Catching Fire (The Hunger Games, #2) Catching Fire discussion


328 views
Am I the only one who doesn't approve of Sam Claffin as Finnick??

Comments Showing 1-50 of 67 (67 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1

Shula Am I?


em (lattereads) No, you're not. I wanted Alex Pettyfer. He looks just like I imagined Finnick.


★ Mist ☆ Cassidy ★ I thought they had officially cast Finnick in July...


Zaheen Alex Pettyfer or Sam Claffin are fine by me, i mean cummon apreciate it isnt someone ultra ugly!!!


message 5: by Jo (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jo I don't hate or adore him for it. He's just not a knockout.


message 6: by [deleted user] (new)

I don't think Pettyfer would do the role justice-there would be too much focus on Pettyfer and no one would pay attention to anyone else.

@Tirzah, no, but basically every official ish site (IMdB and such) have him rumoured-now, that does not mean it is him, but if you were to put your money on him, you'd have a decent chance at winning. Who knows, maybe it'll be Daniel Newman?(He was the first rumoured and someone posted he was Finnick on IMdB a couple months ago. It was random, and the site took it down though)


Heather You are not alone! I just do not see it! I know movie magic can do wonders but you still want the person to look like the part before make up and wardrobe. I thought I was the only one.


Shula Heather wrote: "You are not alone! I just do not see it! I know movie magic can do wonders but you still want the person to look like the part before make up and wardrobe. I thought I was the only one."

Yay!


Cassie Lynn Actually, I love him as Finnick. Exactly how I imagined him.


Fallon Moore I want Alex Pettyfer for Finnick. He is exactly what I had pictured when I first read Catching Fire and Mockingjay. I vote no for Sam Clafflin.


message 11: by Elia (new) - rated it 5 stars

Elia Yeah, I'm not sold. He looks nothing like I imagined Finnick. However, I do have to say that I have liked all the other casting choices, so maybe I will be pleasantly surprised once I see his performance.


message 12: by Zoeღ (last edited Aug 21, 2012 03:24PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Zoeღ i dont like him. But I've heard that they just offered him the role and he hasnt descided yet. but i could be wrong. I was hoping Garrett Hedlund would play finnick. Or alex Pettyfer :/


Taggerung You're not alone. Garrett Hedlund should play Finnick. I won't die if its Alex Pettyfer (not that it will be since he says he won't be doing anymore YA adaptions), but Sam.....when the official casting come out...if its Sam....I will literally start a petition against it.


Andrea Calaway I actually really like Garrett Hedlund as an actor and I think he would do a great job as the strong, charismatic Finnick. I'm hoping Pettyfer isn't cast because he doesn't seem to have enough personality for this role.


Kezia Alex once said that he didn't want to acted in YA movie adaptation so it's very unlikely for him to play Finnick
Too bad it is already confirmed that Sam Claflin will be playing as Finnick. Personally, I will say no. Cause I never imagine Finnick like that...

Check this out:
http://www.mtv.co.uk/news/the-hunger-...


Taggerung It's just rumors. Lionsgate has an official cast list posted for the cast members they've done so far. Finnick hasn't been done yet.

http://www.lionsgatepublicity.com/


Kezia Phew. At least he's still not officially casted.
I just hope they won't ruin Finnick or other charcters in the movie


message 18: by Eban (new) - rated it 5 stars

Eban O'Sullivan At the moment, with the change of director, I am not to sure about this movie. It will hopefully live up to it's hype, but I have my doubts. As for the role of Finnick, Any-one who I wouldn't want to have their
[SPOILER ALERT]
head ripped off I'm fine with.


message 19: by l (new) - rated it 5 stars

l It's not official, but I'm not too disappointed with it.

I anyone really knows what to feel about him though, since he just kind of popped into the rumors so quickly.


message 20: by Joe (new) - rated it 4 stars

Joe Gibson It's official now! Sam Claflin is Finnick according to the official facebook page!!


message 21: by [deleted user] (new)

He isnt good or bad :/


message 22: by Taggerung (last edited Aug 22, 2012 12:19PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Taggerung NOOOOOOO!!!!! Sam Claflin is officially Finnick! DX lionsgate announced it today...


message 23: by [deleted user] (new)

:P


Allison I dont have a problem with Sam C. Just please dont let it be that Alex P. Just from seeing interviews of him....I dont get all the craze


Nicki I would be curious to see their auditions. I found myself not thinking that Peeta "looked" the part at first in the first movie, but then I think he did a great job. They did good in casting with the first one, so I trust that they are picking the best person for the part, even if their look isn't what everyone thinks it should be. I think once we see him act and get in character that he will be great in transforming into the hunky Finnick that we know :)


Karina I'm furious -__________- I wanted Zac Effron to be Finnick. He was perfect. His hair, eyes and tan. Not to built but muscular and perfect for Finnick. I'm extremely angry because Sam doesn't look handsome enough and he is to scrawny to play him.
Finnick is the most gorgeous, sexiest person in the fictional world. Therefore, should DEFIANTLY not be played by Sam C.


message 27: by Nicki (last edited Aug 22, 2012 12:56PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Nicki Karina wrote: "I'm furious -__________- I wanted Zac Effron to be Finnick. He was perfect. His hair, eyes and tan. Not to built but muscular and perfect for Finnick. I'm extremely angry because Sam doesn't look h..."

Funny, because I don't think Zac Effron is the most gorgeous, sexiest person to play Finnick in the fictional world. I find Sam much sexier. "Sexiness" is subjective, and I really think that his acting will have to pull it off well. Just like when you know someone who, on the outside it beautiful but is a real b*tch? Suddenly they are hideous. Same for vice versa. Someone you are not initially attracted to could be the most amazing person (like Peeta's character in the first movie, who I wasn't attracted to at first). I saw Sam in Pirates and fell in love with his character. Hopefully everyone will give him a chance.


message 28: by Gaby (new) - rated it 5 stars

Gaby I'm 50/50 w/ Sam...Finnick is supposed to be good looking, and Sam is...good that he is English, but I don't kno...,I feel as though somethings of about him....I mean that he won't fit Finnick's role....Tom Felton woud be great for the part...good looking, and he's British, but he does a killer American accent so I would make him American...yip I like Tom better for the part.


Hailey I don't really think I like the idea oh him being Finnick because I amagoned him te sexy flattering funny guy I just can't see him like that. Sure Sam's pretty handsome but not like the Finnick I've been thinking about


Teresa ϮAʛʛⅇℛʊℵʛ {J-Hutch's GF} wrote: "It's just rumors. Lionsgate has an official cast list posted for the cast members they've done so far. Finnick hasn't been done yet.

http://www.lionsgatepublicity.com/"



Yes, it's official. Or at least they cast Sam Claflin as Finnick on IMDB.


Taggerung Imdb is not official for casting cuz its user updated and a bunch of people put who they want, not who was cast, even before casting is announced. Lionsgate is the one making the movie so I trust them lol. So now imdb is actually accurate.


Taggerung Teresa wrote: "ϮAʛʛⅇℛʊℵʛ {J-Hutch's GF} wrote: "It's just rumors. Lionsgate has an official cast list posted for the cast members they've done so far. Finnick hasn't been done yet.

http://www.lionsgatepublicity...."


I posted that before he was cast when it was still just rumors lol, not after.


Teresa ϮAʛʛⅇℛʊℵʛ {J-Hutch's GF} wrote: "Teresa wrote: "ϮAʛʛⅇℛʊℵʛ {J-Hutch's GF} wrote: "It's just rumors. Lionsgate has an official cast list posted for the cast members they've done so far. Finnick hasn't been done yet.

http://www.lion..."



Yes, up at the top it says plain as day: Sam Claflin cast as Finnick.


Taggerung I know it says that. But this thread was started before he was cast, not after.


Teresa Oh. Well, I think Sam Claflin is Handsome and he probably will make a fine Finnick.


Shula Great. Now it's official.


message 37: by Jo (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jo Well...well...he's sweet, that's as far as he'll go in my list.


message 38: by Judy (new) - rated it 5 stars

Judy The Half-Blood wrote: "No, you're not. I wanted Alex Pettyfer. He looks just like I imagined Finnick."

No, I think Alex wouldn't have fit.


Kay Marie I was hoping for Garrett H. Because I really liked his acting skills. And yes Sam Claflin is the official movie Finnick. I agree that Alex Pettyfer would have been horrible as Finnick. He may have the looks, but he is not a good actor, especially trying to do an American accent, awful. But I really hope that Sam C. will surprise us and make us fall in love with whatever way he presents Finnick. I'm pretty sure we all have some high standards...


Sierra I don't think anyone they could've picked to play Finnick would have made most of us happy, to be honest.


message 41: by [deleted user] (new)

sure sam is good looking but i like alex petyfer better and i dont even know who the other guy is and i dont think its offical yet that sam claffin is going to be finnick


message 42: by [deleted user] (new)

who other than alex petyfer were going to play finnick


message 43: by l (new) - rated it 5 stars

l It is official. It's on Lionsgate's website:

http://www.lionsgatepublicity.com/epk...


message 44: by [deleted user] (new)

I haven't seen a single actor in my life that I think would fit the role of Finnick. He's such an amazing character it is hard to find someone who would be good.


Shannyn w/e you guys will probably all love him and probably be running a blog about him next year.


Hulou Catalina *The Cat Herself* wrote: "I haven't seen a single actor in my life that I think would fit the role of Finnick. He's such an amazing character it is hard to find someone who would be good."

I agree. And I still think we haven't found him yet :(
Sam isn't the guy I don't think. But oh well


message 47: by S.J (new) - rated it 5 stars

S.J he can go to hell he looks nothing like finnick is supposed to look!


message 48: by Cody (new) - rated it 5 stars

Cody You are not alone! I mean, he's good looking, but I just don't see it. I've tried and I just can't. Kinda like I tried to root for Gale and couldn't. PEETNISS FOREVER! Haha.


message 49: by May (new) - rated it 5 stars

May No, you're not the only one. He looks like nothing I imagined him. He's good looking, but not god-like like Finnick supposed to be.
But, he deserves the benefit of the doubt, right? So I'm giving him a chance, and if he screws Finnick up, I am going to kill him personally.
But Lionsgates did a great job on the casting, so I guess we'll just have to trust them.


Chris Yeah, but i thought he would look stronger, hopfully he will work out hard before the movie. he has to look like he can carry an old lady and a teenager on his shoulders, if not i will be dissopointed...]:


« previous 1
back to top