Diarmaid MacCulloch "does not conceal his preference for secularism."

CWR's sister publication, Homiletic & Pastoral Review, has a number of new book reviews posted, including a lengthy review of Diarmaid MacCulloch's popular 2010 book, Christianity: The First Three Thousand Years. It is reviewed by Fr. Brian Van Hove, S.J., a regular contributor to both CWR and HPR. Fr. Van Hove begins:

According to Catholic tradition, faith is a gift. The author’s
cultural background is Low-Church or Evangelical Anglicanism. But this
is a heritage and not a theological virtue.

Diarmaid MacCulloch is professor of the History of the Church in the
theology faculty at St Cross College, Oxford. Professor MacCulloch
proclaims himself a skeptic, although he writes with the zeal of an
apostate. His is a paradoxical mixture of both skepticism and
appreciation of religion, especially Christianity. At times, he reveals
classical Greek tastes which are benevolently pre-Christian, though he
has been shaped by the Enlightenment. His erudition permits him to
indulge freely in refined, urbane scoffing. And his erudition is
considerable.

Why is this important? Because all writing emerges out of a tradition; 1
no author can be fully original. Perhaps, he could have written a
shorter work had he not considered the subject a formidable one. In over
a thousand pages, he writes about Christianity—not as a Christopher
Dawson (d. 1970), or a Paul Johnson, or a Hubert Jedin (d. 1980), or a
James Hitchcock, 2
who, each of them from within the subject, wrote histories of
Christianity and the Church. Nor are these religious historians ever
quoted. Anglican—especially Owen and Henry Chadwick—and various, and
often liberal, Christian historians—including Richard P. McBrien and
Hans Küng—do appear among the “Further Reading” selections, beginning on
page 1098. 3 John W. O’Malley, Eamon Duffy, and John McManners are a few of his more favored historians.

He says that Edward Gibbon, who wrote a celebrated Enlightenment-era history in seven volumes, 4 “had a fine eye for the absurdities and tragedies that result from the profession of religion.” 5
The author does not conceal his preference for secularism. One can say
that MacCulloch is a thoughtful, post-Enlightenment writer who knows
more about Christianity than most Christians, including the clergy. Yet
another reason for us to posit that faith is a gift, although we must
observe that, some without this gift, at times strenuously defend the
Church and the Christian tradition. 6

Read his entire review, along with several other reviews, at HPRweb.com. Fr. Van Hove's review of Dr. James Hitchcock's new book, History of the Catholic Church (Ignatius Press, 2012), will be published by CWR later this month.