Little token of affection from the London Tube

I bet London's transport network is a field day for epidemiologists (sp?) worldwide. The kind of nasty you can pick up because your neighbour coughs his or her lung out over your shoulder is impressive. Now, I do have the typical Taurus (I've been told) constitution; very hard to kill, generally, but my weak area is the whole breathing apparatus plus sinuses. I went to work first day with really bad sinuses, then they cleared up over a few days, and then my boss's boss fell ill. Then my boss. Over two weeks, it's been closing in, and I've done my level best to fight it off. Everybody's coughing and sneezing - same on the tube, bus, train.

It was only a matter of time. And the problem in my job is that I have to be sharp enough to catch a missing "bn" for "billion" in a financial edit (it does make a difference when editors mess up). What I edit every day requires me to be 100% sharp. Even 80% would do it (as long as I'm not the last pair of eyes on the edit). Today, I'm down to 50%, which means enough coherence to read a bit and go to the supermarket to acquire some soup (and remember to take the change). And write a quick blog update. But otherwise I'm woozy and headachy and surrounded by used paper tissues. It's a sorry sight.

To add insult to injury, the slice of vegetable quiche I found in the shop tastes like cardboard. Which is probably more my fault than its maker's; taste buds are on holiday while my brain's dribbling out of my ears. So I'll stick to mainlining hot tea, coffee, orange juice and cough syrup. Sounds like a balanced diet to me.

Yesterday, the rest of the plot for my space opera came together - which, as usual, led to a discussion with my partner. Now, bless him, he's patient and supportive, but he's incredibly focused on plot, and unless it's an awesome plot, he's all "bleh" about it. Anything. Books, films, and definitely my (or his own) writing. The gods were having a laugh, teaming me up with a 100% plot person. So, after some digging on his part, I told him the plot for the space opera novella I'm working on. And then we had a bit of a shouting match over the ending. He wants me to end it where my very specific ideas have run out (very much the dark moment in the story, where things look really bad). Whereas I do like to get characters out alive and halfway happy. I do think the main character kinda deserves it, too.

So there's the argument between a plot-driven reader and a character-driven author. The author wants to reward the characters for a "good effort" and all their struggles by showing them a way out after the big "oh shit" moment. The plot-driven reader can't care less about the characters and is totally focused on the twist ending - up to the point where he really only wants the twist and no real "afterglow".

I'm not yet sure how to resolve the issue. When I tell him that I don't actually *have* a clear ending, I get "yes, you do! You told me the twist, and every word after just weakens the impact! You'll ruin a perfectly good story" as a response. No use telling him that I'm still 10-15k away from the ending, and books change as I go along, with pieces falling into place before me like in a jump-and-run arcade game (anybody still play those?).

I honestly don't know; my brain's too mushy to work out a solution to that issue right away. In the end, I'll have to trust Mister Muse to put the missing pieces into place. It's not like I can sell a gay sci-fi story to the mainstream, regardless how kick-ass the twist is. If fantasy readers are unready for gay characters, then mainstream sci-fi is probably the last bastion of the "clenchies" as I like to call the "YIKES, GAY CHARACTERS!" homophobic fanboys out there.

On a side-note - the friend whose book I was proofing/helping to edit when I wrote the last few updates has landed a Big Name agent with it, so if anybody kept their fingers crossed for my friend, thank you. The goods vibes helped. :)
4 likes ·   •  11 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on February 17, 2012 12:10
Comments Showing 1-11 of 11 (11 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Lenore (new)

Lenore The link here on GR never works for me (I get a "the post doesn't exist" notification). I always have to go and read the post directly on your blog. Any idea why?


message 2: by [deleted user] (new)

It takes a while for GR's servers to update the actual link. The same thing happens with book reviews. You just have to be patient and eventually it all comes together.


message 3: by Lenore (new)

Lenore I can't be patient when it comes to this particular gentleman. Sorry.


message 4: by [deleted user] (new)

I know. I usually just pop over to his blog and read it there. Although I usually comment here because you can get all kinds of interesting conversations going.


message 5: by Lenore (new)

Lenore :) I totally agree about the comments.


message 6: by [deleted user] (new)

Oleg wrote: "IF YOU END IT THERE I AM GOING TO KICK HIM.

I SWE.. Oh damn, he can kick my arse...

I'll do something else! I SWEAR.

(And well, me and arcade games. We do like each other.)"


Heh. When it comes to sci-fi plot over everything. Even happy endings. Srsly. :>


message 7: by [deleted user] (new)

Hey! Oleg and I stopped agreeing. Life is back to normal. Phew.


message 8: by [deleted user] (new)

Pffft. Big bang IS satisfying.


message 9: by Aija (new)

Aija YAY for your friend! *uncrosses fingers*

About the plot vs. characters... It's a tough choice. I love when the characters get their HEA, HFN or even just a hope for a happy ending, but the books that have left the biggest impact on me (and are still deeply seated in my heart) are the ones with no happily-ever-afters.
What it comes down to is I trust you - do whatever your Muse tells you to and I'll love it no matter what! :)


~♥*Marianna*♥~ Characters! Ten thousand times the worth of plot for me! When everything goes to hell in a handbasket if the story is not "character driven" I most likely will not finish it.

I have many times overlooked bad or cliched plots and still enjoyed a book but I have never managed to do the same when the characters are not up to snuff.

However, characterization is not something Aleks has a problem with. (At least not in the final product. I'm not a writer, I don't know how hard doing all that stuff I love to read is. ) So, write whatever feels right; I'm sure I'll enjoy it!


message 11: by VJ (new)

VJ Summers I'm not familiar with any sf with gay characters, but there are several fantasy series I know of - Lynn Flewelling's (OMG - effing AMAZING), Storm Constantine's Wraethu (not exactly gay, more dual-gendered?), Tanya Huff's Sing the Four Quarters stories... So maybe mainstream sf is ready for you! (I'll be panting to read it, at any rate).

I think in sf I'd be more accepting of ending on a dark moment... though I'd really want a sequel to gibe them some sort of tolerable resolution. Huh. Reading back over that, yeah. I guess I need to end on, if not a high note, at least not suicidal darkness.

I'm likely to put down a book with amazing plot but flat characters, where I'm likely to forgive some plot holes if the characters grab me by the throat...

Just my 57 cents...

And, I've said before, Aleks, I read your blog and always get all thinky about my own writing process, or ethics, or whatever. You da bomb - even at 50%!

(Okay, so it's 59 cents...)


back to top

Letters from the Front

Aleksandr Voinov
Aleksandr Voinov's blog on reading and writing. ...more
Follow Aleksandr Voinov's blog with rss.