date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Patrick
(new)
Apr 02, 2018 12:07PM
I am fond of Agatha Christie's Miss Marple series for reasons I've never quite understood. The Body In The Library stands out for me.
reply
|
flag
Patrick wrote: "I am fond of Agatha Christie's Miss Marple series for reasons I've never quite understood. The Body In The Library stands out for me."Can't go wrong with those, Patrick! My only gripe with Miss Marple is that it just makes me think someone is misspelling "maple," and then I start thinking about maple syrup, which makes me want waffles, and then I completely lose the thread of the story (also, paper + drool = suboptimal combo).
While Holmes and Watson are tough to beat, at least Inspectors Gregson abd Lestrade always said so. There are others I enjoy just as much. Wolfe and Goodwin, Mason and Drake and Street, Lam and Cool, the detectives at the 87th Precinct, Luis Mendoza and his crew in Robbery and Homicide, Poirot, and Marple, for starters.Thrillers: Sigma Force, The Odessa File, Where Eagles Dare.
Just a few to help the conversation along.
Gary wrote: "While Holmes and Watson are tough to beat, at least Inspectors Gregson abd Lestrade always said so. There are others I enjoy just as much. Wolfe and Goodwin, Mason and Drake and Street, Lam and Coo..."Jeez, Gary...I don't know half of those characters! What books are they from? And where should I start?
You haven't read Nero Wolfe, Perry Mason, Donald Lam and Bertha Cool (by the same author as Perry Mason), the 87th Precinct is by EdMcBain, Luis Mendoza is by Elizabeth Linnington writing as Dell Shannon. Thd add on was the Hardy Boys.Sigma Force is by James Rollins, Where Eagles Dare by Alistair MacLean, The Odessa File by Frederick Forsythe.
Gary wrote: "You haven't read Nero Wolfe, Perry Mason, Donald Lam and Bertha Cool (by the same author as Perry Mason), the 87th Precinct is by EdMcBain, Luis Mendoza is by Elizabeth Linnington writing as Dell S..."See, except for the Hardy Boys, those are all unfamiliar to me! You're givin' me a schoolin' on mysteries...
Hercule Poirot will always rule the genre for me — all about using those little grey cells, non? My favourite of the Poirot books has got to be Five Little Pigs — it’s one of Poirot’s finest, imo.Uhhh, what else? James Rollins’ Sigma Force series has already been mentioned, and I totally agree — it’s fab! And about Holmes and Watson — I do enjoy Doyle’s work, but I think I enjoy the retellings it has rendered possible even better, right from stories about the Baker Street Irregulars to television shows like Sherlock and Elementary. Sherlock Holmes is a genre unto itself.
Also, twelve year old me thought Artemis Fowl and Alex Rider were both thrilling and captivating, and twenty one year old me totally agrees.
And one last shout out to Otto Malpense from the HIVE series!
(Okay, I’m done rambling. 🕵️♀️)
Adult me would like to add to the above: Anything by Robin Cook. If you look up the meaning of thrillers in the dictionary, you’ll find his name there, sitting in bold typeface.
broken-barriers wrote: "Hercule Poirot will always rule the genre for me — all about using those little grey cells, non? My favourite of the Poirot books has got to be Five Little Pigs — it’s one of Poirot’s..."Poirot is pretty splendiferous--I'll co-sign on that proposition. :)
Holmes really is its own genre at this point, and there is some delightful Holmesian pastiche out there (there's also some execrable Holmesian pastiche, but, well, them's the breaks when you create the most famous detective in the history of detecting).
Thanks for weighing in! :)
broken-barriers wrote: "Adult me would like to add to the above: Anything by Robin Cook. If you look up the meaning of thrillers in the dictionary, you’ll find his name there, sitting in bold typeface."Adulting is highly overrated in my humble opinion, but we'll allow this nod to maturity. :)
Sean wrote: "broken-barriers wrote: "Hercule Poirot will always rule the genre for me — all about using those little grey cells, non? My favourite of the Poirot books has got to be [book:Five Little Pigs|121648..."My favorite faux Holmes is the Solar Pons series by August Derleth and later Basil Copper.
The Ellery Queen and Sherlock Holmes novel Study in Terror is great fun as well.
Sean wrote: "Ooh, Study in Terror—I think I need to check that out."It is loosely tied to the movie of the same name. Holmes takes on Jack the Ripper. The manuscript by Watson ends up in Ellery's hands. Ellery is not in the movie.
Gary wrote: "Sean wrote: "Ooh, Study in Terror—I think I need to check that out."It is loosely tied to the movie of the same name. Holmes takes on Jack the Ripper. The manuscript by Watson ends up in Ellery's..."
I haven't seen the movie, either...will you stop piling on things I need to check out?? I'm only one man, Gary!
Sorry my friend. If you lived nearby I'd loan you my copy of the paperback of the novel. I recently reread the ebook version which Open Road Media/Mysterious Press has published.
A recent thriller I enjoyed was Good Me, Bad Me, a very non-put-downable one-sitting read.As for mysteries... Hercule Poirot is quite iconic, but for something different I'll say The Queen's Man by Sharon Kay Penman, a medieval mystery.
How many mysteries/thrillers need to be mentioned? I have lots and please do not force me to choose.
1. Sherlock Holmes by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. THE original detective; still fun to read.
2. Hercule Poirot and Miss Marple by Dame Agatha Christie. Nobody created more complicated, but (im)possible to solve mysteries. Just avoid her political thrillers.
3. Nero Wolfe and Archie Goodwin by Rex Stout. The best interaction between the main characters.
4. Perry Mason. I hate courtroom drama with a passion. This one is a notable exception. Perry Mason makes boring court proceedings look exciting.
5. Anything by Dashiel Hammett. The guy created noir genre.
6. Philip Marlowe by Raymond Chandler. This guy took pulp literature (noir) and made it art form.
7. Lew Archer by Ross Macdonald. If you think good noir takes place in the beginning of the 20th century, take a look at this. Nobody does "Skeletons in a family closet" better. Nobody.
I think I covered the major people :)
1. Sherlock Holmes by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. THE original detective; still fun to read.
2. Hercule Poirot and Miss Marple by Dame Agatha Christie. Nobody created more complicated, but (im)possible to solve mysteries. Just avoid her political thrillers.
3. Nero Wolfe and Archie Goodwin by Rex Stout. The best interaction between the main characters.
4. Perry Mason. I hate courtroom drama with a passion. This one is a notable exception. Perry Mason makes boring court proceedings look exciting.
5. Anything by Dashiel Hammett. The guy created noir genre.
6. Philip Marlowe by Raymond Chandler. This guy took pulp literature (noir) and made it art form.
7. Lew Archer by Ross Macdonald. If you think good noir takes place in the beginning of the 20th century, take a look at this. Nobody does "Skeletons in a family closet" better. Nobody.
I think I covered the major people :)
Kristy wrote: "When I was quite young I read "Comes the Blind Fury" at my older sisters suggestion. Since then I developed a serious suspicion of all dolls..and my sisters wicked intentions"Haha! Dolls are just plain creepy. And so are your sisters, apparently.
Sean wrote: "Kristy wrote: "When I was quite young I read "Comes the Blind Fury" at my older sisters suggestion. Since then I developed a serious suspicion of all dolls..and my sisters wicked intentions"Haha!..."
Dolls indeed are creepy — that’s my major take back from all those horror movies that I somehow end up watching.
Andrew wrote: "Love, Sherlock Holmes, Poirot and especially the Saint ...."All good choices, Andrew!
I'm a sad person, because I don't really read mystery. Not because I don't want to, but because I don't know where to start and even just picking from my own tbr causes me distress. Send help.
Derpa wrote: "I'm a sad person, because I don't really read mystery. Not because I don't want to, but because I don't know where to start and even just picking from my own tbr causes me distress. Send help."Haha! A daunting problem, to be sure.
I'd start with Sherlock Holmes...
Luisa wrote: "I'm a Sherlock fan myself :)"Well of course you are, Luisa--you have an exquisite taste in books. Possibly the most refined on Goodreads. :)
Mystery isn't really my go-to genre, unless it's in space or involves magic, or takes place in a evil dystopia.I could name many authors or series that I've enjoyed over the years, the classics, the obscure, the delightfully bizarre. But the most recent mystery series that I enjoyed is the Cormoran Strike series by Robert Galbraith aka J.K. Rowling
Dichotomy Girl wrote: "Mystery isn't really my go-to genre, unless it's in space or involves magic, or takes place in a evil dystopia.I could name many authors or series that I've enjoyed over the years, the classics, ..."
I'm with you on the enhancing qualities of magic/supernatural in mysteries! (Hence, The Camelot Shadow.)
I don't usually go for mystery or thriller.... but maybe the Dresden Files series would apply?It has lots of action, magic, mithology references... and all while being a series of detective cases.
No doubt the world's best wizard named Harry.
Valië wrote: "I don't usually go for mystery or thriller.... but maybe the Dresden Files series would apply?It has lots of action, magic, mithology references... and all while being a series of detective cases...."
That is a solid choice! (Though I suspect many Potterites may take umbrage with your choice of best wizard named Harry... :))
I think I have reached out to everyone who posted here about getting their copy of The Camelot Shadow, but if you haven't heard from me, kick me in the shins! Or message me, which would be less painful for me.
So many books, so little time... yes, that is an overused cliche but so true!Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, Agatha Christie, J.K. Rowling (read all her books aloud to my kids), Nancy Drew and the Hardy Boys (from way back, not on my Kindle) and others buried in the electronic bits and bytes of my tablet. Iris Johansen (especially the stories about the rescue dog), Dick Francis (adventures on horseback). My list could get ridiculously long, so I'll stop.
Cynthia Law wrote: "So many books, so little time... yes, that is an overused cliche but so true!Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, Agatha Christie, J.K. Rowling (read all her books aloud to my kids), Nancy Drew and the Hardy ..."
Excellent choices all! I read the first two HP books to my son when he was still a bun baking in the oven (along with the Hobbit and The Princess Bride). :)
Sherlock Holmes or Cormoran Strike novels by JK Rowling. I love British mysteries. I typically don’t love American mysteries. American mysteries always seem full of gore.
Danielle wrote: "Sherlock Holmes or Cormoran Strike novels by JK Rowling. I love British mysteries. I typically don’t love American mysteries. American mysteries always seem full of gore."Thanks for weighing in, Danielle! I'm glad we're all united in our Sherlockian love. :)
Sean wrote: "Well of course you are, Luisa--you have an exquisite taste in books. Possibly the most refined on Goodreads. :)"Why thank you kind sir, could that statement possibly have anything to do with being a big fan of a certain "Mr. Handsomely-Nosed Independent Author"?
Luisa wrote: "Sean wrote: "Well of course you are, Luisa--you have an exquisite taste in books. Possibly the most refined on Goodreads. :)"Why thank you kind sir, could that statement possibly have anything to..."
Of course not! That's just a complete coincidence. (Though it really does back up my assertion.) :)



