Rereading Holmes

As an adult rereading Holmes with a more critical, demanding eye, however, I find the stories thin, unexciting, sometimes confusing, and almost always quickly forgotten. The characters are still deathless, the atmosphere nicely judged and subtly stoked, and Conan Doyle's writing isn't half so clumsy or overwrought as many of his peers'. But, as with Faulks's Bond pastiche, not much seems to happen in Sherlock Holmes tales.

I've been thinking about taking a stab at rereading Holmes, but a