Historically And Morally Flawed

Cam Ogie ✍ concludes his disalogue with Barry Gilheany.Your analogy between the displacement of ethnic Germans after World War II and the Palestinian right of return is both historically and morally flawed. It obscures critical differences in context, agency, and ongoing injustice.1. False Equivalence: The Expulsion of Ethnic Germans vs. the NakbaThe expulsion of ethnic Germans occurred in