Logic in Judgment

 It is important to leverage data analysis and inferences in making both strategic and operational decisions in the complex business environment with a high degree of unpredictability and ambiguity. 

Sound judgment relies on logical chains that involve critical thinking, which uses reasoning and impartial scrutiny to solve problems. Data, regardless of how big or complex, does not make sense if not converted into quality information, fact-based knowledge for making sound judgments.

Elements of Sound Judgement

-Break down the problem: Deconstruct the problem to reveal underlying logic and assumptions.

-Recognize biases: Acknowledge personal biases in judgment and experience. Cognitive biases are systematic errors in reasoning due to subjective perception, affecting how people understand reality.

-Collect evidence: Gather relevant evidence through observation, experimentation, or external information.

-Reevaluate thinking: Adjust and reevaluate thinking based on new information.

-Form a reasoned assessment: Propose solutions based on a reasoned assessment.

-Critical Thinking: Critical thinking involves a broad set of skills and habits of mind:

-Habits of mind: Curiosity, open-mindedness, self-awareness, empathy, and persistence.

Evaluating a logical chain involves assessing its validity and soundness. Here are the key steps:

-Reasoning: Reasoning can be evaluated for correctness using definitory rules and for efficiency using strategic rules. Violations of these rules result in fallacies. Fallacies can be material, which presume too much, or formal, which have issues with the structure of the argument.

-Skills: Analyzing problems, recognizing biases, gathering evidence, and forming reasoned assessments.

-Identify the premises and conclusion: Determine the statements that form the foundation of the argument and the ultimate point being argued.

-Assess the validity: Check if the conclusion follows logically from the premises. A deductive argument is valid when the truth of the premises guarantees the truth of the conclusion. The argument's form or structure ensures validity, irrespective of the subject matter.

Determine the soundness: Evaluate whether the premises are true. An argument is sound if it is valid and its premises are true.

-Check for fallacies: Identify any defects in the argument. Fallacies can be material (misstatement of facts), verbal (incorrect use of terms), or formal (improper process of inference). Material fallacies, also known as fallacies of presumption, occur when premises presume too much.

-Evaluate the strength of the argument: If the argument is not deductively valid, assess whether the premises provide rational grounds for accepting the conclusion.

Hence, good judgment is a must for good decisions. It is also important to leverage data analysis and inferences in making both strategic and operational decisions in the complex business environment with a high degree of unpredictability and ambiguity. 

Follow us at: @Pearl_Zhu