The Air Force chief's 2012 reading list: A C+ for book selection, but overall a B+

By Lt. Col. Thomas
Cooper, USAF

Best Defense aviation
literature correspondent

Earlier this month the
Air Force released the Chief of Staff of the Air Force's (CSAF) Reading List
(CSAF). One of the non-flying things I've looked forward to in
the past 16 years of my Air Force career is the CSAF's list. Ever since
the first one from General Ron Fogleman in 1996,
the list has presented books about the Air Force and its history that I've
never heard of. Sadly, when I opened up this year's list, there were no
books that I hadn't already heard of or enough that reached back into Air Force
heritage and history like previous years.

"Every Airman an
Innovator" is the theme of this year's list, which captures some of the books,
but it doesn't emphasize "being an Airman" as well as I think it could. Although being an innovator is part of Air Force heritage, the lack of
organizing principles for the list (previous lists have used strategic context,
Air Force heritage, leadership, military history, etc.) makes it difficult to
connect back to innovation and Air Force heritage. The list jumps from
management theory to satire to science to historical fiction and doesn't focus
as well on what is important as an Airman as previous lists have done.

Unfortunately, heritage
isn't an Air Force strength as the service often spends too much time
justifying itself as a valued contributor to the Joint force. This past
year the Air Force has clearly stated its contribution
better than I've heard in my career and I think should be included in every Air
Force message. These purposes are the Air Force's heritage and would have
been a great thing to use to help organize the list. With an enduring
role to establish control in air, space and cyberspace, hold any target at
risk, provide responsive ISR, and rapidly move people and cargo anywhere in the
world, the Air Force has a strong foundation to build a reading list from.

Books on Claire Chennault and the Flying
Tigers, B-29 operations in the Pacific,
and "flying the hump" would have all been
examples of the Air Force's enduring roles that would also help Airmen learn
more about the changing strategic context. The three examples also do a
good job of showing that no matter the conflict, the Air Force has always
strived to control the air, rapidly move people and cargo and strike targets
from great distances. Each example is also full innovative thinking by
Airmen that is an enduring characteristic of serving in the Air Force.

Although I am
disappointed by the books, the true innovation in this year's CSAF list is its
inclusion of movies, TED presentations and a wide range of internet
resources. As younger Airmen are raised with iPads for text books, these
other media will help achieve the purpose of a good reading list and provide a
broader set of learning tools. Unfortunately, these resources also do not
have much of a clear organization other than their source.

The inclusion of movies
will be a very useful tool for commanders and mentors and was the high point of
the list for me. Strategic Air Command captures the
challenges of the rapidly expanding new Air Force and the contribution of Airmen
serving in the early days of the Cold War. With real-life bomber pilot Jimmy
Stewart in the lead role this movie shouldn't be missed. I
would have linked the movie to 15 Minutes: General Curtis LeMay
and the Countdown to Nuclear Annihilation under the caption
"want to learn more." I'd also have added Dr Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and
Love the Bomb because it really is how many people see Strategic
Air Command and the recently released The Partnership to
fully loop from SAC to the future of nuclear weapons. I would have
also added War to accompany Restrepo since I was a bigger fan of the
book.

Using the TED
presentations is a true innovation that I think will become the most popular
element of the "reading list." I had never seen the Norden Bombsight presentation and enjoyed that
story. Again it could have been linked better to the books and
movies. Both Catch-22 and Memphis Belle being on the list would
have tied the story of this innovation better and another example of how organization
of the list disappoints and doesn't lead Airmen to broader learning.

And finally, the
diverse on-line options included in "RESOURCES" is a useful
and innovative way to help expand Airmen's set of learning tools. "Resources includes information on premier educational, think tank,
heritage, documentary, humanities, and scientific organizations" and
does a great job of improving an Airman's self-study tool box to expand how
they think. I will probably bookmark most of these and will wander
through them if I find the time. Linked to a book, movie or theme other
than innovation, to force exploration would have been a more useful way to
organize the resources.

Overall, I'd give the
books a "C minus" because they don't go far enough, in an organized manner to
build Air Force heritage. The grade is brought up to a "B plus" by the
inclusion of all of the other tools for learning that will be useful. As
the first use of diverse media on a "reading list" it is a great start. Next year I'm hoping will be an "A" when the entire list reinforces Air Force
heritage and links the different tools together so the whole team is gaining
the same knowledge, no matter the source.

Lt. Col. Tom Cooper is the Air Force fellow at the Center for a
New American Security. He is spending this year reading following a
career flying the E-3 Sentry, SAMFOX C-9s in the 89 AW and C-40s as
commander of the AF Reserve's active associate 54 AS. He has spent time
on the Joint Staff and Air Mobility Command staff. After his fellowship
he looks forward to getting back to leading Airmen and helping them pick books.