Michael Shermer's Blog, page 23

Tony Blair's Answer

The Force of Ideas Over the Force of Arms

Shermer and Tony Blair

Last week I attended the Khosla Ventures summit at Cavello Point in Sausalito, California, an ex-army base converted to a posh resort, where the venture capitalist (he calls himself a "venture assistant") Vinod Khosla brings together start-up CEOs and their venture backers who are together innovating new science and technologies for alternative and environmentally efficient energy sources. Vinod heard my TED talk in Long Beach...

The Rules of Capitalism, Part 3

Liberty and The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance.

This is the third essay in a series on the relationship between rules, freedom, and prosperity.
Read part 1 on Skepticblog.org and part 2 over at True/Slant.

I believe that the following commentary on the necessity of law and order has some bearing on what is unfolding in Arizona—when the rules are not clearly written or consistently enforced, people will take the law into their own hands because society cannot run smoothly without law and...

Doing Science in the Past

The comparative method of historical science helps to explain Haiti's poverty

HISTORY IS NOT OFTEN THOUGHT OF AS A SCIENCE, but it can be if it uses the "comparative method." Jared Diamond, professor of geography at the University of California, Los Angeles, and James A. Robinson, professor of government at Harvard University, employ the method effectively in the new book they have co-edited, Natural Experiments of History. (Order the lecture on DVD. Jared Diamond lectured, based on this...

Good Rules Make Good Capitalists, Part 1

image via Wikipedia

As the SEC prepares its case against Goldman Sachs for allegedly intentionally defrauding the public with toxic securities that it created, sold, then bet against, I want to reflect for a moment on the need for rules in a free market society. Critics of capitalism believe that we libertarians want an essentially lawless society in which people are free to do whatever they want. That may be true for some libertarians, but I have come to believe through experience and...

Why We Are Hardwired for Belief in God

On April 10 the Wall Street Journal published a debate between myself and Gregory Paul on the question of whether or not belief in God is innate. Here are the links to the two articles:

http://tinyurl.com/y8n7qg6
http://tinyurl.com/y52ckwf

The online version was well edited but shorter than my original draft, which I present here just for the record. Enjoy.

According to Oxford University Press's World Christian Encyclopedia, 84 percent of the world's population belongs to some form...

Would I Ever Pray for a Miracle?

Watch ABC 20/20 Special on Miracles to Find Out…

Elizabeth Vargas hosts 20/20 special on miracles

Last night ABC 20/20 aired a one-hour special on miracles (such topics are common faire on television during Christmas and Easter week) hosted by Elizabeth Vargas, this one featuring the usual array of "unexplained" recoveries from injury and disease, in this case a brain injury, cancer, and Parkinson's disease. (See my interview segments at 26:34, 28:35, 38:15, 39:05.) The producers called me on ...

The Sensed-Presence Effect

How the brain produces the sense of someone present when no one is there

In the 1922 poem The Waste Land, T. S. Eliot writes, cryptically: Who is the third who always walks beside you? / When I count, there are only you and I together / But when I look ahead up the white road / There is always another one walking beside you.

In his footnotes to this verse, Eliot explained that the lines "were stimulated by the account of one of the Antarctic expeditions [Ernest Shackleton's:] … that the party...

Does the moon exist if there are no sentient beings to look at it?

In my last True/Slant post I explained why it is that quantum effects do not apply to the macro world because of the size difference between sub-atomic particles and (say) chemical reactions inside the neurons in your head, concluding:

During the debate Deepak claimed that the moon is nothing more than a soup of teaming quantum uncertainty. No. Subatomic particles may be altered when they are observed, but the moon is there even if no one looks at it.

Deepak wrote a thoughtful response to this ...

Pentagon Gunman a Conspiracy Theorist & 9/11 Truther

What's the harm in believing nonsense? I get asked this all the time: "Oh come on Shermer, let people have their delusions, what's the harm?"

I have a laundry list of retorts to this challenge, from the value of living in a rational world that is based in reality to tales of people who have died from discredited medical practices, such as "Attachment Therapy" — in April, 2000, 10-year old Candace Newmaker was smothered to death in blankets by therapists who were helping "rebirth" her so...

Surviving Death on Larry King Live

Obscurantism and obfuscation on national television

Have you ever died and come back to life? Me neither. No one has. But plenty of people say that they have, and their experiences were the subject of an episode of Larry King Live last December on which I appeared as the token skeptic among a tableful of believers, including CNN's medical correspondent Sanjay Gupta, New Age author Deepak Chopra, a football referee who "died" on the playing field, and an 11-year-old boy named James Leininger...