Walk the Plank!

Piracy has always been a problem in the electronic age. It’s easy and seems harmless, but it’s not. Someone gets an illegal copy of software or a movie or an ebook or an audiobook, and it’s no big deal. Unfortunately, that’s not quite true. Piracy disproportionately hurts small independent authors like myself more than the big names, but it hurts them as well.

As an example, consider my novel Xenophobia, which came out as an audiobook in 2014. Even with protests from me, it regularly appears as a “free” audiobook on YouTube. Trying to get it taken down is like playing whack-a-mole. And, as you can see here, it pops back up every few months.

In two months, it’s had 11,000 views! That’s great, but that’s also 11,000 sales that never happened.

Ah, but what about the sales that DID happen? That’s where the author and audio producer make their money, right?

Hmmm… about that… Over the past decade, Xenophobia has sold less than 500 copies.

For me, this is heartbreaking.

As an independent author, I struggle to get traditional publishing houses to even respond to emails, let alone pick up any of my work. When it comes to audiobooks, it’s a dead-end. Thankfully, Podium has thrown me a lifeline with some of my recent books, but most of my novels will NEVER be produced as audiobooks as they can’t pay for their production costs, let alone put bread on the table.

And the crazy thing about this is all the YouTube “fans” are hurting themselves. They’re the ones that are missing out on other audiobooks that will never be made because of how badly piracy hurts the industry.

4 likes ·   •  8 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on August 05, 2023 20:30
Comments Showing 1-8 of 8 (8 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Davey (new)

Davey 500 copies? Thats crazy.
The book should have been made into a movie


message 2: by Peter (new)

Peter Cawdron Davey wrote: "500 copies? Thats crazy.
The book should have been made into a movie"
Thank you for being so kind :)


message 3: by Davey (new)

Davey Seriously. Your First Contact series could be a TV show. Would be nice to have more authentic sci fi
Comon Netflix !? Amazon? Disney ?


message 4: by Peter (new)

Peter Cawdron Davey wrote: "Would be nice to have more authentic sci fi
Comon Netflix !? Amazon? Disney ?"
it would be nice, but it is insanely difficult because these productions cost tens of millions of dollars. Even NY Times best sellers get ignored. Maybe one day :)


message 5: by Vorkbaard (new)

Vorkbaard How can we help, apart from buying your books?


message 6: by Peter (new)

Peter Cawdron Martin wrote: "How can we help, apart from buying your books?"That certainly helps.

I don't think piracy is malicious from the perspective of those that "grab a copy." Pirates themselves are malicious, but most regular people aren't, but they really don't understand just how severe the problem is and how it hurts creativity.

I've just finished writing Ghosts, which will be out in Sept/Oct but it will NOT be produced as an audiobook (even though it would be great). And the reason why is the negative impact of piracy. I've got two audiobooks in production at the moment, Apothecary and The Art of War. My audiobook producer needs to see if they'll make any money before considering Ghosts. When the piracy-to-sales ratio is 95% it means audiobooks have to be INSANELY popular to actually make any money at all. They cost roughly $5,000 to produce so audiobooks like Xenophobia still haven't broken even after a decade—despite being insanely popular as a pirated book. I hope this article helps people see the big picture on how piracy hurts the creative industry.


message 7: by Alex (new)

Alex Just don't understand pirates (consumers that is, not the original perps). Then again, when in my teens I did sometimes 'borrow' a friend's 8-bit games to copy so I'm not squeaky clean - but as an adult I can't honestly think of a reason to pirate any IP - we're not *owed* anything by default FFS...


message 8: by Peter (new)

Peter Cawdron Alex wrote: "Just don't understand pirates..." I don't think they realize just how rampant the problem is and how much it hurts creativity. They seem to enjoy the works themselves, but it's too easy to ignore the author in the background.


back to top