More questions about COIN (VI): Do we really understand the nature of the fight?

By Major Tom Mcilwaine, Queen's Royal Hussars

Best Defense guest columnist

Question Set Six -- Do the historical case
studies that we do use stand up to scrutiny? Again, one question leads us onto
a series of further questions. Those case studies (assuming that they are
relevant, and that we should not in fact be looking to Omdurman instead) -- are
they based on the accepted narrative or on the historical record? Did the
British really rely on the principles of minimum force, winning popular support,
and an adherence to the law? Or did they in fact use torture, exemplary force,
and laws which in essence placed themselves above the law? The emerging
archival evidence on the British approach, particularly in Kenya, is beginning
to show that this might in fact be the case. This is an area which requires
more work because the answer to it may well hold the key to answering
Clausewitz's question -- what is the nature of the struggle in which we are
involved?