The annals of chickenshit: They do it to get a sense of control over the situation

Here's another take on the
reflective belts controversy, which says we should focus less on the belts
and more on the number of billets for general officers.
Meantime,
the mysteriously named commenter named "_B_" offered this
astute analysis last Friday of why we see enforcement of petty regulations
and such on bases
in combat zones:
--
"When
you can't accomplish the important, the petty becomes important.
I
was in South-Central Iraq in 2008, on a multinational FOB which had been
getting rocketed fairly regularly. A conventional brigade showed up; they were
living in tents due to lack of CHU space, and highly vulnerable to IDF. They
did not go out on a single raid that I know of to get the guys who were
lighting the FOB up (fortunately, others did.) The only times those guys went
outside the wire, it was to ferry their senior leadership across the province
for unproductive key leader engagements (they killed an Iraqi police guy with
an MRAP while going through a checkpoint on one of those field trips.) You know
what their senior leadership's priorities were? Doing away with takeout trays
at the DFAC (since, according to the brigade's CSM, the local nationals working
on base were sneaking food out to feed to the insurgents) and enforcing
ludicrous uniform standards (all brigade personnel had to wear gloves
outside-in August-to avoid sunburning their hands, and noncompliance meant an
Article 15.) I had to pry their CSM off one of my junior guys at breakfast one
morning-we'd just come back in the wire after being out all night, and he
didn't like my dude's uniform.
The
main issue is this--a LOT of the senior leadership is lost in the sauce, has no
idea what's going on or how to accomplish anything concrete. So, they attempt
to make themselves feel like they're in control of the situation via a)
imposing ludicrous chickenshit on those below them, and b) spending most of
their time liaising with other senior Americans, doing coordination meetings,
briefings, etc., etc., etc. That way, they feel like they are in control of
their environment, and never have to encounter anything which would suggest
differently. All this is done at the expense of their subordinates and of the
war in general, but that's ok."
--
(HT
to "Soldier's Diary")
Thomas E. Ricks's Blog
- Thomas E. Ricks's profile
- 436 followers
