A Note on My Goodreads Ratings

Now that DIE FOR ME's release date approaches, I have more and more people friending and following my reviews on Goodreads. You've probably noticed that I don't give most books a star-rating, while for others I do. So I wanted to let you know just what my perhaps-confusing rating rules are!

This is my system of rating: I put my very favorite books up on Goodreads with 4 or 5 stars - mainly to give an idea of what I love, and sometimes because I'm so excited about a book I just have to tell someone.

HOWEVER, I do not give stars to YA or books similar to my own, or books by friends. If I hate a book, I won't even put it on Goodreads. If I put a YA book on Goodreads, I will tell you what I liked about it, but not what I didn't like. These authors are my colleagues, and I am not a reviewer, so I don't feel the responsibility to point out what I might see as their failings.

I will also always let you know if I am friends with someone, touring with them, etc. so you can consider that as you read my comments.

Oh, and if anyone ever wants to label me as YA Mafia, I would like my code-name to be Scarf-face. Just saying...

Happy reading, everyone!

♥Amy
1 like ·   •  3 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on March 08, 2011 05:04
Comments Showing 1-3 of 3 (3 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by katrina (new)

katrina Honestly its nice to know what people do think of books, but if we took for granted everyones star ratings we wouldnt read half the books we do ;) So realistically its best to read a book for yourself ,, but saying that if a book has been rated one star consideration is taken into that ;)
:) and your book is getting closer,, I checked Book depo today and not long till mine gets shipped !!!! ayayayay... cant wait !! Best of luck Amy !! Im sure we will all love it !!!


message 2: by oliviasbooks (new)

oliviasbooks Amy, your post will probably get lost later on. Maybe you can fix your explanation on your profile. (i haven't checked, since I am surfing on my mobile right now.)


message 3: by Amy (new)

Amy Plum Olivia - I had actually already done that, but dropped it into the "About Me" section. Which I can't actually see in my profile. Is there somewhere better to put it?

And Katrina - thank you for the good wishes and encouragement! (And additional thanks for buying the book!) :)


back to top