Snip, Burn, Solder Blog: Too Many Mundane Secrets: The Problem of Redaction
Snip, Burn, Solder Blog: Too Many Mundane Secrets: The Problem of Redaction
I ended up writing a lot more than I meant to about redaction this morning (you know, over on my other blog that's nominally about building kites and stuff). Thought you guys might be interested, too. The beginning part goes something like this:
. . . In the course of my research I sifted through a lot of FOIAed documents released by the CIA in the early 2000s (when they were forced to 'fess up to Congress about their involvement with Pinochet as a condition of getting their budget money). Predictably, most of this stuff was at least partially redacted--and since it was all stuff form the 1970s-1990s, what I was looking at were PDFs of scans of actual hardcopy from which the offending words and phrases had been excised with a hobby knife. These pages are then stamped "SANITIZED," which tends to imply something about the parts that were removed. (Here's a representative sample; I love that the "one thing" Jesse Helms has to say is specifically redacted. I met Helms once, when I was a grade-schooler visiting Washington, DC. At the time I thought he looked like Boss Hogg, but very affable.)
Anyway, what struck me about these documents, these secrets, is that some human--likely a low-level clerk--went through all of these *very sensitive materials* and cut out those words. All day? Every day? Was this her whole job? Did every day end with a garbage can packed with word salad? In any case, still, some specific human saw all of these secrets unredacted; she knows what Helms's one important thing to say to Kissinger about Chile and Pinochet was. She likely worked in a room *full* of people just like her, and they knew *all* the secrets. And they weren't the only ones: Someone typed up this transcript. For every secret that's deemed such by fat men in expensive suits, there's someone at the bottom who could spill those beans. She's wearing a cheap off-the-rack tweed skirt-and-jacket combo. Her blouse binds under her arms when she reaches up to fetch the next page out of her IN basket. She's going to sip a Diet Tab while sitting on a concrete planter during her 30-minute lunch hour. . . .
