Badly Done, New York Times

[Warning for triggers: rape, and infuriatingly offensive reporting of same]

God, it infuriates me when the New York Times, reporting about a case of gang rape in Cleveland, Texas, decides that it's appropriate to include this in the article: "Residents in the neighborhood where the abandoned trailer stands — known as the Quarters — said the victim had been visiting various friends there for months. They said she dressed older than her age, wearing makeup and fashions more appropriate to a woman in her 20s. She would hang out with teenage boys at a playground, some said."

Because we all know what it means, right, that she "dressed older than her age" and "would hang out with teenage boys?" New York Times, you must be aware that that's code for "she was asking for it?" And that by printing this statement without drawing any critical attention to it, you're suggesting it could be true?

Also, did I mention yet that we're talking about an eleven-year-old girl, which makes your perpetuation of the "she asked for it" myth even more reprehensible (though please note, it would be reprehensible regardless of her age)?

The "asking for it" suggestion is especially troublesome in an article that also contains the choice words: "The case has rocked this East Texas community to its core and left many residents in the working-class neighborhood where the attack took place with unanswered questions. Among them is, if the allegations are proved, how could their young men have been drawn into such an act?"

Drawn into? Seriously?

And if that weren't already offensive enough, this line, which, please note, is in reference to the mother of the victim: "'Where was her mother? What was her mother thinking?' said Ms. Harrison, one of a handful of neighbors who would speak on the record."

How was this article allowed to print? Do we really need the New York Times perpetuating the myth that a rape victim is in any way responsible for being raped? And suggesting that her mother was somehow responsible? Eighteen young men forced an eleven-year-old girl to take her clothes off, threatened to beat her if she didn't, then raped her, then circulated footage, recorded on cell phone cameras, around school, and this is how the New York Times sees fit to report it? How did those poor boys ever get drawn in? Here's another actual line from the article: "'It's just destroyed our community,' said Sheila Harrison, 48, a hospital worker who says she knows several of the defendants. 'These boys have to live with this the rest of their lives.'"

I think my head is going to explode.

The only reason any of these statements would have been print-worthy, relevant, or appropriate is if this article were an exposé on a few people in a town who have really f***ed up ideas about who is responsible when eighteen young men have gang-raped an eleven-year-old girl, the rapists or the victim.

Badly done, New York Times.
12 likes ·   •  16 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on March 09, 2011 12:55
Comments Showing 1-16 of 16 (16 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Amber Lessa (new)

Amber Lessa Well said! Did you send a copy into the editor?


ChaoticallyNatasha Wow! I haven't heard about that! But well done calling New York Times out on that, Kristin!


message 3: by Justin (new)

Justin Fraxi UGH. I wasn't aware that the New York Times was trash journalism, but apparently it is. :/


message 4: by Tommie (last edited Mar 09, 2011 06:35PM) (new)

Tommie That is horrifying and frightening. I can't even behin to wrap my head around it. I agree that you should send a copy of this to the editor. Well said.


message 5: by Artemis (new)

Artemis This is crap. Really, the raptists have to live with the horror of raping a girl all their lives! Gasps, that is sooooo sad, oh my, what if they can't stand it, get depression and commit suicide?
Seriously, what's wrong with the residents there and the journalists? Shouldn't these "sympathetic" words be said to the victim, the girl, and not the rapists? I think you really should send a copy of this to New York Times, cause what they are printing is - excuse my language - bull sh**!


message 6: by Andrea (new)

Andrea And so, some ask, where is the future of feminism headed, when "journalists" are allowed to publish garbage like this?


message 7: by Artemis (new)

Artemis Exactly, just why can men treat women as a lesser being just because we're not as strong as they are?


message 8: by Doug (new)

Doug Unfortunately that kind of sexist thinking is so ingrained that most people would read it and not even consider just how ridiculous and horrifying it is!


message 9: by Artemis (new)

Artemis I'm sorry Christians, but I've gotta say some of these ingrained sexist thinkings came from the Church. It's Eve who was tempted and ate the apple first. Women are weak and can not rule. Women are the temptress and it is because of them, that the kingdom falls to dust... And so on and so on. Ironically, yesterday was International Women's Day.


message 10: by Jaime (new)

Jaime West it just goes to show that no matter how low men can stoop they can always manage to find a way of blaming the woman for their actions.. or in this case a little girl!! Did you notice how the article never asked 'where was her FATHER?' no it's the mothers fault and the daughters fault, cause an 11 year old girl made 18 men rape her.. get real!!
All eighteen men should be tried as adults.. and then the parents (mum & dad) should be made accountable for the where abouts and actions of their sons!!
disgusting!


message 11: by Jasmine (new)

Jasmine Absolutely horrible. Thank you for writing this, and bringing it to people's attention.


message 12: by Vanessa (new)

Vanessa I agree ... it's absolutely unbelievable that an article like that would be printed in ANY newspaper, regardless of whether it is the New York Times or some obscure small-town paper.


message 13: by Jennifer (new)

Jennifer That type of reporting is horiffic and what's scarier is that someone allowed that drivel to be published. How sad! This is truly bad form for the NYT.


message 14: by Artemis (new)

Artemis I hope people won't just buy all the crappy words and sentences they are printing on the papers. I mean, I'm 14, and if I know what's wrong with this article, which is like, everything, then why would the residents and the press think otherwise? Are their IQ below a 14-year-old? It's quite sad how people can be blinded like this, not knowing black from white.


message 15: by Cassie (new)

Cassie The article mentions the "whereabouts of the victim and her mother were not made public." Perhaps the father is not in the picture and perhaps the mother was at work during all of this. And who knows? Maybe the mother never suspected these boys capable of such a thing. She could have seen them as adopted older brothers for her little girl. Sometimes it's so difficult to be an outsider looking in (After all, we only know how the reporter has described the situation). It amazes me how quickly people can judge others, as many seemed to judge this girl by her appearance. I don't know this eleven-year-old and what her interest was in the older boys. But only a fool would question who was at fault here.

I'm surprised that more in the community didn't comment on the videos going around and that these boys have some serious issues, the ones that the article implies many wish protect. It's hard to imagine what this women is looking for:
“It’s devastating, and it’s really tearing our community apart,” she said. “I really wish that this could end in a better light.”

Could it end any better than providing justice and safety for the girl? It also wouldn't hurt for the community to set aside prejudices and learn to support one another so that travesties like this would be less likely to occur in the future.


message 16: by William (new)

William Bentrim Well written, couldn't agree with you more. The irresponsible reporting is 2nd only to the inconceivable bad behavior of the rapists.


back to top

Kristin Cashore's Blog

Kristin Cashore
Kristin Cashore isn't a Goodreads Author (yet), but they do have a blog, so here are some recent posts imported from their feed.
Follow Kristin Cashore's blog with rss.