The Three-Goddesses Chat: Book Collages

This is the sixth in a series of Three Goddess Chats, brought to you by Krissie (aka Anne Stuart and Kristina Douglas), Lucy (Lucy March aka Lani Diane Rich), and Jenny (Jenny Crusie), who meet in a chat-room called ThreeGoddesses to talk about everything. Most writers have discovery methods, techniques they use to brainstorm their stories and keep them in the world of the book. The Three Goddesses favor soundtracks and collage, and today's topic is collage. (Click on the images to see them full size.)

Jenny: Collage is basically cutting and pasting your notes for the book in picture form. It's a way to get past words, which we're already using a lot of to write the book, and go to images and objects that evoke the tone and spirit of the book, the same way soundtracks do. In fact, collages with soundtracks can be lifesavers for novelists.

Lani: I'd never heard of collaging for books until Jenny talked about it. Jenny, when did you start collaging for your books?

Jenny: The first book collage was a fairly simple one for Bet Me, but that was after the book was done.

Lani: Why did you do it after it was done?

Jenny: I collaged for the copy edit which was a huge help in balancing all the stuff that was in there. I'd been looking at those words for so long I couldn't see them any more (another reason you always need an editor) but doing the book in pictures helped me see the things I intuitively made bigger or smaller in the context of the story.

Lani: What made you think of collaging?

Jenny: I have no idea. I had a shadow box and I just started sticking things in it, trying to see the book. What was the first one you did?

Krissie: When I was about twenty I did a scrapbook of pictures that were evocative to me. Mixed words with photos and stuff. So that was what I thought of when I did my first book collage. I had this historical and I was having trouble getting into it so I cut out photos that made me think of the book. but it was much too literal. It ended up just pasting pretty pictures on poster board.

Jenny: Sometimes literal is good. Helps you remember what things look like in the story.

Krissie: But then I went to a seminar Jill Barnett did, and she used words as well. Which made a huge difference. My collages will be examples of collages that didn't work, which I think is interesting.

Jenny: Well, your books work so your collages must.

Krissie: I did love the stuff we did for Fairy Tale Lies.

Jenny: I love your collages for Fairy Tale Lies:

Krissie: I think doing collages on scrapbook-size pages is easier for me.

Lani: For me, too. I struggle with the big posterboard.

Jenny: I'd never thought of it, but once I saw yours and Lani's for Fairy Tale Lies, scrapbook pages seemed obvious. Although I need the big posterboard. But I think we collage for different effects. I need to see the book as a whole because I am not a good storyteller. You both seemed to be collaging for individual scenes, characters, details.

Lani: You said you need it for the big picture, which you lose. I need it for the smaller parts, like individual character collages, because I'm usually pulled way out to big picture, which is why I used scrapbook collage for A Little Night Magic:

Krissie: Jill Barnett uses those science project triptych boards. And the left side is the opening act, the middle is act two, and the right is the closing act. At least, that's what I think she did.

Jenny: Alesia had a collage for a book in her Atlantis series that was just a box with about half a dozen things that were crucial to her story. It was simple and beautiful and all she had to do was look at it and go back to Atlantis.

Lani: My first collage was for The Fortune Quilt. I made what I call "The Magic Shelf." Which sounds like I'm talking about boobs, but I'm not. I put up a shelf with a ribbon board, and put objects from the book on the shelf, and pictures and a map of the town on the ribbon board. It was really effective, and it's how I found my way into collage. Worked way better than I thought it would; I was very skeptical at first about collage.

Jenny: That's a good way to get started. Lots of flexibility, no craft time.

Krissie: Collage has yet to give me anything, but I'm less visual than you two. It's fun to cut out pictures and it's a good excuse to buy magazines but I haven't made a connection. Except with Fairy Tale Lies. I think I have trouble claiming collage.

Lani: What I find from teaching my Discovery classes is that it's the students who are skeptical about something – either collage or soundtrack – who end up getting the most out of it. Something about forcing yourself past a barrier that breaks things open, I think.

Jenny: I think when you're afraid of a process, it's because you subconsciously know its power. And visuals have a lot of power. They can really change a book.

Lani: Yeah, there's something to pushing past that resistance.

Krissie: Maybe I hear mean art teachers in my head. It seems more like an assignment.

Jenny: Krissie, it may be because the story is so complete in your head that you don't need collage. You really are a born storyteller. I'm not, so I really need collage. Detailed collage.

Krissie: No, my story isn't complete, but it tends to evolve organically. It just flows. I like the idea of Alesia's.

Lani: You did really great with Fairy Tale Lies, Krissie. And you seemed to get a lot out of it.

Jenny: Yeah, you had fun with the FTL collage. You loved that intricate carriage sticker you got. And your pages were wonderful.

Krissie: Yes, I did.

Jenny: There was distinct vibe to the pages you did. The same with Lani's ALNM pages. I think if you pinned all those pages to the wall, you'd have that big collage you're afraid of.

Lani: I find that I need different things for different books. The scrapbook pages worked wonders for A Little Night Magic; I had a lot of fun with that. Plus, I love going to the paper aisle in the hobby store and just picking out what speaks to me about the book. So for me, sometimes I do it digitally, sometimes with a shelf and a ribbon board, sometimes with a full posterboard. It just kind of depends on the book. Same way my process will vary, so will the collage.

Jenny: Exactly. Whatever works visually to put you into the book.

Krissie: I met someone in NY (at Lani's old chapter) who did scrapbook collages and then reduced them on her color copier so she could carry them around in a purse-sized notebook. For inspiration.

Jenny: Love that idea.

Lani: I used a digital collage for ALNM as my computer desktop for a while. There's something about taking that time to focus on the book in a different way that works, too.

Krissie: I need to pull photos and pictures into Scrivener. I know it's possible. That would be a start. I do have corkboard with evocative photos on it.

Lani: Scrivener's great for that; and there are a number of places online where you can gather pictures together and the like. You can stretch the idea of "collage" until it's something that works for you. Not everyone is the glue-and-ribbons type.

Jenny: I did both a digital and a cut-and-paste collage for MTT, and I loved the digital collage, it was beautiful, but it did absolutely nothing for me for the book.

Jenny: The cut and paste one, though, was exactly right, a huge help.

Krissie: Well, you're an actual hands-on artist.

Jenny: I think the big thing is thinking in images and objects instead of in words. We associate words with work, so cut and paste is play.

Lani: Collage can be as simple as a corkboard. I find that I need it to get a visual sense of the world, which is usually where I'm lacking. It opens up a different layer of your creativity.

Jenny: I think a small corkboard may be the best way to get into collage. Just pin the stuff up. Or use Pinterest if you're more digitally minded.

Krissie: I do like the corkboard. It's less threatening. I think I have issues.

Jenny: Oh. I've always done that. I think my old iPod is so low tech, it doesn't even notice the car. So COLLAGE.

Krissie: Okay, back to collage.

Jenny: This is really my thing, isn't it? I dragged you into this.

Krissie: No, no. You didn't get me started. Barbara and Jill did.

Jenny: I meant I dragged you into this chat. I'm torn between "follow your instincts and if you don't want to do it, don't" and "if you're resisting it that much, you really should do it."

Lani: No, it's good. I think we're all on the spectrum. You're a natural with collage, and you make beautiful ones.

Krissie: I love the idea. It's kind of like trying to have an orgasm (you knew I'd bring sex in, didn't you?)

Jenny: Paper orgasms.

Krissie: You'd have paper orgasms, Crusie. I most definitely have music orgasms. TMI.

Lani: I'm a little resistant, but I push past it, and am a collage proselytizer. I make my students do collage, and the ones who resist the most get the most out of it, so I usually encourage people to try, especially if they think they're going to hate it.

Krissie: I keep trying too hard and it's always just out of reach. I'm someone who'd really ought to do it.

Jenny: So the next time you're here, Krissie, we work on Fairy Tale Lies and collage again? Or are you guys finished with the collage work on that?

Krissie: Oh, hell no. I've got lots more collage work to do on it.

Lani: I can collage again. I need to revisit the material.

Krissie: Uh, is mine here? Or do you guys have it?

Lani: I have it, I think.

Jenny: I don't. But I have pictures of your pages.

Krissie: Because god knows where it is. But I'm cleaning, I'm cleaning. The bedroom first. I'm making progress.

Lani: Wait a minute…

Krissie: It'll turn up. It's in a scrapbook, right?

Jenny: Ah. The big one I started is upstairs, but I don't know where the scrapbook pages went. Oh, and I set up a Fairy Tale Lies wiki. Did you get the link? No idea if it's going to be any help or not, but now you have everything on it that I had. I can put pictures of the collages in there so you can see them any time.

Krissie: I hate to tell you but I'm gonna collage tonight. It's calling me.

Jenny: YAY! Krissie collages! That makes me happy.

Krissie: The Wiki looked incredibly cool. I wish my books were laid out like that. With that kind of outline I could sail through it. Or so it seems.

Jenny: You could probably collage an outline. You can definitely collage acts, I did that for an old version of You Again.

Lani: I have my pages, but not Krissie's. I thought Krissie took her pages home with her?

Krissie: Yes, I probably did. I'm cleaning — they'll turn up. I just haven't seen them.

Jenny: I thought she did, too, but I can't remember. Worse comes to worse, we collage again.

Krissie: And maybe discover something new. That happens when I occasionally lose pages. I rewrite and something even richer comes up. I loved those pages but maybe they were a rough draft.

Jenny: Exactly. Because we're different people now than we were then. I'm really seeing that with the You Again collage, changing a lot of things, adding a lot of new stuff. Whereas Liz's collage? Pretty much finished. Just put down the glue and finish the book, Crusie.

Lani: I have to collage again, anyway. It's been a long time, and I need to reconnect with the material.

Jenny: I learn so much when I'm collaging. There's so much discovery in the process.

Lani: There really is. It's a great way to build up the energy to write.

Jenny: The bottom line for me is that I need both collage and soundtrack to nail the book for me outside the written word because I get so bogged down in words, editing and rewriting and trying to find the story, but with sound and pictures, it's easy. It makes it play again.

Krissie: So Collage R Us.

Jenny: Collage R definitely us.

Krissie: I may want foamcore board. Or scrapbook pages. Who knows.

Jenny: You should live closer, I have a cabinet of foam core. I buy in bulk.

Lani: It's great to be able to throw yourself into something creative, too. Gets those juices flowing.

Krissie: Yup. I'll just play.

Jenny: That's the key. Just think about your story and play, go by instinct. It's all about instinct. And glue.

Lucy March's A Little Night Magic will be out from St. Martin's Press on January 31, 2012.



Kristina Douglas's Raziel and Demon are out now;Warrior will be out in April 2012.



Jenny Crusie's You Again and Lavender's Blue will be out from St. Martin's Press a year after she finishes them; when is anybody's guess.