The Allure of the Fish-out-of-Water Trope in Fantasy

In the sprawling annals of fantasy literature, the ‘fish-out-of-water’ trope is as permanent a fixture as a brooding hero in a murky tavern.

Imagine plucking an unassuming character and tossing them into a realm where their understanding of the world is about as useful as a chocolate war hammer.

Picture a character for whom the idea of quantum physics is less alien than their current predicament.

And there you have the stage set for a delightful dance of the disoriented.

The Appeal: A Symphony of Misfits

There’s a peculiar charm in watching a character fumble through a world they find as baffling as a dragon at a vegan barbecue.

It’s akin to the thrill of watching someone navigate a maze blindfolded.

We find a strange kinship in their cluelessness, a shared sense of “Well, this should be interesting.”

For the reader, the fish-out-of-water is less a literary device and more a comrade-in-arms, wading through the murky waters of the unknown, while we chuckle from the safety of our armchairs.

And let’s be honest, there’s a certain schadenfreude in witnessing someone attempting to mount a dragon as if it were a slightly larger-than-average pony.

Character Examples: From Zero to Hero, and Perhaps Back to Zero

Bilbo Baggins in ‘The Hobbit‘: Here we have Mr. Baggins, a hobbit more suited to a quiet life of tea and scones, suddenly thrust into a world where dragons consider his kind more snack than conversationalist.

His journey from hobbit-hole to dragon’s den is the epitome of bewildered bravery.

Harry Potter in the ‘Harry Potter’ Series: Picture a boy who believes his biggest problem is the Dursleys, only to find out he’s supposed to play hero in a world that thinks safety regulations are for Muggles.

Harry’s journey is a masterclass in “I’m sorry, you want me to do what now?”

Arthur Dent in ‘The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy’: Arthur, a man whose biggest worry was the council demolishing his house, suddenly finds himself traversing the universe.

It’s less a leap of faith and more a tumble into the absurd.

Thomas Covenant in ‘The Chronicles of Thomas Covenant’: Here’s a man dragged from his own bleak reality into one where he’s expected to be a savior.

Covenant’s disbelief is almost as palpable as the reader’s amusement.

Why It Works: The Joy of Disorientation

This trope sings because it’s a mirror to every time we’ve felt like bringing a manual to a social gathering.

It’s the universal experience of “I have no idea what I’m doing, but I’ll pretend I do,” set against a backdrop of elves and sorcery.

In fantasy, this trope isn’t just relatable; it’s a masterclass in world-building by stealth.

The reader, much like the protagonist, learns that sometimes, ignorance isn’t just bliss; it’s downright hilarious.

The Unlikely Charm of Being Out of One’s Depth

The enduring allure of the ‘fish-out-of-water’ trope in fantasy lies in its uncanny ability to blend the journey of self-discovery with the kind of mishaps that make for excellent dinner party anecdotes.

It’s a reminder that sometimes, all it takes to find oneself is getting hopelessly lost in a world where even the laws of physics seem to have had one too many at the local tavern.

In the end, there’s nothing quite like a character utterly out of their depth, yet doggedly paddling on, to remind us that sometimes, the best adventures begin with a healthy dose of bewilderment and a side of “What in the seven hells have I gotten myself into?”

follow jon on REam.

The post The Allure of the Fish-out-of-Water Trope in Fantasy first appeared on Jon Cronshaw.