date
newest »

message 1:
by
Kristen
(new)
May 10, 2011 05:40AM

reply
|
flag

I think the next trend is going to be rock stars. I don't know why, but I do.
Also, you have now put into my head the idea of a Matrix-style Robin Hood battle. Thankyou, from the bottom of my heart. I'm going to be living off that for weeks.
As for realism, when I use the word 'realistic', I mean 'my disbelief is easily suspended'. If the world/s or premises you're writing about are detailed and explored and fleshed out well enough, and they flow, then I'm going to be more easily carried along by the novel.
Also, let's face it: I've read the original Batman origin story, and it's kinda dumb. Dressing up as a bat to combat childhood trauma is more 'sophisticated' and 'acceptable', and other 'words' like that...
Still funny, though :)

Bit of a waste.
Really bugs me that people will except all kind of unrealistic stuff as long as a movie has created it's own world and rules ( James Bond and Harry Potter are best examples.)
With comic book movies, we suddenly have adhere all the rules of reality.
Why are they the exception to the realism rule? Never got a decent answer to that one.

So by being as realistic as possible (ie assimilating), they're trying to say, 'hey, we belong here in your world'.
It's a deeply rooted inferiority complex. That's what I think.

Iron man, Thor, X-men, the first Superman movie etc.
Okay, the Dark Knight went all serious, grim and real world and made money, but that formula won't work with every character.
Course, I liked the Fantastic Four movies and didn't like the Dark Knight, so I might not be the best person to ask.

The grim formula worked for Batman, because--hey, it's Batman!
But yeah, stuff like Superman... there's no way you can angst about being HIM and have it taken seriously. From what I've heard, though, Smallville is making a decent effort at it.

Smallville was mostly teen angst and tended to flounder when it got too angsty and not enough super hero.
Not a big fan of 'Dark Knight' tries to do too much, Heath ledger's Joker only occasionally worked for me and I think his death got it too much of a mythical quality, so you can't criticize him.
Decent movie, but not the 'amazing epic and greatest comic book movie ever!' that people make it out to be.

I kid, I kid.
Damn, I meant Batman Begins, not The Dark Knight. It's just because that one is so well-known that my brain got scrambled.
Hey, did you know DC's giving all their comics a reboot from #1 in August this year? I hope it works out, because I'm just thinking: Finally! A chance to get on board with them!

Batman Begins is a better movie than 'Dark Knight' , in my humble opinion, but still deeply flawed.
I do know about the big reboot and I have mixed feelings.
The good: lots of second tier characters are getting a shot at the spotlight and neglected genres ( Westerns, military action, horror etc) are getting a shot and the the general scrapping the barnacles of history off some characters.
The bad: some really ugly costume redesigns ( why does it look like Superman is wearing body armor? He's Superman?! and if that's realistic, why is Wonder Woman still wearing basically a corset?)
While trying to simplify things there will still be seven Batman related titles, 4 Superman, and 4 Green Lantern.
I'm staying optimistic about it and applaud Dc taking a risk on some obscure heroes, but of the 52 titles, I plan on only trying maybe 20 and of that expect I'll only stay with 10 for more than five issues.
and becuase I haven't ranted enough about comics: my philosophy on comics is if there's a character or team you are interested in go to a comic shop and grab an issue where the cover catches your eye.
Doesn't matter what the issue number is, if that issue doesn't hook you , then the writer wasn't doing their job, move on and try something else.
If you liked it then decide 'Do I want to get the numbers before this one and see how we got here or do I want to just keep going?"
That's the joy of a good comic book.

But when I get a chance, I'll definitely keep your philosophy in mind :)

I have my 'wish list' of stuff I'm looking for, but I'm quite happy to just prowl the shelves seeing what I can find until my wife drags me out.

New thought: after reading the 128th review for a supernatural series about a girl who is some kind of 'chosen one', but is also trying to juggle a complicated and supernatural love life ( have you noticed that nearly all of them feature a love triangle and one guy is always a werewolf and the other is a vampire?) I have this urge to try and write one.

It just seems every other book being reviewed on GR is some kind of urban fantasy about a woman that fights some kind of monsters and so many of them look pretty bad.
I keep thinking I could do one and couldn't possibly be as bad as some of the ones out there.
Not sure if I'd try and use all the cliches and see if I could make them work/interesting to me or if I would ignore them.
and no, I haven't seen any of your writing. I got think I got distracted talking about my stuff.
You'll have to point me in the direction of some of your stuff.