Terry Teachout's Blog, page 95

TT: Snapshot

Anton Chekhov's Swan Song, performed by John Gielgud and directed by Kenneth Branagh. This telecast was filmed in 1992:



(This is the latest in a series of arts-related videos that appear in this space each Monday and Wednesday.)

TT: Closing the circle

My mother's house in Smalltown, U.S.A., is no longer empty. David and Kathy, my sister-in-law, moved in this weekend. I've written in this space about their decision to do so. My mother, who entered a nursing home a year and a half ago and spent the rest of her life there, knew of their plans and approved of them wholeheartedly. She had come to terms with the inescapable fact that she would never again be able to live at home, and it meant the world to her to know that the house at 713 Hickory Drive, which she loved, would stay in the family.

David, who is a virtuoso amateur carpenter, started remodeling the house last March, two months before my mother's death. It took me aback when I first saw my old bedroom stripped bare, but I knew as well as my mother that it was important for David and Kathy to feel free to reshape the house in their own image. I unhesitatingly gave them my blessing, and since then I've rejoiced each time they send me a snapshot of the work that David is doing on the interior of the place where I spent twelve happy years.

The work is not yet complete, but David and Kathy are now temporarily ensconced in--yes--my old room, into which they have moved the furniture from the master bedroom in which my mother and father used to sleep. I can't tell you how much it pleases me to know that.

"The past is a foreign country: they do things differently there," L.P. Hartley wrote in The Go-Between. I know that is true, but I also believe deeply in the communion of souls past and present. By choosing to live at 713 Hickory Drive, David and Kathy have chosen to keep faith with the departed souls of our beloved parents, and with the blessed childhood that those two good people made for us.

When David texted me on Sunday letting me know that he and Kathy had finally made the move, I sent this reply: Welcome home, my brother.

* * *

The opening of Joseph Losey's film version of The Go-Between, adapted by Harold Pinter from the novel. Sir Michael Redgrave is the narrator and the score is by Michel Legrand:

TT: Lookback

From 2004:

The last time I finished writing a book (as opposed to editing a collection, which feels much less eventful) was on September 4, 2001. I'd actually typed the final words of The Skeptic: A Life of H.L. Mencken years earlier--I wrote the prologue and epilogue first--and I'd completed the next-to-last draft of the book in late August, but it was on the afternoon of September 4 that I finished editing the last draft and started printing out the manuscript. I didn't open a bottle of champagne or go out to dinner: instead, I spent the evening alone and went to bed early. I'd been working under extreme pressure all summer, and now, at last, the heat was off. I delivered the manuscript to my agent the next day and caught a plane to Missouri to visit my mother the day after that.

I was expecting to feel a touch of post-partum depression sooner or later, as most writers do when they finish writing a long book. Then, five days later, my mother's phone rang and a caller from the Upper West Side told me to turn on the TV. That was the last time I thought about Mencken, or my book, for the next few weeks....

Read the whole thing here .

TT: Almanac

"In the rotation of crops there was a recognized season for wild oats; but they were not sown more than once."

Edith Wharton, The Age of Innocence

WHEN "JAZZ" WAS A DIRTY WORD

" Fire up the time machine, set the controls for New Orleans in 1907 and make your way to a rickety night spot on Perdido Street that is known to the locals as Funky Butt Hall. Look closely and you might see a child in short pants peering through a crack in the wall and listening to the band inside. The child is Louis Armstrong, and the band, a combo led by a cornet player named Buddy Bolden, is playing a brand-new style of music that sounds like a cross between ragtime and the blues. Don't call it 'jazz,' though, because nobody in Funky Butt Hall will know what you're talking about..."

TT: Almanac

"Mrs. Ballinger is one of the ladies who pursue Culture in bands, as though it were dangerous to meet it alone."

Edith Wharton, "Xingu"

TT: Just because

"The Music Box," starring Stan Laurel and Oliver Hardy and directed by James Parrott:



(This is the latest in a series of arts-related videos that appear in this space each Monday and Wednesday.)

TT: From "jass" to jazz

The word "jazz" first started to appear regularly in print a century ago this month. On Saturday, the weekend edition of The Wall Street Journal invited me to commemorate the anniversary. Here's an excerpt.

* * *

Fire up the time machine, set the controls for New Orleans in 1907 and make your way to a rickety night spot on Perdido Street that is known to the locals as Funky Butt Hall. Look closely and you might see a child in short pants peering through a crack in the wall and listening to the band inside. The child is Louis Armstrong, and the band, a combo led by a cornet player named Buddy Bolden, is playing a brand-new style of music that sounds like a cross between ragtime and the blues.

Don't call it "jazz," though, because nobody in Funky Butt Hall will know what you're talking about. They call it "ragtime." And don't try to tell them that it will someday be played in concert halls, because if you do, they'll laugh you off the dance floor. Bolden's band played background music for bumping, grinding, drinking and fighting. Nobody in New Orleans thought of it as art, and nobody would think of it that way for years to come. Well into the '60s, there were still plenty of skeptics who continued to question the musical worth of jazz, and one of the reasons for their persistent skepticism was the fact that it had been born in honky tonks with names like Funky Butt Hall.

The word "jazz" didn't appear in print with any frequency until March 1913, exactly a century ago. What's more, it doesn't seem to have had anything to do with music, nor was the word coined in New Orleans....

* * *

Read the whole thing here .

TT: An unrecovered memory

Richard Powell, my first music teacher, died eight years ago, on which occasion I wrote about what brought the two of us together:

So much of life is a matter of pure coincidence (if that's what you think it is). I happened to see a televised concert by the Russian violinist David Oistrakh one Sunday afternoon, and the warmth and passion with which he played the Brahms D Minor Sonata, a piece I'd never heard by a composer I knew only for having written a lullaby, made a fateful impression on me. Dick Powell came to Matthews Elementary School a few months later to administer a musical aptitude test to the fifth grade, and I got a perfect score. This, he informed me the following week, qualified me to play a stringed instrument. I went home and told my astonished parents that I wanted them to buy me a violin, and that was that.

I doubt there have been many days in my life as fateful as that Sunday afternoon. I'd heard a certain amount of classical music by 1967--most of it on The Ed Sullivan Show--but my parents listened to pre-rock pop music, not Bach, Beethoven, or Brahms, and so it hadn't occurred to me that I might play an instrument, any more than the fact that I spent most of my free time reading made me want to become a writer. That came later. It was seeing David Oistrakh that made me want to play the violin, and thus set me on the road to the life of art. It's not much of an exaggeration to say that my identity as an adult arose from that event....

That, at any rate, is how I remember it, and it pleased me greatly to discover that the same telecast of the Brahms D Minor Sonata that I saw as a boy has now been posted on YouTube. It turns out that the pianist was none other than Sviatoslav Richter, and the performance, not at all surprisingly, is magnificent.

Alas, there's a catch: I looked up the program and found, very much to my surprise, that it aired in 1970, three years after Dick Powell came to Matthews Elementary School and discovered that I was a born musician.

In other words, I really do remember seeing David Oistrakh on TV when I was young--but that wasn't what made me want to become a musician. The proximate cause of that fateful decision is lost, presumably forever, in the thickening mists of a middle-aged man's faulty memory.

Are you thinking what I'm thinking? This is the West, sir. When the legend becomes fact, print the legend. That oft-quoted line from John Ford's The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance has been wrangled over endlessly and heatedly by critics and commentators. David Thomson, for one, holds it in something close to contempt:

All of a sudden, the Ford ethos looks fossilized, yet there he is urging us to believe in the legend and call it fact. By 1962, surely it was plain to anyone that the movies had done terrible damage to a sense of American history with their addled faith in bogus myths.

I wouldn't go nearly that far, though I do understand what Thomson is getting at. For my own part, I suggest the following amendment: When the legend becomes fact, print the legend--but if it turns out not to be true, print that, too.

* * *

David Oistrakh and Sviatoslav Richter play the Brahms D Minor Sonata at Alice Tully Hall in 1970:

TT: Only when they talk

In today's Wall Street Journal I review three shows, the Broadway revival of Cinderella , the off-Broadway premiere of Jesse Eisenberg's The Revisionist , and Ann , a new one-woman play written by and starring Holland Taylor. Here's an excerpt.

* * *

The new Broadway revival of "Rodgers + Hammerstein's Cinderella" (to give the show its freshly minted, officially sanctioned title) could have been wonderful. The show itself is a gem, a compact operetta with a radiant score, and virtually every aspect of this production is right on target, starting with Laura Osnes, the star, who looks like she stepped out of a storybook and sings like she stepped out of a dream.

So what went wrong? Douglas Carter Beane.

Mr. Beane, who wrote the books for "Lysistrata Jones" and "Xanadu," two of the worst musicals to have been mounted on Broadway in the past decade, was hired by the Rodgers and Hammerstein estate to supply a modernized book for "Cinderella." In so doing, he smeared cheap, jeering "Family Guy"-style sarcasm and faux-irony ("If you can't afford a nice dress, you don't have any business marrying a prince") all over the show, thereby wrecking it beyond any possibility of repair....

Jesse Eisenberg, who got an Oscar nomination for his role in "The Social Network," has now written a three-person play called "The Revisionist," in which he shares the stage with none other than Vanessa Redgrave. He plays an immature young novelist who has traveled to Poland to visit his septuagenarian cousin (Ms. Redgrave), a Holocaust survivor who treats him with oppressive solicitude and who has--you guessed it--a Deep Secret. Nothing very surprising happens in "The Revisionist," which is a young man's play, loosely structured, full of off-the-rack situations (except for the ending, which is tough and unexpected) and stronger on personality than plot. But Ms. Redgrave digs deep into Mr. Eisenberg's standard-issue Jewish-mother character...

It may well be that the life of the late Ann Richards, a one-term Texas governor who is mainly known outside her home state for having said that George H.W. Bush was "born with a silver foot in his mouth," is worthy of commemoration with a sharp, knowing one-woman play. "Ann," written by and starring Holland Taylor, isn't it. The play's original subtitle, "An Affectionate Portrait of Ann Richards," gives the game away. Ms. Taylor, lately of "Two and a Half Men," goes to enormous trouble not to question, even in passing, the received wisdom about Ms. Richards, which is that she was a great wit and a greater stateswoman. The problem is that neither of these traits is evident from "Ann," which is static, self-congratulatory and full of po-faced lines like "Life is not fair, but government should be."...

* * *

Read the whole thing here .

A complete kinescope of the dress rehearsal of the original 1957 telecast of Cinderella: