Dealing with a bad review, part 3

And now for the conclusion of our exciting adventure, "Marilyn and the Bad Review". Last time, Marilyn said that there's a deeper issue.

The deeper issue is happiness. These reviewers weren't happy. They weren't happy with my book. It didn't make them feel what they were wanting to feel. I don't know what emotion they were looking for, but I didn't provide it - and that didn't make them happy. Their lack of happiness was expressed as a poor review of my book.
You know what the main criticism seemed to be? It seemed to be that my book didn't go into the real troubles associated with establishing a harem relationship in real-life. How would I know anything about that? It isn't what I'm writing about. That aspect of my stories is allegorical. These characters are different aspects and facets of ourselves. And the sex is fun. But it isn't real. Except that it is, if you accept our own multidimensional natures. I am several people. I have different needs and motivations at different times.
All of my books have a preface that tells all of this. It also says that I won't apologize for any of it. I don't mind a critical review that helps me do better. I don't mind that I received a small number bad reviews from people who probably shouldn't have taken up their time reading something that wouldn't give them what they wanted. They did help me reflect and look for ways to improve. I appreciate that.
It's only natural to have my feelings feel a bit bruised at first. I hope 'hat' the bad reviews don't deter other readers who would enjoy a bit of dime-store diversion.
Thank you all who do read and enjoy my writing. Please do follow me and ask questions and connect in a way that helps you feel happy.
1 like ·   •  8 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on September 20, 2018 07:56 Tags: reviews
Comments Showing 1-8 of 8 (8 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Lester Helaire (new)

Lester Helaire All I can say is "What's taking you so long to get me my books"? I am kidding. But please hurry up.... I really enjoy your stories. I don't know what that negative reviewer read, or didn't read. But I've come to realize that some people try to sabotage other peoples writing for whatever reason. But please know that that I can hardly wait for the next installment of the Nogud Legacy. The Guiardian Maidens introduced me to your writings. But the Nogud Legacy made me a fan. So, "Are you finished yet"?


message 2: by Marilyn (new)

Marilyn Foxworthy That's what I needed to know! You'd be happy if I publish Book 3. I had two strong choices for what to edit and publish next. I Love the Shrine Maidens of Barsoom stories (none published yet), but I have more Nogud Legacy just waiting for final editing. I'll get you Book 3, The Woodsman soon. But I think that Book 5, The Warrior is my favorite. I do want to release a few more series before I finish out all of the Nogud though. We have to go back to 2016 and see where Joshua's grandfather came from. Thank you so much for your kind words and support. I'm glad that you felt something happy.


message 3: by Lex (new)

Lex Damn now I'm looking forward to both the next Nogud books and your new series 😂


message 4: by Lester Helaire (new)

Lester Helaire I can't wait. I have been checking Amazon daily. You have made a "fanboy" out of me. So, just keep them coming. And I will keep reading. (Publishing them a week apart has truly spoiled me.)

If you ever need a beta reader....


message 5: by Marilyn (last edited Sep 22, 2018 07:39AM) (new)

Marilyn Foxworthy You know, I'd love to have my books added to a few Listopia lists, if any of you know of some that would be appropriate and if you think that the readers there would enjoy what I'm writing.

It's so fun to have the feedback and support of all of you. I'm going to post a picture of the front cover of the next Nogud book soon, just so that you can see what it looks like.


message 6: by Lex (new)

Lex Tagged your books on a few lists I follow hopefully it'll generate some interest for you


message 7: by Marilyn (new)

Marilyn Foxworthy Thank you Lex! That's kind of you. And I just posted a new blog post with a teaser for the Cover of the Nogud 3 book that should be out soon.
Does anyone remember he old TV show, "You asked for it?" Well, you asked for it.


message 8: by Lester Helaire (new)

Lester Helaire The cover is excellent. And you are right, we asked for it. I have also been crowing about your books. Hopefully it will generate interest....


back to top