A Review of Reviews

I read that, once he was established as a novelist, George Orwell shied away from doing any book reviews. I understand why. It's hard to be completely frank when criticising another writer. You know that they've put their heart and soul into a work and liking or disliking something is so personal. Any criticism looks like professional jealousy. Too much praise looks unconvincing - you scratch my back and I'll scratch yours. The exception might perhaps be when an established writer is giving a helping hand by endorsing a new kid on the block, who might not otherwise gain the exposure they deserve. Without the enthusiastic support of such generous writers - in my case, it was Alan Sillitoe and Kevin Crossley-Holland - it's hard to make the breakthrough.