Exercise to Flip Class: Should you buy extended warranty for new car, used car, new appliances?

 

Sept.24, 2025 GPT5 Prompt: give clark howard'sadvice on whether to buy extended warranties for 1- new cars, 2-used cars, andnew appliances. Then provide your opinion on whether the advice is right orwrong

 

ClarkHoward’s Advice: What He Says & His Principles

From his podcasts, articles, andinterviews, Clark Howard’s stance is fairly consistent:

Context

What Clark Says / His Principle

 

New Cars

Clark is skeptical of extended warranties; he might permit considering one only under limited circumstances, but strongly prefers sticking with manufacturer coverage and having savings for repairs.

 

Used Cars

His view is largely similar: extra caution with third-party warranties; only buy if you lack the funds to absorb a breakdown and if the vehicle’s make/model and history justify it; lean toward manufacturer/authorized warranty sources if possible.

 

Appliances / Electronics / Home Warranties

Clark almost always recommends declining extended warranties on appliances and electronics. He considers them a poor financial decision and says they rarely pay off.

 

NuancedCritique of His Advice (by GPT)

Clark’s advice is sound in manyrespects, especially as a general guide for most consumers. But as with all“one-size-fits-most” financial advice, there are caveats. Below is where Iagree, where I think he overstates things, and when I’d deviate.

WhatHe’s Right About

Warranties often favor the seller, not the buyer
Many extended warranty / service-contract plans have exclusions, limitations, deductibles, or conditions (e.g. requiring dealer service, geographic restrictions) that make it hard to get certain repairs covered. This undercuts their value. Clark’s warning about loopholes is appropriate.The “expected return” is generally negative
Statistically, many people never use their extended warranty, or use it only for small repairs that don’t recover the full cost paid. Clark says (in one article) that only 8 cents on every dollar spent is “used on repairs” (i.e. you lose 92 cents). Clark Howard While that figure may be an illustrative or rounded claim, it captures the asymmetry: sellers price in margin, risk, administrative overhead, and they expect many buyers won’t file claims.Self-insurance / emergency fund is a better “warranty”
If you can afford major repair costs (or build a cushion over time), you skip the premium paid to third parties and retain control. For many durable goods/appliances, this is a sensible approach.Manufacturer warranties are more reliable than third-party ones
If you were going to get extended protection, Clark is right to prefer the automaker’s extended warranty or authorized extension rather than a disconnected third-party plan. He’s cautious of warranties sold by the dealership or third-party services. WSOC TV+1Avoid overpaying at the point-of-sale under pressure
Dealers and stores often push warranties as add-ons at checkout when consumers are in “buying mode” — a classic upsell. Clark’s repeated advice to decline the warranty offer (or at least slow down and evaluate) is good consumer protection.

WhereMore Nuance Is Needed

Homewarranties and “protection plans” differ from extended warranties
Some home warranty services (covering systems or appliances faults) might havelimited use, but in some markets and with proper contracts they can offer peaceof mind, especially in older homes. Clark tends to lump all of these under“never buy them,” which may be too blunt. For example, if you’re buying a homewith older HVAC, plumbing, etc., a home warranty may provide value (thoughstill often marginal). Clark does allow that sellers may buy a home warranty toreassure potential buyers. Clark Howard+1

My(GPT) Bottom Line

For appliances / electronics / home gadgets, I largely agree with Clark: extended warranties are rarely worth it for the average buyer. They often cost more than what one would expect to pay in repairs, especially given limited likelihood of failure within the extended period and contractual restrictions.For new cars, I lean toward a cautious “sometimes, but usually no.” I think it’s reasonable to consider an extended warranty under specific conditions (you plan to use the car far beyond its factory warranty, you drive very aggressively or in rough conditions, the car is known to have expensive repair parts, or your savings are limited). But I would not default to buying one; I would instead estimate repair risk, check reliability ratings, and compare warranty cost vs expected repairs.For used cars, I'm more skeptical. Because you already lose some “known good period” of the vehicle, warranties become more expensive relative to risk. If the used car is from a reputable brand with good reliability, and you have enough buffer to absorb small to moderate repairs, skipping the warranty is often prudent. If the seller offers a manufacturer-backed or certified used car program warranty, that’s more trustworthy than generic third-party plans.