A reckless affair and a travesty of justice

I am so sorry that my visits here continue to be hit or miss. Between trying to coddle a troublesome back and keeping the Deadline Dragon at bay and now laying siege to Kerak Castle, my nerves are vibrating like a drawn bowstring these days. I will do my best to assure you from time to time that I am still amongst the living and have not joined the Witness Protection Plan. Here is an old post from 2012 that I hope none of you remember since I hate to have to foist reruns upon you. 😊
What do a 12th century Marcher lord and a 16th century queen have in common? They were both undone by their lack of caution. William de Braose, the grandson of one of King John’s most notorious victims—his grandmother and uncle were starved to death at Windsor Castle—was hanged on this date in 1230 by the great Welsh prince, Llywelyn ab Iorwerth, after being found in compromising circumstances with Llywelyn’s wife, Joanna, in his own bedchamber. What could have been more reckless than that?
Recklessness also helped to doom that Tudor queen, for Anne Boleyn ought to have known the sort of man she’d married; had she continued to cater to his monstrous ego and bloated pride, perhaps he might not have turned on her with such terrifying suddenness, giving her time to produce the male heir that would have been her salvation. But she was too proud, too quick-tempered, and she paid a high price for that. This is a sad day for anyone who cares about justice, for on May 2, 1536, Anne was arrested at Greenwich Palace, thus setting in motion the events leading to her execution on Tower Green. I always thought one of the bravest men in the world was the Lord Mayor of London, who’d dared to say after her trial that he was convinced of her innocence. Imagine the courage that took when he’d just seen the lengths to which Henry would go to rid himself of an unwanted wife. One of the many reasons why I love the two brilliant novels about Anne’s daughter—Susan Kay’s legacy and Margaret George’s Elizabeth I—is the way both authors showed how traumatized Elizabeth was by her mother’s beheading.
Moving on, an indisputable genius died on this date in 1519, Leonardo da Vinci.
Lastly, we often talk about history trumping fiction, and nowhere is that more obvious than in Joanna’s mad affair with Will de Braose. What writer would have dared to send a woman into the bed of the man whose grandmother had been starved to death by her own father? I could not possibly make something like that up!
16 likes ·   •  7 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on May 02, 2017 13:49
Comments Showing 1-7 of 7 (7 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by RJay (new)

RJay Sharon-
Your comment about history trumping writers imaginations is so true! I find it amazing that some writers feel they need to change history for dramatic purposes when what really happened is so 'out there' it doesn't need any embellishment.

Hang tough with the Deadline Dragons and take care of yourself. We'll still be here when you have time to share with us!


message 2: by Sharon (new)

Sharon This is why my family and friends have stopped going with me to see historical films, Rosemary. They say they got tired of listening to me gnashing my teeth and muttering into my popcorn while Hollywood screenwriters play fast and loose with history. As you say, the truth is often as extraordinary as anything they can concoct.

Thanks for the good wishes, too.


message 3: by Leila (new)

Leila Hi Sharon, firstly may I add my own heartfelt wishes for your early return to better health. No apologies needed ever and I'm certain everyone who admires your brilliant books and your commitment to your readers will be saying "Hear hear"

Thank you for the heads up for Susan Kay and her book 'Legacy' Although I have Margaret George's book I had never heard of Susan's ...no prizes for guessing where I headed off to. Yes I found it! Most of the sellers are in America but I did find one in Britain.

I remember so well reading about William and Joanna in my favourite of all your books 'Here be Dragons' I was almost holding my breath as Joanna gradually gave way to William's advances. What in the name of????? I couldn't believe she would take such terrible risks especially when she loved her husband so deeply and given William's background too! For all I understand that he would be put to death I did feel for him. Joanna in some ways got off more lightly, but perhaps in the long run she suffered greatly. I think her husband probably suffered the most. Trust shattered is so hard to forgive. The truth is always stranger than fiction it is said! You take care of yourself

Bless you.

Leila


message 4: by Sharon (new)

Sharon Thank you so much, Leila. I have the best readers in the world, bar none!
I think you will really enjoy Legacy; it is the best over-all treatment of Elizabeth's life just as I think Margaret George's novel about her autumn years brilliantly captures that period. (I tried to convince her that they should call it The Lioness in Winter. :-) )
One friend of mine told me that she was dozing in bed while her husband was reading Dragons and he suddenly woke her up by shouting, "No, Joanna, no! Don't do it!" She said my books were hard on her health, for another time she was reading in bed and her teenage son came bursting into her room, crying "George is dead!" Since she had a favorite nephew named George, she said she nearly had a heart attack. But then her son said thoughtfully, "I wonder how Edward had him killed. Do you think that legend is true that he was drowned in a vat of malmsey?" Only then did she realized he was talking about George of Clarence, the Yorkist black sheep brother.
It was actually the story of Joanna's infidelity and Lywelyn's amazing ability to forgive her that nudged me in the direction of writing Dragons. As you say, trust shattered is a heart wound. And for a medieval Welsh prince to be able to forgive a wife for infidelity--especially with an Englishman--Well, it was a plot twist I'd never have dared to invent! And we know they were able to mend that broken trust because of what he did when Joanna died; not many wives had a friary founded in their memories. The only comparable act I can think of at the moment was Edward I's beautiful Eleanor crosses in honor of his queen.
PS Do let me know what you think of Legacy. Oddly, the author, Susan Kay, wrote only two novels, Legacy and one about the Phantom of the Opera.


message 5: by Leila (new)

Leila I will Sharon, you look after yourself. x


message 6: by Iset (new)

Iset Sad thoughts of Anne Boleyn every time this year.

Having read both Susan Kay and Margaret George's book, I can say they are both excellent portrayals of Elizabeth. I feel that Margaret George's book might be slightly closer to the real woman, it goes into such wonderful depth about her later life... but then it leaves you wanting more! Susan Kay covers it all, although I am left wanting greater detail!

I hope you will feel better very soon, Sharon, with all my wishes.


message 7: by Sharon (new)

Sharon Thank you, Iset! I agree that both authors have managed to craft believable portrayals of a very complex woman; I could never decide if she was brilliantly neurotic or neurotically brilliant!


back to top

Sharon Kay Penman's Blog

Sharon Kay Penman
Sharon Kay Penman isn't a Goodreads Author (yet), but they do have a blog, so here are some recent posts imported from their feed.
Follow Sharon Kay Penman's blog with rss.