Book Review: The Wrong Daughter by Dandy Smith

As someone who navigates the structured world of behavioural therapy and the fluid complexities of human emotions, The Wrong Daughter was a psychological thriller that resonated deeply with me. Dandy Smith has crafted an intricate narrative that delves into the unsettling dynamics of identity, manipulation, and familial bonds—themes that hold particular relevance in are relevant to my field of work.

The novel opens with an eerie premise: a sister, long presumed dead, suddenly reappears after sixteen years, seamlessly reintegrating into her family’s life. But something feels off. As the story unfolds, two parallel sibling narratives gradually intertwine, revealing secrets, deception, and a sinister game of psychological control. Smith masterfully weaves these timelines together, keeping the reader constantly questioning: Who is telling the truth? Who is the real victim?

As a counsellor, I was particularly drawn to how the book explores the concept of Stockholm syndrome, trauma, and the lasting impact of childhood experiences on adult behaviour. The way Smith portrays emotional manipulation and gaslighting is both chilling and realistic, making it a fascinating study of power dynamics within relationships. The sisters’ fragile and deeply rooted bond raises thought-provoking questions about trust, survival, and identity.

The pacing is relentless. The short chapters, cliffhanger endings, and shifting perspectives make it nearly impossible to put the book down. I devoured it within a day, eager to unravel the final twist. And when it came—it hit hard. While the ending was gripping, I felt some elements could have been explored further for an even stronger and more substantial emotional payoff.

As a mother, I couldn’t help but reflect on the novel’s portrayal of childhood experiences and how they shape personality and choices later in life. The psychological depth of the characters makes The Wrong Daughter more than just a thriller; it’s a study of resilience, trauma, and survival instincts.

Final Verdict:

This book is a must-read if you love psychological thrillers that keep you second-guessing, challenge your perception of reality, and offer an emotional depth beyond just suspense. While not without minor flaws, The Wrong Daughter is an engrossing, thought-provoking, and emotionally gripping read.