Is It Beneficial to Use Generative AI in Missiology?
I was asked to research and recommend some policies on the use of Generative AI (“Artificial Intelligence”) at the seminary where I teach. I had to do some study of this since my involvement with AI is quite limited. Reading experts, including policies of some universities, it is clear that a nuanced approach would be the best route. Some find value in the use of Generative AI in the learning process.
I wanted to try this myself. Therefore I submitted the following question to two different AI engines:
What role does the localization of theology have in the growth of the church in new regions?
On June 1, 2024, I submitted this question to Chat GPT (https://chatgpt.com/), and to Copilot (https://www.bing.com), these were the responses I got:
Chat GPT:
The localization of theology plays a significant role in the growth of the church in new regions by making the faith accessible and relevant to the local culture and context. Here’s how:
1. Cultural Relevance: Every culture has its unique values, traditions, and worldview. When theology is localized, it can be presented in ways that resonate with the cultural norms and beliefs of the new region. This makes the message of the church more relatable and understandable to the local population.
2. Language and Communication: Localizing theology involves translating religious texts, teachings, and rituals into the language spoken in the new region. This facilitates effective communication and allows people to engage with religious concepts in their native tongue, leading to deeper understanding and connection.
3. Contextualization: Localizing theology also involves contextualizing religious practices and beliefs to fit the social, political, and economic realities of the new region. This may involve adapting rituals, customs, and organizational structures to align with local norms while maintaining the core principles of the faith.
4. Missionary Work: When missionaries enter new regions to spread the message of the church, they often need to adapt their approach to effectively engage with the local population. Localizing theology helps missionaries build trust and credibility with the community, making it easier to establish connections and foster growth.
5. Inclusivity and Diversity: Embracing the diversity of cultures and perspectives within the church fosters a sense of inclusivity and belonging among believers. By incorporating local traditions and practices into the theological framework, the church demonstrates respect for cultural differences and encourages participation from a wide range of backgrounds.
Overall, the localization of theology enables the church to grow and thrive in new regions by making the faith accessible, relevant, and meaningful to the local population. It fosters a sense of belonging, builds bridges across cultural divides, and promotes the spread of the gospel in diverse communities.
Copilot
The localization of theology plays a significant role in the growth of the church in new regions. Let’s explore this topic further:
1. Contextualization and Relevance:
– Local Theologies: When the church engages with local contexts, it adapts its theological understanding to address specific cultural, social, and historical realities. Local theologies emerge as a response to these unique contexts.
– Relevance: By contextualizing theology, the church ensures that its message remains relevant and meaningful to people in the region. It bridges the gap between ancient truths and contemporary life.
2. Witness and Authenticity:
– Authentic Witness: Local theologies allow the church to bear authentic witness to the Gospel within its specific cultural milieu. It demonstrates that Christianity is not a foreign import but a transformative force that speaks directly to local needs.
– Credibility: When theology is localized, it enhances the credibility of the church. People are more likely to engage with a faith community that understands their struggles, aspirations, and questions.
3. Incarnational Ministry:
– Incarnation: Just as Jesus became incarnate in a specific time and place, the church’s theology becomes “incarnate” when it takes root in local soil. It reflects God’s love and presence in tangible ways.
– Ministry Approach: Local theology informs how the church ministers to the community. It shapes preaching, worship, pastoral care, and outreach strategies.
4. Challenges and Opportunities:
– Challenges: Developing local theologies involves grappling with complex issues. It requires discernment to avoid syncretism (blending Christianity with other beliefs) while embracing cultural expressions.
– Opportunities: Local theologies empower believers to engage in transformative action. They inspire social justice, environmental stewardship, and holistic mission.
5. Unity and Diversity:
– Unity: While local theologies celebrate diversity, they also contribute to the unity of the global Church. Each local expression enriches the larger body of Christ.
– Global Learning: Churches in established regions can learn from the theological insights of new churches. This mutual exchange fosters growth and maturity.
In summary, local theology is not merely an academic exercise; it shapes the church’s identity, mission, and impact. By embracing contextualization, the church becomes a vibrant witness, rooted in love for God and neighbor.
Source: Conversation with Copilot, 6/2/2024
(1) The theological foundations for church growth – Bible Society. https://www.biblesociety.org.uk/content/explore_the_bible/bible_in_transmission/files/2018_spring/The_theological_foundations_for_church_growth.pdf.
(2) Re-Thinking Homogeneity: The Biblical Case for Multi-Ethnic … – 9Marks. https://www.9marks.org/article/re-thinking-homogeneity-the-biblical-case-for-multi-ethnic-churches/.
(3) LOCAL THEOLOGIES IN THE LOCAL CHURCH: ISSUES AND METHODS – Boston College. https://ejournals.bc.edu/index.php/ctsa/article/download/3018/2637/.
(4) Globalization and Church Growth: A Reflection on African Evangelism and …. https://www.arcjournals.org/pdfs/ijrsa/v7-i2/1.pdf.
(5) The Evangelical Church Interacting between the Global and the Local …. https://lausanne.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/The-Evangelical-Church-Interacting-between-the-Global-and-the-Local-Global-Listening-Team-Report-21.11.03.pdf.
(6) Theology, Ethics, and Church Growth – Biblical Research Institute. https://www.adventistbiblicalresearch.org/wp-content/uploads/Theology-ethics-and-church-growth.pdf.
(7) 5 Top Effective Church Growth Strategies. https://jesusleadershiptraining.com/effective-church-growth-strategies/.
(8) Strategies for Effective Church Growth Planning. https://jesusleadershiptraining.com/church-growth-planning/.
(9) Church Growth Theology. http://essays.wisluthsem.org:8080/bitstream/handle/123456789/654/WendlandGrowth.pdf?sequence=1.
Neither gave me footnotes, but Copilot was kind enough to give me references. Looking over the responses, I can see uses at the Pre-drafting stage. That is, Generative AI can help me evaluate topics, give me some references to study more, and even give possible ideas for outlines. Doing this should help the learning process— something that definitely does not happen if one simply “cut-and-paste” the answer as one’s own completed work.
Of course, there are cautions.
First, AI is known to hallucinate. It can make up references.
Second, AI can share false information and reference incorrectly. I had this happen before where I asked for a biography of a person, and it indicated that he worked for me. The reference the AI gave was to my website but it certainly did not say that he worked for me.
Third, AI crowdsources data so it shares opinions and biases without good verification.
Fourth, related to the previous point, does not necessarily verify the quality of the data it draws from.
