Mark Anthony Neal's Blog, page 418
December 9, 2018
Soundcheck: Composer and Drummer Tyshawn Sorey Explores Time

Published on December 09, 2018 14:19
On Seeing an Africa Beyond Our Anti-Blackness

Published on December 09, 2018 14:01
December 8, 2018
'Fight The Power': The Isley Brothers, Public Enemy and A Tale Of 2 Anthems

Published on December 08, 2018 17:51
‘I Gotta Fight for My Girl’: Adam Levine, ‘The Voice’ and the Kinship of Whiteness by Stephane Dunn

‘I Gotta Fight for My Girl’: Adam Levine, ‘The Voice’ and the Kinship of Whiteness by Stephane Dunn | @DrStephaneDunn | NewBlackMan (in Exile)
Every week during the season of TV’s The Voice, competing singers have to reclaim the right to be there. What happened two weeks or three prior - whether the artist got the most votes, the least votes or was number one on iTunes the prior week - never equals a guarantee of staying. Each singer is as good as the last performance voted on. Fans don’t always reward the best voice performance. Competing singers and viewers must ride with the frustrating, jarring incongruities between talent and popularity. That’s why the coaches, in this case Adam Levine, Blake Shelton and whichever current two female coaches on The Voice’s absurd rotation happen to be in the chairs, must do their absolute best to be mentor-coaches that champion the talented overlooked underdogs on their team.
During a crucial elimination round, Adam Levine made a mockery of that pretense when he did the unthinkable and told his fans that instead of voting for his singer DeAndre Nico who clearly outperformed Blake team member Dave Fenley, they should vote for his young team member Reagan Strange. In his words, he had to fight "for his girl" because she can't do it for herself. And clearly, too many fans uncritically followed his lead. Reagan Strange was in the bottom three and was present, as Carson Daly kept repeating, but too ill to perform.
While there has been some social media furor over Levine throwing Nico "under the bus" or 'Kanye Westing" him, not enough, if anything, will be said about the not so covert gendered racial implications of the Levine spectacle with assistance from the strangely unprepared Voice rule makers.
These days gendered racial politics become real enough to confront primarily when they are ‘visible’ through some controversial language uttered on-air or over Twitter or when racial violence makes news. Harder to call out is the kind of insidious and persistent racial politics that is rooted in the conscious of American culture and in individuals through social conditioning and personal identification which comes to the fore often in emotional moments. These days, heavy highlight on this is often limited to major elections or reflections on a historical episode like the OJ Simpson trial when it’s okay to address how racial and or gender bias influences people’s choices.
Levine cast Reagan Strange and himself as star sympathetic players in the narrative he wrote from the coach’s chair. To paraphrase him, he had to rally behind Strange because of his "special relationship" with her and he has "two little girls at home. He was thinking as a father. [Read: Reagan was like his own].
It was a very John Grisham A Time to Kill Jake-like summation. In the movie adaptation, Jake, played by Matthew McConaughey, asks the all-White jury members to imagine that the victim is a little White girl who was violated by two White men instead of the young Black girl (Tonya Lee) who is the actual victim in order to get his Black client (Sam Jackson) acquitted by the southern White jury .
DeAndre Nico was clearly the favored when the voting began and deserved to be after his performance, but with Levine’s emotional display of kinship with Reagan Strange over his other singer, they were suddenly neck and neck then Strange a sliver ahead. Completing the narrative of the girl like one of his daughters needing and deserving to be rescued, The Voice was quick enough to heighten the melodrama by suddenly showing Levine’s imaginary other daughter, cutting to a dewy eyed Reagan Strange, clinging to her mother and looking impossibly young and tragic in what appeared to be a white robe.
But let’s say the covert racialized gender implications of Levine’s spectacle still seem too far-fetched to grasp. Imagine the situation reversed. DeAndre Nico is ill and cannot fight to stay with a last performance and Reagan Strange performs and bests Blake’s singer.
Cut to Adam Levine. He is sympathizing with Nico remarking how sad it is he can’t perform. He reminds us that DeAndre Nico is a great singer, and it’s all so sad. But he has none of the personal identification he cited in his endorsement of Reagan. He doesn’t see or characterize DeAndre Nico as a tragically robbed figure. He does not equally value Nico’s story, his disappointment, or possible fate as the older contestant and as a black male R&B singer with arguably less time, opportunity, and representation in the semi- and finals rounds of the show.
Nico’s inability to take the stage, his not being a young White girl that would provoke Levine’s association with his own or faith in him as a sympathetic figure for viewer support doomed Nico personal even before he performed so well.
It was disheartening for what it taught Reagan Strange and Levine’s girls at home and for what it reiterated to DeAndre Nico and viewers. The content of your talent and representation does not trump personal alliance even if you do the best performance of the battle moment The personal and cultural identification of all three singers - Nico, Strange, and Adam Levine most of all, played the defining role in who stayed when he determined that one of his singers was his really his own. So much for being judged by the performance.
+++
Stephane Dunn is a writer and professor and the director of the Morehouse College Cinema, Television, & Emerging Media Studies Program (CTEMS). Her publications include the 2008 book Baad Bitches & Sassy Supermamas: Black Power Action Films(U of Illinois) and a number of articles in mediums such as Ebony.com, The Atlantic, The Root.com, Bright Lights Film journal, and others. Follow her on Twitter at twitter @DrStephaneDunn and www.stephanedunn.com.
Published on December 08, 2018 14:11
December 7, 2018
Black Women Who Brunch: Voices from the Writers Room

The Hollywood Reporter
Published on December 07, 2018 05:26
December 6, 2018
Black Women are Dying From Cervical Cancer in Alabama

Published on December 06, 2018 03:58
December 5, 2018
Zócalo Public Square: What Does the Life of Frederick Douglass Tell Us About America?

Published on December 05, 2018 04:24
Voter Suppression in the Twenty-First Century: a Conversation with Carol Anderson

Published on December 05, 2018 03:55
December 4, 2018
A Trap Jazz Classic: Bridget Ramsey ----- Save Your Love for Me featuring Ursula Rucker

Published on December 04, 2018 08:05
What the New York Times Doesn't Write About When it Writes about Policing and White Supremacy.

Published on December 04, 2018 05:13
Mark Anthony Neal's Blog
- Mark Anthony Neal's profile
- 30 followers
Mark Anthony Neal isn't a Goodreads Author
(yet),
but they
do have a blog,
so here are some recent posts imported from
their feed.
