Beyond “How Are You?”: Asking the Questions That Truly Matter

The most straightforward questions often yield the most complex answers. But one question seems to fall flat too frequently: “How are you?”

We ask it several times a day without thinking much about it. But here’s the thing—when was the last time you asked someone, “How are you?” and got an answer that truly reflected their feelings?

I was working with a young client, let’s call him Arjun, who came to me after experiencing bullying at school. Each week, I’d start our sessions with the usual “How are you?” and get the same response: “I’m fine.” It was clear from his body language and the look in his eyes that he wasn’t okay, but he wasn’t ready to say more. I realized that to help Arjun open up, I needed to ask different questions to help him feel safe enough to share his thoughts.

The Shift in Approach

Instead of asking Arjun how he was the following week, I asked, “What’s been on your mind lately?” He paused, seemed to think for a moment, and then started talking about a recent incident at school that had upset him. That simple shift in questioning opened up a conversation we hadn’t had before. It wasn’t that he didn’t want to talk—he just didn’t know how to start.

Inspired by that breakthrough, I began experimenting with other clients, using different questions. The results were enlightening. Here are a few that have proven to be particularly effective:

“What’s been on your mind lately?” 

   This question invites someone to share their thoughts and concerns without the pressure of summarizing their emotional state in a single word. It also acknowledges that what’s on their mind might be complex, layered, or difficult to articulate.

“How are you feeling about [specific event]?” 

   Specificity is key here. By focusing on a particular situation—a recent exam, a family gathering, or a challenging project—you show that you’re paying attention and care about the details of their life. This can encourage them to open up about things they might otherwise keep to themselves.

“What’s something that’s made you smile recently?” 

   This is one of my favourites, especially with children. It shifts the focus to positive moments, helping them reflect on the good things in their life, even during tough times. This question also often leads to delightful stories that reveal much about their interests, passions, and the people who matter to them.

“Is there anything you wish people asked you more often?” 

   This one is powerful because it allows the other person to voice something they might not typically get to share. It’s an invitation to talk about things they wish were more acknowledged or understood by others.

Why These Questions Matter

In counselling, as in everyday life, the questions we ask can close or open doors. “How are you?” is a door often already ajar—it’s easy to slip through without going very far. But when you ask someone what’s on their mind, how they feel about something specific, or what’s made them smile, you’re opening a door to a room they might not have realized they wanted to enter.

These questions indicate your interest in the other person’s experience. They show that you’re not just checking a box or fulfilling a social obligation—you’re seeking to understand and connect.

Practical Tools to Deepen Conversations

Suppose you’re looking to foster more profound, meaningful conversations. In that case, whether with your children, friends or even in your workplace—there are some fantastic tools available that can help:

Mindfulness and Conversation Starter Cards : These cards are designed to prompt thoughtful discussions, making it easier to explore emotions and thoughts. They can be beneficial in family settings or even in therapeutic environments. Guided Journals and Diaries : These journals often include prompts that encourage reflection on feelings and thoughts beyond the usual “How are you?” They can be an excellent way for individuals to explore their inner world independently. Books on Meaningful Conversations : Several books provide insights and techniques to improve communication, focusing on creating more authentic and impactful interactions. Mental Health Games for Kids : These interactive tools enable children to express their emotions and thoughts securely and engagingly, making them invaluable in-home and counseling settings.

You can enhance your emotional connections with others by weaving these tools into your everyday practices. Not only do they provide structure, but they also make the process of opening up feel more natural and less intimidating.

A Personal Touch

Let me share a personal story. My young son, Arihaan, is naturally curious but sometimes struggles to articulate his feelings like many children. One day after school, I asked him the usual “How was your day?” and got the typical “Good” response. I knew there was more to uncover, so I changed tactics. “What was the best thing that happened today?” I asked. His eyes lit up as he recounted a funny moment with a classmate during recess. Not only did this question help me learn more about his day and strengthen our bond, but it also showed him that I was genuinely interested in the little details of his life.

For personalized support and guidance, click below or write to me at namita@educateable.in.

Let’s Connect

In Your Own Conversations

Next time you’re about to ask someone, “How are you?” pause for a moment and consider trying one of these alternatives. Whether you’re talking to a friend, a colleague, or a child, you might be surprised by how much more meaningful the conversation becomes.

In a world where we’re all so used to hiding behind “I’m fine,” asking the right questions can be a lifeline. It’s a simple yet powerful way to show you care—and to connect on a deeper, more authentic level.

So, what’s been on your mind lately?

Subscribe to our website for the latest insights and resources.

Subscribe