Should Firestar have made Graystripe deputy when he returned to the Clan?

I always feel Graystripe got a rough deal, being sidelined by his best friend in favour of an upstart. But I can also appreciate that Brambleclaw deserved to be deputy and Firestar made a smart decision. But who's to say Graystripe wouldn't have made a better deputy than Brambleclaw? Brambleclaw's personal life is a mess. [...]