date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
M.J.
(new)
Apr 25, 2016 08:36AM
I read a number of your comments on the mystery writer blog. That is a practical and fun collection of musings. Writing in first person is powerful, as you say. It forces some strange revelations out of the protag. Very nice blog. I like it! Lots of food for thought.
reply
|
flag
Ugh I'm screaming! I just got that novel to the point of being at a long (one of last) edits and now I see I have to RE-WORK the whole freaking thing!! I wrote it in third person for a lot of good reasons but I realize it won't do. Oh it could do. But I wrote "Self" in first person present from three-4 yr. old dissociating child's point of view to eliminate the need for adult descriptions of the actions. I think that's where the power comes from. Since "Fulcum..." is from adult view I have to deal with "some doors I'd rather leave shut" as you wrote. I can't leave them shut in first person. Remarque appears always to use first person. Then you mention it. The book IS fiction. sorta. But not emotional fiction. g+ is the subconscious plot. I suppose it's the rough draft. It scares me. I'm afraid to write it. All the blasted marketing is so time consuming. Was there ever a well-written book with explicit sex, an adult book? If so I haven't read it. The childhood stuff just grows up with us it never goes away. "Fulcrum of Desire" is the adult version of how the blunt force of childhood experiences twist and turn. No matter that I destroyed all my college notebooks, tore up all the artwork and burned it in the fire it is still as real as if I never did it. I don't know what made me think it would make it go away. I guess it's got to burn through me. Sorry. I thought maybe you'd like the truth given how you wrote "Proud Bastards" and how much you like Remarque. It takes everything to produce it as experienced.
Yikes, an entire re-write! Are you sure? Third-person can be effective. I certainly wasn't trying to influence you to go first-person. You know what YOU have to do. Go with your heart and soul.--Michael
I know you weren't. I'm thinking on it. I think I'll write a scene from first-person and see how it goes. The problem is the dissociative identity thing in the protag. She splits. And she's unconscious during important scenes. I will go with my heart and soul. I always do. Please note, I appreciate nudges you have given very much. You are so talented, polished and accomplished that it inspires me to write my best. I need nudges from time to time. It doesn't matter if they lead me to question what I'm doing.
(M.J. wrote): You are so talented, polished and accomplished that it inspires me to write my best.Okay, now you're making me blush (uncomfortable). I've never taken compliments well (something my PTSD counselor and I talked about many times). I simply don't see where what I do is any big deal. I write; I've had modest success. It is what it is. My life experiences are to be credited (blamed?) for who I am and what I do. I've simply learned (finally!) to go with the flow. :-)
Oh, I am sorry to make you blush. That would be interesting. You should learn to take compliments better as you have done much with your writing and are not the best judge of what you do for the writing you have done ( which is much) and the important things you do personally for other writers who have done less and who struggle with the ghost of PTSD. It is midnight and I have had some wine and feel better for it. There is a storm and lots of lightning. I really hope you understand how important it is for people to have someone to write to and nudges when they need them and to feel there is some contact in a world where writers, who are sensitive creatures but durable do have a struggle with things others don't deal with. Go with the flow and you never know if your success is modest or not. I say it is not modest. I dare say I know good writing when I see it and much better than good as well. I say soak in the comments and let the thank yous (is that a word) refresh your being and know that you are needed and blessed with special talent. I mean what I say and even more after some wine. :-) If everyone had such modest success we would all be happy. Don't let the PTSD take away from it.


