General Shelton: Rumsfeld was the devil in the form of a defense secretary

While Tom Ricks is away from his blog, he has selected a few of his
favorite posts to re-run. We will be posting a few every day until he returns.
This originally ran on October 11, 2010.

That's basically the impression I took away from reading Without Hesitation, the memoirs of retired Gen. Hugh
Shelton, who was chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff from 1997 to 2001. Boy is
he steamed.

There are plenty of other people Shelton pings in the book, most notably John
McCain. But the unquestionable No. 1 villain of the book is the former secretary
of defense who, in Shelton's telling, elevated his old Princeton wrestling
techniques into a management philosophy. "The McNamara-Rumsfeld model," as
Shelton calls it, was "based on deception, deceit, working political agendas,
and trying to get the Joint Chiefs to support an action that might not be the
right thing to do for the country but would work well for the President from a
political standpoint." (401) (As an experiment, I'm including page numbers --
should I continue doing this in future book discussions?) He adds, "It was the
worst style of leadership I witnessed in 38 years of service." (413)

After his first meeting with Rumsfeld, Shelton recalls thinking, "We're going
to need some heavy-duty cleaning supplies if all we're going to do is waste time
having pissing contests like this." (407) When Rumsfeld was proven wrong in a
meeting, Shelton says, he wouldn't admit it, but rather would press on and do
"his best to stay afloat amid the bullshit he was shoveling out." (413)

At one point, Rumsfeld utterly rejected a plan for how to deal with Iraqi
attacks on U.S. warplanes in the old "no-fly zones." Shelton liked the plan how
it was, so when ordered to revamp it, he let it sit on his desk for a couple of
weeks, and then sent it back to the defense secretary with a new label on it:
"Rumsfeld Auto-Response Matrix." "He loved every word of it," Shelton reports
with unconcealed contempt. (424)

This book is different from other senior generals' memoirs I've read, such as
those by Colin Powell, Norman Schwarzkopf, and Tommy R. Franks. Hugh Shelton's
telling stories and naming names. The first half of the book is a rather dull
account of his earlier career, but that changes in his relation of his last year
as chairman of the Joint Chiefs, in 2001.

Overall, Shelton comes off like a good soldier and a decent and honorable
man, but inexperienced in the ways of Washington, and so a bit of a babe in the
woods when it comes to politics. I blame this situation on civilian officials,
Democratic and Republican alike, who were so scared of the political clout that
Colin Powell accumulated that they have picked a series of political
non-starters as chairmen: Shalikashvili (his pop fought for the Nazis), Shelton
(naïve about Washington), Myers and Pace (the two most pliable senior officers
of recent memory). Admiral Mullen is proving to be an exception -- he stands up
for himself, yet isn't trying to move into the political realm. I am not sure
President Obama and his aides appreciate this.

PAUL J. RICHARDS/AFP/Getty Images