Another one of history's what-if moments

I am beginning to feel like the Grim Reaper, for lately all I seem to do is write death and battle scenes. Unlike my other books, of course, which all had such happy-ever-after endings. I am playing hooky from the bloodshed long enough to wish my American friends and readers a happy Memorial Day. Do any other nations have a similar remembrance day for those who gave their lives for their country? I know you have Armistice Day in the UK, which is very similar to our Veteran’s Day. Canada? Down Under?
Anyway, on May 28, 1265, the Lord Edward outsmarted his cousin Harry de Montfort, which does not seem to have been all that difficult. Edward had been held captive since the battle of Lewes the year before, but he was treated more as a guest than a prisoner or even a hostage, and on this May afternoon, he convinced Harry that it would be fun to hold races. Harry and his knights took turns racing one another, while Edward lamented that his new stallion had gone lame. You can see where this is going, can’t you? A pity Harry couldn’t. When Edward got the signal he’d been awaiting from a nearby hill, he vaulted into the saddle of his “lame” stallion and after a mocking salute to his de Montfort cousin, spurred toward freedom. Of course Harry and the other knights pursued him, but their horses soon shortened stride, no match for Edward’s fresh stallion. Roger de Mortimer and his men then rode out to meet him, and the scene was set for the battle of Evesham in August. This is another What If moment of history. If Simon had entrusted Edward into the custody of his son Guy instead of Harry, he’d not have been able to escape. Why am I so sure? Because when some of Edward’s supporters had tried to free him from Wallingford Castle that past November, Guy had threatened to send him out to them--via a mangonel. And there would have been no Evesham if Edward had remained Simon’s hostage. English history would have taken a dramatic detour—and so would Welsh history.
12 likes ·   •  5 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on May 28, 2016 12:38
Comments Showing 1-5 of 5 (5 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Latisha (new)

Latisha In New Zealand and Australia we have an 'Anzac' day to commemorate all those who died whilst serving, Anzac stands for Australian New Zealand Army Corp! :)


message 2: by Marina (new)

Marina Bonomi November 4th for us, in Italy. Day of national unity and of the Armed Forces, specifically meant as a memorial day for the fallen.


message 3: by Estelle (new)

Estelle 14th of July, Bastille day in France for those who fight for freedom and equity between human beings ... And to remember that freedom is fragile need to be preserved


message 4: by RJay (new)

RJay Sharon - Am currently reading Dan Jones' The Plantagenets so your "this day in history" is poignant as I'm currently in the section about Henry III - and Simon has made his entrance. From your books, I recall Edward's escape and the battle that followed. It has colored my view of Edward I ever since. As always, thanks for sharing these fabulous stories of what really happened.


message 5: by Sharon (new)

Sharon Thanks, Rosemary!
I always celebrate Bastile Day, too, Estelle. I am so sorry to hear of the horrific flooding in France this week. I saw that the town of Montargis looked like Venice. I'd been there once while researching The Reckoning, for that was where Simon de Montfort's widow and daughter retreated after his defeat at Evesham. I remember it as a very pretty little town. Flooding is always heartbreaking and it is occurring more and more frequently as the world's climate changes, affecting areas that never experienced such flooding before.


back to top

Sharon Kay Penman's Blog

Sharon Kay Penman
Sharon Kay Penman isn't a Goodreads Author (yet), but they do have a blog, so here are some recent posts imported from their feed.
Follow Sharon Kay Penman's blog with rss.