Twist

Hey everyone – it’s been brought to my attention that I made several serious mistakes in my latest book, Twist. Valerie, my heroine’s best friend since childhood is a woman who was born into a male body, requiring surgical correction. My heroine and this woman are very close, and as an attempt to convey the depth of what I saw as a long-term, supportive friendship, I portrayed my heroine as “matter of fact” about her friend’s transition in a way that I now realize was insensitive.

Specifically, my heroine discussed her friend in past tense as “him,” mentioned her “dead” name, and shared with a third party that she had transitioned. It has been pointed out to me that speaking about a woman who has transitioned in the past tense as male, using her “dead” name, and/or sharing with someone that she has transitioned is considered by some to be a very serious breach of trust and friendship in the real world. While I did consult with a friend who has recently transitioned, I regret not going more deeply into the specifics of what I’d be writing.

When I wrote Val’s character, I was sincerely attempting to demonstrate in my fiction what I believe to be true on every level – that women who have transitioned are true women in every way, and should be accepted unconditionally. I believe that every human being has inalienable human rights and that we must respect who they are, regardless of whether they had the privilege to be born into a body that matches their true gender. I wish to be an ally to the trans community and I apologise to anyone who was offended by my mistakes. I intend to learn from them and do better in future.

Please note that while I welcome feedback from the trans community, I don't feel that this post is an appropriate forum for additional discussion.
50 likes ·   •  4 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on April 17, 2017 21:25
Comments Showing 1-4 of 4 (4 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Mickey (new)

Mickey Thank you for your comments, I did not sense any lack of sensitivity, if anything I appreciated the fact that you were rather matter of fact about the issue - not placing emphasis on it. I have a family member who is gay, I know how difficult her struggles were in her teens, Certainly nothing like those described in Twist, but still painful. Any light shone that helps people understand is a positive....


message 2: by Ayekah (new)

Ayekah I didn't pick up on any insensitivity either. It just seemed to flow with the story. I liked Val and understood their relationship from childhood through their adult lives. I thought it was handled with grace and dignity.


message 3: by Jennifer (new)

Jennifer I was very impressed with the way you presented Val. I feel that the way you described her history and past was from the point of view of a best friend and the journey they had been through together. While I was reading this note, a saying came to mind. "Better to have tried and failed then to have never tried at all". I am sad that Kylie Scott felt the need to write this statement/apology. I thought Val was extremely well written. I am a person, not personally touched by this situation (and would be honored to be), I was once again very impressed to see this situation brought to the forefront like this. Thank you so much Ms. Scott for your efforts to bring transgender characters to your stories!


message 4: by willaful (new)

willaful Jennifer wrote: "I was very impressed with the way you presented Val. I feel that the way you described her history and past was from the point of view of a best friend and the journey they had been through togethe..."

You've never been touched by this situation, yet somehow you know more than people who have.

It's fine to just let someone apologize for a mistake without chiming in to assure them they never needed to in the first place.


back to top