Challenge: Wouldn't Eternity Become Hell?

It's time once again for the challenge. You know how it works—we give you an objection to Christianity, then you get to think through the answer and take a shot at responding to it in the comments below. Toward the end of the week, we'll post our video response, and you can see how you did.

Today's challenge is a question sent in by a reader:

I had a young lawyer (an atheist) ask me why anyone would want to go to heaven. Why isn't 80 years of existence just enough? Wouldn't you become tired after a while? After you have seen everything, tasted all the great foods, met everyone in a deep and fulfilling way, and after you have gained all knowledge, wouldn't you just become Sisyphus? Wouldn't eternity become Hell?

Make sure you check back at the end of the week to hear Brett's response.