smartest" seventh grade class, most of my fellow students and a lot of my teachers treated me like I was likely to drool in ignorance when faced with a challenge. Bless their hearts...they just didn't know any better.


message 2: by Angie (new)

Angie "Beyond rude" is putting it mildly! I wish I could say I absolutely did NOT know what you are talking about in this post, but that would be a big fat lie. Part of my family is from MI. I was born/raised in TN - in the stix of the hills - lol. My accent was extremely thick and unique to the area. We moved to the city when I was small. I learned very quickly that prejudice comes in many forms. I had teachers tell me that I would "never amount to anything" because of my accent....and the stereotypes that went with it. Stereotyping is just another form of bullying. The difference between the North and the South is latitude and attitude. I love my Northern family and my Southern family - I just wish the stereotyping would end on both sides. Great Post! PS Why is it that in every tornado or tragedy in the South the reporter will pick out the ONE person in the crowd who had on a night-gown, no teeth, and curlers? Ugh.


message 3: by Beth (new)

Beth Duke PS--Here is my favorite example of the way I was singled out for ridicule: Eighth grade spelling bee, it's down to four other students and me. They get words like "businessmen" and "edifice" and "personalize." The teacher in charge--not a big fan of the accent--asked me to spell "dicotyledon." I am almost positive no one in eighth grade had EVER encountered that word, and it sufficed to knock me out and put me in my Southern place.


message 4: by Amy (new)

Amy Hearth Beth wrote: "PS--Here is my favorite example of the way I was singled out for ridicule: Eighth grade spelling bee, it's down to four other students and me. They get words like "businessmen" and "edifice" and "p..."

"Dicotyledon"? I couldn't spell that now, let alone in eighth grade! That's so mean-spirited.


message 5: by Beth (new)

Beth Duke Amy Hill wrote: "Beth wrote: "PS--Here is my favorite example of the way I was singled out for ridicule: Eighth grade spelling bee, it's down to four other students and me. They get words like "businessmen" and "ed..."

Wasn't it? I don't think a Southern teacher would've done the same to a kid with, say, a Jersey accent. :p


message 6: by Amy (new)

Amy Hearth Beth wrote: "Amy, I moved from Alabama to Turbotville, Pennsylvania (I did not make that up) at the tender age of eleven--with an accent thicker and slower than sorghum syrup in an hourglass. Even when tested a..."

What little they knew about the South probably came from watching "Green Acres" and "The Beverly Hillbillies," lol.


message 7: by Amy (new)

Amy Hearth Angie wrote: ""Beyond rude" is putting it mildly! I wish I could say I absolutely did NOT know what you are talking about in this post, but that would be a big fat lie. Part of my family is from MI. I was born..."

"Stereotyping is just another form of bullying." Well said, Angie!


message 8: by Mary (new)

Mary Miro Amy, all my relatives on my mother's side are from Mississippi and Texas. I can't say I have their accent, but to me, the southern accent is heaven to listen to! Its intonations bring a special kind of comfort to my soul. My grandmother had the most beautiful Mississippi accent. I would give anything to hear it again!


message 9: by Amy (new)

Amy Hearth Mary wrote: "Amy, all my relatives on my mother's side are from Mississippi and Texas. I can't say I have their accent, but to me, the southern accent is heaven to listen to! Its intonations bring a special ..."

Oh, that's sweet, Mary.


back to top

Born to Write

Amy Hill Hearth
Blog written by New York Times Bestselling Author Amy Hill Hearth
Follow Amy Hill Hearth's blog with rss.