"This eternal piano-playing is too much to bear! ... These
shrill tinkle-tones with no natural resonance, these heartless whirring-tones,
this arch-prosaic rumbling and hacking — the fortepiano is killing all our
thoughts and feelings, and we are becoming stupid, dull, imbecilic. This
prevalence of piano playing, not to speak of the triumphal march of the piano virtuosos,
is characteristic of our time and truly bears witness to the victory of machine over spirit. Technical proficiency, the precision of an automaton, the
identification with strung wood, the sonic instrumentalization of human beings,
is now hailed and celebrated as the highest good.”
— Heinrich Heine, Paris, 1843
Heine being a master ironist, this jeremiad should be taken with a grain of salt. Nonetheless, the resemblance to modern-day denunciations of encroaching technology is amusing.
Published on June 16, 2013 05:48