date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Gerry
(new)
Jul 29, 2016 06:45AM
The Girls: gripping? really? You are far too generous. Your books never disappoint, but I'm afraid your reviews are less reliable indicators of good writing than I'd expect.
reply
|
flag
I am a generous guy, LOL, especially when out comes to first novels. But I understand what you're saying, Gerry.
I have to agree with Gerry about The Girls. I was seriously underwhelmed with it. However, several that you mentioned I put on my wish list because, frankly, you're Chris Bohjalian. ;) But also because they sound interesting.
I hear ya, Rachel. Again, I am very kind to first novelists. I was one once. (Granted, that was in the Mesozoic Era.)
Chris wrote: "I hear ya, Rachel. Again, I am very kind to first novelists. I was one once. (Granted, that was in the Mesozoic Era.)"I appreciate that you're kind. I think Emma's writing has promise, and it's definitely exponentially better than anything I could come up with, so I will read her next as well, to see how her writing grows.
Thanks for clarifying your ***** ratings. I have a question for you: how long do you give a book before you decide you just don't want to bother finishing it?
Do you have any nonfiction you have read this year or are currently reading this summer you would recommend (besides the memoir you mentioned)?
Oh! I like that Rule. 30 years post undergraduate English major I still feel as if I HAVE to finish....I'm going to adopt your rule!
I loved THE HOPEFULS! As you said, it made me laugh and cry. I like dark books too, so Megan Abbott's YOU WILL KNOW ME had me cringing at the right places. My biggest disappointment was THE SUNSHINE PILGRIMS. I am in love with Fagan's THE PANOPTICON, but 100 pages of the new book left me watching the clock. Sophomore books need compassion, but this one needed a plot editor. Eileenps. Memoir, ALLIGATOR CANDY, I highly recommend.
I thought The Girls was brilliant. It vividly brought back the summer of 1969 to me, and found the story quite compelling. I could have finished in in two readings, but was enjoying so much I had to slow down. I got through part two of Cronin's trilogy and loved the second one more than the first. I own City of Mirrors but haven't gotten to it yet. Reading the second part of Jane Smiley's 100 years trilogy (Early Warning) and am glad to be back as an observer to the Langdon family! Will be skipping The Nest but do want to read Before the Fall...its on my Kindle which means I'll probably forget about it! And I finally read Close Your Eyes, Hold Hands on my way to Burlington and found myself looking for the homeless kids all over Church St.
Chris wrote: "I follow the Rule of Amor Towles.I give a book this many pages: 100 minus my age."
Love this!
Sherry wrote: "I thought The Girls was brilliant. It vividly brought back the summer of 1969 to me, and found the story quite compelling. I could have finished in in two readings, but was enjoying so much I had t..."
I've given up on the last two books I've started, following your Law of Amor Towles. Is this bad luck? Or is it that the book before was To Kill a Mockingbird? My son is reading it for HS sophomore English so after a 40 year hiatus (aargh, Paleolithic,) I picked it up. How do I go from A Genteman in Moscow to Mockingbird, with their lyric beauty..,, to anything? Any suggestions for a next book? This year I am thankful for all of your great books!



