Christmas songs--the good, the bad, and the ugly

I hope all of you in the path of the latest monster storm stay safe and can ride it out at home. Yesterday was the anniversary of the bombing of Pearl Harbor. Few of us were alive then, of course, but I was listening to a radio show in my car that discussed how dramatically different news becomes public today. Pearl Harbor occurred during a Philadelphia Eagles football game, and some of the players later reported that they knew something horrible had occurred, for the stadium PR system suddenly began to announce that some of the fans needed to call their offices immediately—all of them high ranking military men and police officers and politicians. On the same show, someone described how he learned of the capture of Osama bin Ladin. He was at a Philadelphia Phillies baseball game, and suddenly noticed that many in the audience were paying more attention to their phones than to the game. He said a buzz swept the stadium as word began to spread, and marveled that people today can often learn of important events even before they are officially announced or the story is reported by the media.
As Christmas approaches, we usually have a discussion of Christmas music, posting about the songs we like the most and those we loathe. So I’ll get us started today. One of my favorites is What Child is This, because it is set to the music of Greensleeves, one of my best-loved songs, followed by Christmas—Sarajevo by the Trans-Siberian Orchestra. I enjoy listening to The Little Drummer Boy, in large measure because my dad loved it and I think of him whenever I hear it. Along the same lines, I was never a fan of The Twelve Days of Christmas, but I have learned to like it simply because it was my mom’s favorite Christmas song. I stop whatever I am doing to listen to I’ll be Home for Christmas, even though I think it is one of the saddest songs of the season; I interpret it to be a lament for bygone days and loved ones now dead. Who does not like Silent Night? I am not normally a fan of novelty Christmas songs, though I do like Rudolph; after all, he prevails over the bullies in the end! I like Silver Bells and Mele Kalikimaka. I once lived in Hawaii and am still proud that greeting can roll trippingly over my tongue; Hawaiian is a beautiful language. I also have fond memories of decorating a corn plant with big red bows for our Christmas tree and going to the beach on Waikiki on Christmas Day. There are more, of course, that I really like. And then there are the clunkers, the ones I’d ban from the airwaves forever if I ever become Dictator of the World. The version of Santa, Baby by Madonna sets my teeth on edge. I don’t like the song that turns “Christmasing” into a verb—ugh. And I absolutely loathe I Saw Mommy Kissing Santa Claus, surely the most obnoxious Christmas song of all time. It always sounds smarmy to me, but I’ve even heard versions where the bratty kid plans to blackmail Mom, making her pay for his silence.
Okay…..your turn, guys. What holiday songs do you love to hear and which ones affect your nerves like chalk on a blackboard?
7 likes ·   •  23 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on December 08, 2018 13:16
Comments Showing 1-23 of 23 (23 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Wanda (new)

Wanda Love Silent Night and I Saw Three Ships. Hate Santa, Baby. And, for fun, I enjoy I Want a Hippotomaus for Christmas.


message 2: by Sharon (new)

Sharon We're on the same musical page, Wanda. I like yours, too. And I also think the Hippopotamus song is funny.


message 3: by Gary (new)

Gary Love The Christmas Song (Mel Torme) and Silent Night of course. And, to add a contrarian note, I like Santa, Baby (but only done by the inimitable Eartha Kitt).


message 4: by Sharon (new)

Sharon I like Eartha Kitt's throaty version, too, Gary. That's why I specified I did not like the version done by Madonna. Oddly, I don't think I remember The Christmas Song. Can you jog my memory with a few lyrics?


message 5: by Gary (new)

Gary Chestnuts roasting on an open fire,
Jack Frost nipping at your nose
Yuletide carols being sung by a choir
And folks dressed up like Eskimos


message 6: by Sharon (new)

Sharon That is very interesting, Anduine. In Germany, do they start playing Christmas songs weeks before the holiday? Here, the stores start bombarding us with Christmas music in October! I love it, so I don't mind, but it drives a lot of people crazy.
Thanks, Gary! I guess I did not realize that was the name of this song. I like it, too; the Mel Torme version sounds like his vocal chords were made of velvet, doesn't it?


message 7: by Anduine (new)

Anduine As you know I'm German, so our Christmas songs differ very, very much, except of course for Silent Night - Stille Nacht in th original version. Our Christmas songs are more or less all along the "somber" way like that classic so I sometime like to interrupt with the lighter English ones, especially the Bing Crosby ones. I'm afraid most Germans get very melancholy during Christmas so we/I also love to listen to the true classics like Händel and Bach. I really dont like the pop versions


message 8: by Anduine (new)

Anduine No we don't start playing Christmas songs here that early, Maybe about a week before. Come Christmas Eve, which is our "main day" you here nothing else though. As a matter of fact our whole Christams season differs, is more quiet in many ways. (except for the typical Christmas foods and and toy overabundance in the stores maybe that indeed start in October). We have Christmas markets all over the country starting on the 1. of Advent to get us "in the mood". It is very much a season to reflect hence the somber music I guess and to spend evenenings with friends and families, especially on the weekends throughout Advent


message 9: by Sharon (new)

Sharon Years ago, Anduine, I was a house guest during Christmas at the home of friend who'd moved to the US from Germany. After the Christmas party ended, Inga and her husband and me and a few of their close friends were sitting in the living room, chatting and drinking wine. Inga suddenly said she'd not "lit the tree" yet, and to our surprise, she climbed up on a chair and began to light candles on the tree. Her husband was used to this, but the rest of us were taken aback and uneasy, expecting at any moment that the tree might become a bonfire. Inga laughed and said this was a tradition in Germany. I've never forgotten it!
At one time, Christmas music did not burst upon the scene until December, but those days are long gone; now stores begin to decorate for Christmas before Halloween!


message 10: by Anduine (last edited Dec 08, 2018 07:36PM) (new)

Anduine Oh yes the real bee wax candles on the Christmas tree. Unfortunately nowdays mostly a thing of the past. To me it was always part of the Christmas magic, but even here they were mostly replaced by electric lights - mainly for safety reasons (though it makes you wonder how we survived all the previous Christmasses without burning the house down). We still use candles all over the house during advent time, such a wonderful light they cast. And of course we have Christmas pyramides and in the windows the typical "Schwibbögen". You would have to google schwibbogen for pictures, there are too many varieties, they come in all shapes and sizes (and prices), but you see them in nearly every window. As for the stores, well decorating for Christmas doesn't start that early, but you can get the typical Christmas sweets as early as September, ridiculous, if you ask me.


message 11: by Iset (new)

Iset I cannot think of a favourite seasonal song, although in adolescence I was part of a choir for many years, so I have sung and know them all very well. It seems to me that the ones I found most musically pleasing were also the ones with the most stuffy lyrics, while the ones with pleasing lyrics are little more than ditties - for that reason I hesitate to name a favourite!

I find it utterly obnoxious if anything appears in stores before 1st December. I am not alone. More and more Brits have snapped store displays in evidence several months ahead of time and posted their derision on Twitter. Our tolerance for commercialisation seems to be lower than Americans'. Among the many things I've enjoyed when visiting the States, one definite negative has been the insufferable commercialisation pushed in one's face to the nth degree. I don't know how you tolerate adverts every two minutes when you're trying to watch a good historical drama. Do they not think people have an attention span longer than that?


message 12: by Anduine (new)

Anduine Iset wrote: "Among the many things I've enjoyed when visiting the States, one definite negative has been the insufferable commercialisation pushed in one's face to the nth degree. I don't know how you tolerate adverts every two minutes when you're trying to watch a good historical drama"

Iset you made chuckle, because it is exactly the way I feel. Sorry Americans, but this is so true.


message 13: by Loretta (last edited Dec 09, 2018 10:11AM) (new)

Loretta One of my favourites has to be Joy to the world, the Lord has come. Oh come, all ye faithful is another top of my list.

I'm not fond of Santa Claus is coming to town.

I love that very old carol, Lullay thou little tiny child, by by, lullay, lullay. I love the ancient feel of it. Little drummer boy, little donkey - they make me cry.

The Christmas song I really, really loathe? The Coca Cola one, Holidays are coming - as though the only thing that makes Christmas is Coke! Lol, don't get me started on that one.


message 14: by Sharon (new)

Sharon Americans are not happy about it, either, guys. :-) Sadly, the commercial jauggernaut seems impossible to stop, not even noticing that unhappy consumers are being mowed down like ten-pins. I have never heard anyone say they liked seeing Christmas decorations hit the stores in October--not one. But at the rate we're going, they'll leave them up all year round...sigh.
I like Joy to the World, too, Loretta. Aside from songs like Silver Bells and Drummer Boy, I usually prefer the traditional "old" songs. But just as bad as I Saw Mama Kissing Santa Claus, at least IMHO, is one called The Red Shoes, about a little boy trying to buy shoes for his dying mother. It is so shamelessly manipulative that I want to put the Curse of the Cat People on the one who penned this terrible song!


message 15: by Iset (new)

Iset You know, I think I might cite Good King Wenceslas. Because it's historical. So obviously it is favoured by me.


message 16: by Loretta (last edited Dec 10, 2018 01:45AM) (new)

Loretta Sharon wrote: "Americans are not happy about it, either, guys. :-) Sadly, the commercial jauggernaut seems impossible to stop, not even noticing that unhappy consumers are being mowed down like ten-pins. I have n..."

Lol, Sharon, I've never heard The Red Shoes - I've obviously been saved from a fate as bad as Coca Cola's juggernaut. Should I look it up to see how bad it is? Or should I spare myself the misery?


message 17: by Amy (new)

Amy I can't stand that Christmas shoe song! It's awful. I mean it's just flat-out trying to make people emotional. I don't like that. I recently heard another country Christmas song, about a guy playing Santa who meets a little girl who wants to be adopted. The chorus goes:
"She said my name is Christmas Carol, I was born on Christmas Day
I dont know who my daddy is, and mommy's gone away
All I want for Christmas is someone to take me home
Does anybody want a Christmas Carol of their own."

It's just terrible.


message 18: by Stewart (new)

Stewart Patch As an antidote to the Twelve Days you should try to find a recording of "Christmas Countdown" by Irish comedian Frank Kelly in which the hapless Gobhnait O'Lunacy receives the twelve gifts from his sweetheart, Nuala. Mayhem quickly ensues when the partridge, the calling birds, and the french hens all turn out to be territorial and set upon each other (not to mention the bird droppings which has his mother sheltering under an umbrella in the sitting room.

There is also the "Poacher's Christmas" from the singing tradition of the Kipper Family of Trunch in Norfolk: "On the first day of Christmas my dog and I brought back, a partridge in an old sack..."


message 19: by Helen (new)

Helen Robare Favorites: Silver Bells, Snoopy's Christmas, I saw Three Kings (by Judy Collins)

Drives me up the wall: Santa Baby!

RE: Christmas decorations in October...HATE THEM NOW. Would probably have LOVED them as a kid! :)


message 20: by Loretta (new)

Loretta Stewart wrote: "As an antidote to the Twelve Days you should try to find a recording of "Christmas Countdown" by Irish comedian Frank Kelly in which the hapless Gobhnait O'Lunacy receives the twelve gifts from his..."

Those soind a lot of fun.


message 21: by Sharon (new)

Sharon You guys are very funny! These are great comments. "The Poacher's Christmas" made me laugh aloud. Your Christmas Carol song sounds as bad as the Red Shoes, Amy. Spare yourself, Loretta! It is not even about this poor woman dying on Christmas Eve and her little son trying to buy her red shoes before she dies. It is given from the point of view of a man who'd felt harried and frustrated by all the Christmas shopping he had to do. But he has this magical epiphany when he overhears the little boy trying to buy the shoes. Suddenly he is filled with Christmas spirit. Of course the young mother is still dying and her little boy is left to grieve, but hey, things happen, right?


message 22: by Barbara (new)

Barbara I sing with our community Christmas Chorale, and last year we learned a new song that I love. If This Child Were Born Today gives me goosebumps to sing, especially since the altos carry the melody. Here’s a high school choir singing it. https://youtu.be/rrlg_TfMoFI


message 23: by Sharon (new)

Sharon What a beautiful performance by the choir, Barbara. Thank you for sharing it with us. I can see why you love this song.


back to top

Sharon Kay Penman's Blog

Sharon Kay Penman
Sharon Kay Penman isn't a Goodreads Author (yet), but they do have a blog, so here are some recent posts imported from their feed.
Follow Sharon Kay Penman's blog with rss.